Swimmer here. Gave football and soccer a try. I was too short to make much out of football. They really weren't into 5'7" football players back then...even running backs. But we had a crappy HS team so it didn't matter.
I was a great goalie at soccer, unfortunately my teammate and 1st string goalie was a guy who ended up playing on a collegiate championship team and went on to play for Chile and Panama. Kind of hard to shine when your teammate is made of chrome.
Swimming was my forte'. I had a fun time, did well...never challenged Mark Spitz' records at the time, but I had some fun.
Still play some softball, biking, golf. No nagging injuries from the past...just new ones.