topper7788
Saturday, November 4, 2006 8:39:00 AM
Doc,

"Since the issue is Iraq, we'll let the red herring of Somolia fall like the dead, stinking fish it is."

Yes I agree, we should never bring up Somalia as for one thing it makes the previous administration look bad! Wouldn't want and do that when were so good at picking on the current one....

Dr Pepperhill
Saturday, November 4, 2006 8:48:00 AM
I'm not picking on anyone Topper, just trying to direct the focus to the problem at hand, and away from the misdirection and uselessness of blaming Clinton for an issue that legitimately falls in Bush's lab.

People often as "were there now. It doesn't matter how or why we got there."

Crying about Clinton won't save any lives, but knowck yourself out if it makes you feel better.

topper7788
Saturday, November 4, 2006 8:58:00 AM
Doc,

Doesn't make me feel better! I feel fine, you?

Divert? Not trying to divert anything.. Just making a statement that you don't agree with.....Actually that is like most of my statements (the you don't agree part)

Dr Pepperhill
Saturday, November 4, 2006 9:07:00 AM
Glad to gear you're feeling ok, but what about Iraq? Did you even read post# 58? If so, what are your thoughts?
HockeyDad
Saturday, November 4, 2006 9:07:00 AM
There is no problem in Iraq. Philadelphia is more dangerous than Baghdad.
topper7788
Saturday, November 4, 2006 9:24:00 AM
Doc,

"Did you even read post# 58"

Yes, and you don't want or would agree with my thoughts. But the short version is... Let the military fight.

It is my understanding (I could be wrong) that the current rules of engagement greatly hinder our forces and put our men at a terrible disadvantage.

I believe our current ROE states that our guys unless they make a POSITIVE id on a shooter cannot return fire.

example: our guys see 4 men running away from a bombing, if they did not see them actually set off the bomb they cannot fire or even fire warning shots for them to stop.

Our guys are in a "police action" not the best situation for us to fight from. Our guys are trained to return fire in overpowering way, but unless engaged in a direct fire fight with the enemy they cannot do this for fear of "collateral damage".

Our guys take casualties to protect Iraq's civilians... And god help one of our young soldiers who makes a mistake. Wouldn't want CNN to find out about that!!

I have no problem with the war, I don't like the way we are fighting it!!

You wouldn't like my solution because I think we should let our men do what they were trained for or get them the hell out of there.. But thats another issue because I don't believe we can leave yet under any circumstances...

Does that answer your question?

Dr Pepperhill
Saturday, November 4, 2006 9:29:00 AM
No. I'm not following your thinking Topper. Are you suggesting the military take over the duties of secretary of defense and commander in chief temporarily? That would be unique. Are you saying to allow a specific general in Iraq take over and implement the US military there? If so, which general? I'm not folklowing you at all. When you say "let the military fight" are you agreeing with option "A" in post # 58. What about the caveats I mentioned to persuing option "A", could there be any longer term negative remifications to that path which might hurt Americans?

I think option B is the more plausible course at this juncture in the conflict.

topper7788
Saturday, November 4, 2006 9:42:00 AM
Doc,

I'm a simple guy, I believe when you decide to commit troops you call in your generals. Give them the objective and the rules of engagement. Then ask them how, when and what they need to do the job. If they tell you we need x,y,and z and we can so it in this amount of time. If they say under the limits you are giving us we cannot do the job we should not commit troops to action. If the military says it can do the job with what is given and within the ROE, then it is time to let them do there job and fight the action.

The military should plan out and then carryout the action once approved by the powers to be. Then its the powers to be job to put the proper spin and sell it to us...

Again, I told you I am a simple guy.

I don't have the answer you seek, nor is it my responsibility to come up with one.

We voted for the guy to make those decisions, now we have to let them do what they get paid for. If we don't like what he does we get the chance every 4 years to fire him and get someone else.

Guess we are not going to solve the war issue this week on this board?