tailgater
Tuesday, May 2, 2006 5:48:00 AM
Look at the context: They are lazy regarding their will to make things better in Mexico. It's lazy to take the easy way out. Coming here illegally is easier than staying and fixing the problem. Or at least to make the attempt to fix it. Hence, Lazy.

I thought that was clear.

teedubbya
Tuesday, May 2, 2006 5:50:00 AM
#40 was for you rug.

Generally speaking broad statements about a large class of people are not true. Mexicans are lazy is a stereotype based on ignorance.

The only true generalizations are that the French are cowards and the Canadians are to blame for everything bad n the western hemesphere if not the world.

teedubbya
Tuesday, May 2, 2006 5:51:00 AM
sorry. I looked at it in context and its not true.
tailgater
Tuesday, May 2, 2006 5:57:00 AM
TW, Post 39 is pretty good.

But when America was in the Depression, it affected the WHOLE country. Mexico has some fairly prosperous areas. It would make sense to harness that wealth, and to better utilize their great natural resources. America 1920 didn't have that as an option.

The scenarios are only similar on the surface.

As for beggars?

You always hear the story of beggars wanting money, and not food. I saw it first hand while in CA on vacation. A couple came out of the Calif Pizza Kitchen (they were new back then) and gave the guy a doggie bag. When they turned the corner, he threw it in the trash and asked us for money.

I told him to stick the pizza up his ass and crawl back into his hole.

But I'm colorful like that...

teedubbya
Tuesday, May 2, 2006 5:58:00 AM
I'm just going by your words, and the context in which I (and evidently others) read them.

Lets just say, I don't see things as simply as you.

Lets for a moment accept you meant they are not motivated enough to affect political\social change. Do you really think it is just that simple? Look away from Mexico and at much of the rest of the world. That tag could be hung on large populaitons of the world.

Is it just a coincidence that a common stereotype of Mexicans is lazyness? You just happened to chose that term even though you were speaking in a much more pure intelectual context.

Similar to if you had said you want to drop chicken and watermelon into the inner cities to appease the masses and later said it was in the context of you want to feed the masses through redistribution of wealth.

I don't accept the coinidence or the spin after the fact.

teedubbya
Tuesday, May 2, 2006 6:00:00 AM
some parts of the country did ok during the depression.

I never give beggers money, but I do give to the food bank and the shelter and prepare meals every now and then for a downtown church outreach program.

tailgater
Tuesday, May 2, 2006 6:05:00 AM
"Generally speaking broad statements about a large class of people are not true." What about when people refer to the illegals as "hard working"?

"Mexicans are lazy is a stereotype based on ignorance." Most stereotypes are based on truth, but are perpetuated by ignorance. I don't think Mexican being lazy is a stereotype at all. I think they are more often than not refered to as "hard workers", but that is based more on their econmic status than their heritage. Most poor people are hard workers (perhaps because they have to be), at least until they sip from the sweet nectar of welfare..

teedubbya
Tuesday, May 2, 2006 6:05:00 AM
re 44

Here is where I become a hypocrit.

I'm not a big fan of redistribution of wealth. I don't want to be taxed more so someone else can have a part of my earnings. Taxes are for roads, national defense, and law and order.

But even if I was. How difficult is it for the have nots to force the haves to share. Not necessarlily give, but even the playing field.

Those areas in Mexico with wealth will fight that tooth and nail. And much like a challanger fighting an encumbant in this country, the success rate is low.

There are states in theis country that are perpetually poor and perpetually rich.

teedubbya
Tuesday, May 2, 2006 6:08:00 AM
lazyness is actually a traditinal common stereotype of mexicans.

hard working is actually the anti stereotype concocted after the lazy label.

both are false.

Ask one of your friends about siestas sometime. Kind of interesting.

tailgater
Tuesday, May 2, 2006 6:12:00 AM
The problem is they haven't even tried to correct things in Mexico. They simply come over here.

It's much easier to do so.

If I said "lazy" without any qualifiers, then you'd be correct. But it's part of a much longer rant, and it's not simply coincidence that it fits in with my main point.

We don't have to agree on this issue. But I know what I meant.

tailgater
Tuesday, May 2, 2006 6:15:00 AM
I think "lazy" is a stereotype thrown in front of any minority group. I don't recall it being used specifically for Mexicans.

As for siestas, I like the concept. Much of Europe used to take long lunch breaks to have their big dinner and long nap.

They didn't have to work in the heat of the noon hour, and they came back to work refreshed.

I like siestas, but much prefer fiestas.

teedubbya
Tuesday, May 2, 2006 6:22:00 AM
lazy mexicans and siestas are attached unfortunately. And lazy is a common stereotype of mexicans.

I'm not much of an expert on the thing but I have a friend that gets pissed if you suggest seiestas are part of being lazy.

I think you are right in part that heat has something to do with it, but I think a big mid day meal and the fact they worked dawn to dusk had something to do with it as well.

teedubbya
Tuesday, May 2, 2006 6:26:00 AM
Its cool TG we don't have to agree. If I agreed with you all the time I wouldn't like you because you would be too much like me.