I've enjoyed all of M Night's movies, although I think The Village was his weakest effort yet.
His movies are never about the action going on but rather the consequences of the action.
Signs was more about faith than anything dealing with aliens. The majority of the scenery in that movie was filmed about 2 miles from my home in Bucks County, PA.
As a rental, The Village is worth watching.
His new film, The Lady in the Water is due out later this year.
The one homage to Hitchcock I wish he would dump is his cameo in every one of his movies. It's really annoying and disruptful to his plots.