I've only had a few, but from my limited statistical sampling, I would agree on the age factor. The first couple I tried were fresh. They were good, but didn't give me fireworks. Last summer I smoked the Petite Lancero I'd kept around for two years and it was fantastic. Sweetness, leather, spice, cedar, all distinct and changing. I wouldn't buy a box at MSRP, but I would definitely pony up for a handful.