poohkitty7
Wednesday, June 6, 2007 3:21:00 AM
I would welcome some opinions on some of the cheaper boxes. I was of the opinion the you get what you pay for..... am I wrong?? Any suggestions.
andytv
Wednesday, June 6, 2007 4:27:00 AM
In MY opinion, the cheaper ones and the midrange ones are all about the same.....veneer over pressboard with Spanish cedar lining.

Kinda like ceiling fans.......the real expensive ones are just as crappily made as the cheap ones.

engletl
Wednesday, June 6, 2007 4:28:00 AM
Do a search on coolerdor, tuperdor etc

Then decide if you want RH Beads or the less expensive kitty litter(again you can search for these)

IMO that is the way to go.

That is unless the spouse doesn't want to see those type of humis.

Todd

Odylic
Wednesday, June 6, 2007 4:36:00 AM
what ever you decide on, just double the size right off the bat... or go for a tower... that way you should hopefullly have enough room for your future purchases/trades. Haven't had any trouble with the ones I have won here (ranging in size from 20 to 300 capacity)
ubsplat
Wednesday, June 6, 2007 4:41:00 AM
My advice is if you're at all serious about the hobby, invest a little bit more up front and get a bigger one that you like (figure 300-500 sticks). Otherwise as your storage evolves you'll end up with a melange of humidors and rotating stock and rehumidifying will be something of a pain. A coolerdor will also work, it has a lot of advantages, but some (read spouses usually) don't think they're aesthetically pleasing. This is advice I should have heeded years ago as I've got the melange of humidors now to maintain. Good Luck!
Cybus
Wednesday, June 6, 2007 6:39:00 AM
I started with a 20 count, then another 20 and another, Now i have to maintain humidity in 7 smaller humidors rather than one or maybe two larger ones.
SteveS
Wednesday, June 6, 2007 7:13:00 AM
=======================================

Author: poohkitty7 Date: 06/06/2007 07:21 AM

I would welcome some opinions on some of the

cheaper boxes. I was of the opinion the you get

what you pay for

=======================================

Inexpensive and cheap are not necessarily synonymous ... you can get a quality humidor at a good price and you can pay $$$ for junk ...

One of my best humidors is one I paid $10 for at an estate sale where the guy said "oh, that used to be a cigar humidor, but it's missing its' dials ... maybe you could give it to your wife for a jewelry box" ... I didn't trouble him with the info that I didn't give a rats' patootie about the 'dials' ... it's a sweet little box that holds rock-solid RH ...

I also got a 300ct 'dor that was advertised on a 'scratch and dent' sale ... paid less than $100 for it and have seen it sold all over creation for half again to double what I paid ... and I've never seen whatever the scratch or dent was that caused it to be sold inexpensively ... it too holds rock-solid RH

you can get any number of high-quality humidors right here on CBid for prices far lower than you'd pay elsewhere ... and they'll give you a lifetime of good service ...

Sure, you can pay big bucks for something somewhere else, but bottom line is, if it does a good job of preserving and aging your cigars, what more value are you going to derive from it?

SteveR@CigarBid
Wednesday, June 6, 2007 8:07:00 AM
A humidor is simply a box 'programmed' to store cigars at a desired humidity level. You do most of the programming. So long as an optimum seal is provided, just about anything can become a humidor. Whether it is and empty cigar box, Tupperware, Coleman coolers, or an actual manufactured humidor.

Humidors are made with a few things in mind: interior wood, organization, optimum seal, and aesthetics. Most humidors are lined with Spanish cedar. Your very high end humidors are often lined with mahogany. Spanish cedar is predominantly used because of the pleasant aroma it provides, which will influence your cigars (in a good way) over a significant period of time. Mahogany is actually better for storing cigars, as it is more efficient at holding and releasing humidity, in order to maintain a more stable environment. However, mahogany is far from necessary.

Humidors are no different from cigars. Price means nothing. As long as a humidor is well built and provides an optimum seal, it will do just fine. After all, the majority of storage problems are a direct result of the owner...not properly seasoning the humidor, not paying attention to the humidor or its contents over significant periods of time, failing to calibrate the hygrometer regularly, etc. Each of the humidors we sell are proven winners, as each is well made from some of the industry's top humidor manufacturers.

That said, there is really no reason to spend hundreds, or even thousands, of dollars for a small, 50-capacity humidor. For this reason, we do not carry certain brands, such as Eli Blu or Davidoff. Personally, I cannot justify paying that much for a desktop humidor, seeing as something which costs considerably rest does the same exact job, just as well.

ATLS4
Wednesday, June 6, 2007 8:21:00 AM
I'm on my 3rd humidor which is a H.Upmann 160th Anniversary humidor that holds ~160 cigars. It replaced a 50-stick no-named, mid-quality box that I had for gotten as a present years ago. I plan on eventually building a tower or chest humidor that can support 500 sticks at some point but I want something that is for apperance as well as the actual function of keeping cigars.

With that said, I would agree with the rest of the posters here. Go with a much larger capacity humi than you're thinking of currently so you can grow into it. A decent 50-100 stick box shouldn't run you that much but to budget money to replace the hydrometer and humidification device. As long as your box has a nice tight seal and Spanish cedar or Mahogany you're in good shape. The rest is for show....

Thunder.Gerbil
Wednesday, June 6, 2007 8:21:00 AM
^^^

Awwwwh, come on Steve.

Doesn't everybody need a Davidoff 20-ct Carbon-Fiber reinforced, zircon-encrusted, 24kt. gold plated, Kevlar humidor assembled by virgins for the low, low, everday price of $1195.95?

It even comes with a free cup of Zino's famous $40/cup vintage chicken noodle soup, $12 spoon and $3 napkin.

GreenWolf70
Thursday, June 7, 2007 8:46:00 AM
I picked up this one:

http://www.cigarsinternational.com/prodDisp.asp?item=M-MTHUM6&cat=10 

on CBid for $28 a month or so ago and it is better built than anything I have seen for $200 of less. It comes without a humidifier or hygrometer, but the box is really tight and holds humidity very well. I keep my ready smokes in it and I especially like the glass top. Also the box is very large for a 40 ct humi. It is actually larger than the 75 ct. generic cherry box it replaced.

Thunder.Gerbil
Thursday, June 7, 2007 8:50:00 AM
^^

GW70,

Does the divider move or is it fixed in place?

jojoc
Sardious
Thursday, June 7, 2007 9:35:00 AM
I have a few small humidors for fun and a few for at work small like the 20 count humidors that you get for way cheap but still look good and make the word desk look better. They work as good as my fancy 400 count. Also I started getting some of those ones you see here on CI like the ones that are names after various brands like ACID and Perdomo, and indian and such, all about the same size just different art on top but I have a few now and for a small count box they work exelent, and some like the perdomo and both RP's have great art work too. I have the perdomo and it looks better in person than in the picture on the web site. The acid one sells higher here at Cbit, many Drew estate fans out there I guess and the one with the lady on fron sells higher too but they work great and you can get them cheap here