Haven't tried many of those listed above, but my current top ten are:
Perdomo Estate Selection Monstro Maduro
Padilla Obsidian
CAO Gold Maduro Robusto
Perdomo Reserve Maduro (Red Label) V, X and C
CAO Brazilia Gol
Padilla Signature 1932 Torp
Saint Luis Rey Serie G Maduro Short Robusto
El Rico Habano Maduro
Saint Luis Rey Maduro Belicosa
Tie: CAO Gold Robusto and RP Connie
Honorable Mentions:
PD Series II
5 Vegas Apocalypse
Triple Ligero X3
Padilla Achilles
RP Vintage 1990
Padilla Hybrid
Gran Habano #3 Habano All
Perdomo Lot #23 Maduro
CI Legends Purple (GrayCliff)
El Mejor Expresso Torpedo
Untried but resting in Humidor:
CAO Black VR Totem
Gurkha X-Furte
REO Rubusto
Nording Torp
Juan Lopez Epicure #2
Opus X Belicosa
Don Pepin JJ
Don Pepin Blue
601 Serie Connie
I guess I just like a lot of cigars and I am constantly trying new ones.