Some cigars, like the Partagas 150, are a one time release (although they have now released the new Partagas 160), so you know when you see one that it is from that original batch. If you can find them now, they are probably $40 to $60 and more per cigar.
The Dunhill Collection was a CI buyout of inventory from the Dunhill retail cigar stores. When Dunhill closed the stores they sold off the stock and CI (and CBid) bought some or all of it. The ads at CI and the lots on CBid were described as old in their lot and sales descriptions.
John has given you, in his usual shorthand way, some things to look for in aged stock. A lot of boxes will have a date stamp on them. Sometimes a band will have changed and you will see cigars in a store with the old band.
The best indicator is the color of the cello on the cigar. Cloudy or milky looking, yellowed, or sometimes, in really old cigars, the cello will become golden or almost bronze colored.
If you are lucky the cigars will have "plumed" with what looks like powdered sugar or small crystals visible on the wrapper.
Not all plumed cigars are really old, however. Some cigars, like Ashton VSGs, will sometimes come from the factory with plume already on them due to their factory aging and a type of wrapper that is more prone to plume.
Usually you will need to rely on the word of the retailer on the age of cigars and then try to verify it by looking for the signs that John and I have described.
Kaz