pacman357
Tuesday, August 7, 2007 4:58:00 PM
Got some RP SG seconds. They go by a slightly different name, but they are sold as basically SG seconds. Ordered up a bundle of torpedos on a special. Wish I had ordered more, as it's not often you find RP SG torps for less than $2 per (deal ended already, so don't ask--although hey Steve, how about bringing those on board here?).

What I don't get is how they are seconds. Looked like the regular SG's, smelled, smoked and tasted like the regulars. Veining in the wrapper appears a bit heavy, but I don't have one of the regular SG's to compare it to, and that may be normal. Otherwise, I couldn't see any possible way to determine these are somehow defective. Burn was nearly perfect OTT, and the fairly beefy torpedo took me about 80 minutes to smoke, whereas most torps take me just about an hour.

This has me wondering, does anyone know if some cigar makers sell seconds as a way to get rid of excess stock? Either they aimed too high with the price, maybe just flat-out made too many, whatever. Perhaps some expert could tell me why these were seconds, but other than missing a band (which I don't mind in the least, especially at that price), I can't see a reason these were selling as seconds.

Love the RP SG's. If the first one OTT is any indication (and a visual inspection of the rest of the bundle tells me it may well be), I would jump on a similar deal next time I see one. Especially if I can get them for around $98 less than CI's price, sans box and bands.

BTW, I've picked up some seconds here that had some cosmetic blemishes and whatnot but tasted fine, while other seconds from this site or CI made me wonder how they made it to seconds status, too.

andytv
Tuesday, August 7, 2007 5:00:00 PM
I smoke the Vintage 90 seconds.........top notch.
8trackdisco
Tuesday, August 7, 2007 5:04:00 PM
Pac,

Those are GREAT smokes, aren't they? The RPFS is just short of edible. I bought a bundle two weeks before the bastid put them on sale.

If this SCIHP tax passes, I'm getting four bundles of those bad boys and ride out the storm.

8trackdisco
Tuesday, August 7, 2007 5:05:00 PM
The Factory Selects are better than the Seconds, but both are gooood.

pacman357
Tuesday, August 7, 2007 5:49:00 PM
#3 True dat. I thought the first was fantastic and I can't see any visible problems with the rest. Thick, chewy smoke with a lot of character. I tried to get some before but they were out. Wish I had known just how damned good they are. I can't believe I paid less than $1.95 per stick. Almost feels like a crime or something.
pacman357
Tuesday, August 7, 2007 5:50:00 PM
#2 BTW, I've got some of those, too. Quite good and seem to get even better with a little age and TLC.
bsevern
Tuesday, August 7, 2007 6:41:00 PM
I also have the RP SG and Vintage seconds, and I can never tell any physical or palatable differences from their non-second counterparts, but my wallet sees a major difference.

lou2row
Tuesday, August 7, 2007 6:44:00 PM
"Almost feels like a crime or something. "

Do you know a good lawyer?

Plead insanity. You were crazy not to get two bundles at that price!

lou

colinmcfall
Tuesday, August 7, 2007 7:19:00 PM
Have been meaning to try them. Nice to hear a good review.
Charlie
Tuesday, August 7, 2007 7:27:00 PM

RP Seconds are the only seconds that I will bid on, they seem to be almost as good as the normal RP cigars to me.

I have tried other seconds and generally they are dogs with ticks and fleas, but the RP ones are very good

Charlie

pacman357
Tuesday, August 7, 2007 8:09:00 PM
#8 A good one? No. And had I any idea they would be that good, I'd have picked up 3 or 4 bundles.
PDQ
  • PDQ
  • Connoisseur
Wednesday, August 8, 2007 10:57:00 AM
I think almost every manufacturer has cigars that either do not quite measure up, in terms of size, appearance, etc., or simply have more than a given contract calls for.

These are sometimes called "seconds", "overruns", "segundos", "rosados", and so on.

Usually, they smoke and taste the same as the "firsts", though some may have a slightly different flavor. I have enjoyed seconds, also, and they make for a very good, quality smoke for times when you you just want a good, quality smoke, and are not concerned with the label, or appearance.

BrillKill
Thursday, August 9, 2007 1:19:00 AM
never saw the difference. I'm thinking it's just another way to move product without committing to an overall price reduction. The amount of RP's being sold and the amount being "rejected" just can't match up. They are in the top selling 5 of whatever online retailer carries them. Thats a lotta cigars.