Here's some of the ones that I've had recently. There are others, but frankly, I've forgotten what they tasted like.
Heavy chocolate-flavored / maduro sticks:
1) El Mejor Expresso
2) Nestor Reserve
3) Belinda Black
4) El Rico Habano
5) Indian Tabac Super Fuerte
6) Gurkha X-Fuerte
7) Cuba Libre Honduran Maduro.
Heavy chocolate-flavored / peppery:
1) Partagas Black
2) 5 Vegas "A"
3) La Gloria Cubana Maduro
Moderately Chocolatey / earthy / toasty:
1) Ancient Warrior (Yellow Band)
2) Hoyo de Monterrey Excalibur 1066
3) Rocky Patel Vintage (1992?)
4) Romeo y Julieta Viejo
5) Sancho Panza Double Maduro
6) Tierra del Sol
7) Santa Rosa
8) Cu*Avana Maduro
9) Matacan.
The reason why I included three different categories is that the proportion of that chocolatey / sweet flavor you're tasting is in large part due to the wrapper. Generally, when you move down ring sizes, the flavor of the wrapper is predominant in the flavor. I usually smoke larger ring cigars (48+), so I'll usually get a better mix of overall flavors. So, taking the last category, and scaling down the ring size might give you a little more of what you're looking for.
I think most people here would agree that the El Mejor Expresso is EXACTLY what you're looking for, and they're very reasonably priced. My only suggestion is that you dry-box them prior to smoking, as they are a vary oily cigar, and they WILL burn poorly.