"Tell him it is a Cuban and you paid $15 for it. He will most likely say it's the best cigar he has ever had."
I've been in that situation several times. I didn't want to sound like I was sh*tting all over someone's favorite cigar, so I said, "yeah, this is a good cigar." In reality, I thought the cigar sucked...in a way that a sucky cigar has never sucked before.
I ended up getting more of them the next time we met up.
So that prank can backfire in more ways than one...