A humidor is simply a box 'programmed' to store cigars at a desired humidity level. You do most of the programming. So long as an optimum seal is provided, just about anything can become a humidor. Whether it is and empty cigar box, Tupperware, Coleman coolers, or an actual manufactured humidor.
Humidors are made with a few things in mind: interior wood, organization, optimum seal, and aesthetics. Most humidors are lined with Spanish cedar. Your very high end humidors are often lined with mahogany. Spanish cedar is predominantly used because of the pleasant aroma it provides, which will influence your cigars (in a good way) over a significant period of time. Mahogany is actually better for storing cigars, as it is more efficient at holding and releasing humidity, in order to maintain a more stable environment. However, mahogany is far from necessary.
Humidors are no different from cigars. Price means nothing. As long as a humidor is well built and provides an optimum seal, it will do just fine. After all, the majority of storage problems are a direct result of the owner...not properly seasoning the humidor, not paying attention to the humidor or its contents over significant periods of time, failing to calibrate the hygrometer regularly, etc. Each of the humidors we sell are proven winners, as each is well made from some of the industry's top humidor manufacturers.
That said, there is really no reason to spend hundreds, or even thousands, of dollars for a small, 50-capacity humidor. For this reason, we do not carry certain brands, such as Eli Blu or Davidoff. Personally, I cannot justify paying that much for a desktop humidor, seeing as something which costs considerably rest does the same exact job, just as well.