Lost In The Smoke
Skip directly to the full story.
By BILLY HOUSE The Tampa Tribune
Published: Aug 1, 2007
WASHINGTON - There's a dilemma wafting over Tampa Bay area members of Congress in the battle over expanding children's health care.
To help pay for expansion of the State Children's Health Insurance Program, known as S-CHIP, congressional committees are proposing jumps in the cigar tax from about a nickel a cigar to as much as $10 a stogie.
For most politicians nationally, it may be shrewd to frame this issue as pitting the health needs of children and others against depictions of cigar-chomping fat cats.
However, many Florida lawmakers, worried over such a dramatic hit on an industry so historically linked to Tampa and their state, want to snuff out the proposed cigar-tax increase. Debate on the Senate's S-CHIP bill began Monday, and votes on the Senate and House bills could come this week.
Democratic U.S. Rep. Kathy Castor of Tampa says she includes herself as among those concerned over the proposed cigar-tax increase.
Castor doesn't hesitate when asked how she plans to vote if it comes down to a choice between S-CHIP expansion paid partly with a cigar-tax increase or no expansion of the program.
"Children's health care comes first," Castor says.
Democratic U.S. Sen. Bill Nelson, another long-time supporter of expanding the S-CHIP program, would make the same choice, say his aides.
Nelson on Tuesday also was pushing the Senate Finance Committee to change, "what appears to be a heavy-handed tax on just one consumer item," said Nelson spokesman Dan McLaughlin.
Local cigarmakers couldn't agree more.
"This is the 'Let's put the Tampa cigar industry out of business' tax," warns Eric Newman, president of the J.C. Newman Cigar Co. and president of the Cigar Manufacturers Association of Tampa.
Tax Might Increase 20,000%
The moves in the House and Senate to raise the federal cigar tax are just the latest of long-time legislative efforts to discourage smoking.
Compared with the roughly $85 billion in retail cigarette sales nationally last year, cigar sales totaled about $3 billion.
Although representing such a small portion of tobacco sales, some lawmakers and health officials have argued cigars have been given essentially a free ride on taxes for too long.
In the House, lawmakers are seeking to help increase the federal S-CHIP funding by $50 billion partly by raising the 5-cent-a-cigar tax to 44.6 percent of the manufacturers cost, capping the tax on a single cigar at $1.
Going from a tax of 5 cents a cigar to $1 represents a 2,000 percent increase.
That's small compared to the current Senate proposal. It would increase S-CHIP funding by $35 billion partly by raising the 5-cent a cigar tax to 53 percent of the manufacturers cost, with the cap being $10 a cigar.
Going from a 5-cent tax on a cigar to $10 a cigar would represent a 20,000 percent increase.
More than just a dramatic increase, those in the cigar industry say such proposals would have dire consequences for cigar manufacturers in West Tampa, Ybor City and elsewhere in Florida, particularly Miami, many of them small mom-and-pop shops.
Thousands Of Jobs At Risk
Newman said as many as 1,500 cigarmaking jobs could be at stake in Tampa, and several thousand others in Florida, where 80 percent of the cigars made in the country are manufactured.
Newman said that doesn't count the effect on the nearly 4,000 specialty smoke shops in the United States, or tens of thousands of jobs in other countries.
"I am personally supportive of providing health insurance for children of those who can't afford it," Newman said. "Double it to 10 cents - I won't like it, but don't increase it 2,000 or even 20,000 percent."
Congresswoman In Tough Position
Newman said he has talked to Castor and that she understands, "Tampa is the cigar city, and that people know Kathy Castor represents the cigar city of the United States."
Castor remains one of the most vocal proponents of expanding the children's health program.
For Castor, the expansion of the program to 3 million more children who do not quite qualify for Medicaid, "is one of the reasons I ran for Congress."
As for the tax implications on an industry important to her district, Castor said, "We're working on it [to lessen the impact on the cigar industry.] If we can make it more equitable, we will."
Other lawmakers representing the area simply want the cigar-tax plan to go up in smoke.
"We don't like it," said Kern Lundberg, a spokesman for Florida's Republican U.S. Sen. Mel Martinez. Martinez "thinks it's excessive and unfair and unduly penalizes a Florida industry."
The issue could come to a head this week. Both houses of Congress are set to act on their respective bills.
Passage of either the House or Senate bills is not a done deal. They have some way to go before either becomes law.
Veto Threat
One major hurdle: President Bush has warned that he would veto any bill that includes more than $5 billion in new S-CHIP funding.
Congressional conservatives such as Rep. Adam Putnam of Bartow are ready to wage floor battles over the S-CHIP expansion.
Putnam complains it would represent a significant increase in the scope, cost and mission of a program that was not created as an entitlement, such as Medicaid, but could soon very much mirror one.
Putnam says there's another reason for his opposition.
As now written, Putnam said these bills "would have a uniquely negative impact on the city of Tampa and the 1,000-plus jobs that are involved in our legendary cigar manufacturing industry."
Reporter Billy House can be reached at (202) 662-7673 or [email protected].