hoplite
  • hoplite
  • Connoisseur Topic Starter
Friday, August 31, 2007 2:36:00 PM
In the last couple of months I have purchased

Profesor Sila Rothschilde

Don Elias Robusto

Profesor Sila Double Robusto

Flor De Farach Petit Lancero

Centenario Classic Liga B

Profesor Sila Rothschilde

Mantequilla Square-Pressed Maduro

Corona Pueblo Dominicano Series II Belicoso

Don Elias Toro

Astral Aged Ecuadorian

La Invicta Corona

Joya del Jefe Connecticut Toro

Don Rafael

La Vieja Habana Celebracion National

Astral Aged Ecuadorian Robusto

Te-Amo Meditation

Liga IV Almirante

Liga IV Almirante

La Primadora Select Celebration Maduro

Etiqueta Azul Belicoso

R.B. Fundadores Longfellow

Don Felo Petits

Don Elias Churchill

Cremosa Cubana Corona

Gurkha Class Regent Torpedo

Gurkha Castle Hall Churchill

Cibao Toro

Flor De Farach Petit Lancero

Astral Aged Ecuadorian Toro

Ashton Mini Cigarillo

Indian Tabac Limited Reserve Bear -

Jericho by Camacho Robusto

Rocky Patel Connecticut Churchill

Double Happiness by La Aurora Torpedo

Astral Aged Ecuadorian Torpedo

Angel 100 O.T.C.

Perdomo 2 Milenario 'Mistakes' Cameroon

Which ones need aging?

hoplite
  • hoplite
  • Connoisseur Topic Starter
Friday, August 31, 2007 2:40:00 PM
Forgive me, in alphabetical order that would be:

Angel 100 O.T.C.

Ashton Mini Cigarillo

Astral Aged Ecuadorian Robusto

Astral Aged Ecuadorian Toro

Astral Aged Ecuadorian Torpedo

Centenario Classic Liga B

Cibao Toro

Corona Pueblo Dominicano Series II Belicoso

Cremosa Cubana Corona

Don Elias Churchill

Don Elias Robusto

Don Elias Toro

Don Felo Petits

Don Rafael

Double Happiness by La Aurora Torpedo

Etiqueta Azul Belicoso

Flor De Farach Petit Lancero

Gurkha Castle Hall Churchill

Gurkha Class Regent Torpedo

Indian Tabac Limited Reserve Bear -

Jericho by Camacho Robusto

Joya del Jefe Connecticut Toro

La Invicta Corona

La Primadora Select Celebration Maduro

La Vieja Habana Celebracion National

Liga IV Almirante

Mantequilla Square-Pressed Maduro

Perdomo 2 Milenario 'Mistakes' Cameroon

Profesor Sila Double Robusto

Profesor Sila Rothschilde

R.B. Fundadores Longfellow

Rocky Patel Connecticut Churchill

Te-Amo Meditation

jojoc
Friday, August 31, 2007 3:19:00 PM
lol someone has been busy!

I have no clue about aging. My oldest cigars are a little over 2 years. My thoughts on aging is let them age until you feel like smoking them.

Sardious
Friday, August 31, 2007 4:26:00 PM
that super hot 20 year old at the office could age a year so that they can party.

How long have you had etica Azul? I thought they were new, aging may bland them out?

I still say for the most part agining a year or so seems to help most, but I still really dislike what 2 years of aging did to my antanio 1970's

hoplite
  • hoplite
  • Connoisseur Topic Starter
Friday, August 31, 2007 4:32:00 PM
Sardious,

BTW there is no Wiki entry for your name.

The Azuls were an thrill. My first experience w/a flavored cigar aside from some CAO valnillas (which I liked). Not sure what I'm going to do w/the rest of the two bundles of Azuls I've got. Giving them to my brother for Christmas comes to mind.

cgbgjr
Friday, August 31, 2007 9:02:00 PM
I think you should ask the opposite question--which ones _don't_ need aging.

So, look for yellow or brown cellophane. Any with those clearly are ready to smoke.

I would recommend aging all Gurkhas a year to get their full flavor.

The Don Felos will be very spicy now and will mellow out over the course of a year. I prefer them aged, but they are certainly smokeable immediately.

As to the cheapies (and you know which ones they are 🙂 )--most will be totally unsmokeable without a year of age. Some will still be unsmokeable or very bland after you age them so it won't matter.

One that I recognize that ages well imho is the Cremosa. After two years those are pretty decent. It would be a waste to smoke those before a year.

For your next year of purchases how about considering some of my favorites:

--CAO Brazilias--any size

--CAO Blacks--any size

--Camacho 1962s (don't need aging)

--5 Vegas--you can't go wrong with any of them

--Perdomo Reserve La Tradicions--the Champagnes and Maduros are real treats

--Vega Talanga Rojos (don't need aging)

--Alec Bradley Exotic Maduros

--Nestors

If you can handle the Don Felos then try the rest of the Camacho line including the lower cost Jerichos.

BrillKill
Saturday, September 1, 2007 3:58:00 AM
The Profesor Sila definitely need at least a couple of weeks with the cello off. If you have the patience to sit on them for longer they can only get better.

I was looking for a Baccarat alternative and they do indeed fit the bill.

Charlie
Saturday, September 1, 2007 5:20:00 AM
The following need tossing!

Centenario Classic Liga B

Cibao Toro

Cremosa Cubana Corona

Don Elias Churchill

Don Elias Robusto

Don Elias Toro

Don Felo Petits

Don Rafael

Double Happiness

Etiqueta Azul Belicoso

Flor De Farach Petit Lancero

Joya del Jefe Connecticut Toro

Profesor Sila Double Robusto

Profesor Sila Rothschilde

R.B. Fundadores Longfellow

Te-Amo Meditation

Good luck

Charlie

bigbird1227
Saturday, September 1, 2007 5:26:00 AM
Charlie,

What do you mean by tossing?

pgje51
Saturday, September 1, 2007 6:21:00 AM

Salad.

...and things you don't like.

hoplite
  • hoplite
  • Connoisseur Topic Starter
Saturday, September 1, 2007 9:06:00 AM
RE: defending the purchase and smoking of "cheap" cigars

Hey, I'm moving up from White Owls, Dutch Masters, and King Edwards. These are a real improvement for me 🙂

The only cigars I have tossed so far are a couple of bundles of Shakespeares, a house brand for another vendor. Until I tried to smoke those, I didn't even know you could roll dog ****.

GreenWolf70
Saturday, September 1, 2007 9:35:00 AM
The Angels and RB Fundadores will age well, but those and the RP Connies are the only ones I would bother keeping. I agree with Charlie, the rest make good mulch.
rbmbb
Saturday, September 1, 2007 9:44:00 AM
I tend to age the fuller bodied cigars rather than the milder ones...

Whenever I make a purchase(usually a box, or fiver)I smoke one immediately and see if I enjoy it. If I like it right away,I smoke them right away!

If they seem like a little ageing could do them justice, then I age them. Keep track in a little notebook so that you know how long you've had them.(some people actually write on each stick when they were purchased, but I'm not that anal....I mean....I'm not that interested :^) )

R

Charlie
Saturday, September 1, 2007 12:19:00 PM
Big bird,

I mean open the trash can and throw em away! LOL

Charlie

8trackdisco
Saturday, September 1, 2007 5:08:00 PM
'..What needs aging?..'

--------------------------

17 year old girls.

hoplite
  • hoplite
  • Connoisseur Topic Starter
Sunday, September 2, 2007 11:08:00 AM
Re: Defending my cigars,

I expell methane in the general direction of those who say mean things about my cigars.

There isn't a single one of the cigars listed above that isn't a good smoke, and I've smoked at least one of each kind. My ritual is to take each new box and strip and clip all the cigars, then write the month and year on the box and put them in a tupperdor.

Then, when it comes around on the guitar...

hoplite
  • hoplite
  • Connoisseur Topic Starter
Sunday, September 2, 2007 11:14:00 AM
Re: Jericos by Camacho

Got a box. Love 'em. Just bid on three more.

TempestPSO
Sunday, September 2, 2007 1:52:00 PM
I know from experience the Don Elias Age really really well. For an inexpensive cigar you'd be suprised after a few months or a year. I've been somking mine (2 years old) this summer when I'm out golfing and such, I think they are at there peak. Also the Perdomos will show improvement with age.
Thunder.Gerbil
Monday, September 3, 2007 12:12:00 AM
I've either aged some of the cigars on your list myself or heard comments from people who have aged them.

Here's what I remember:

-------------------------------------------------------

AGE WELL:

Angel 100

Centenario Classic

Gurkha Class Regent

Jericho by Camacho

La Vieja Habana

Perdomo 2 Milenario 'Mistakes' Cameroon

Pueblo Dominicano Series II

R.B. Fundadores

-------------------------------------------------------

-------------------------------------------------------

MINOR IMPROVEMENT WITH AGING:

Cibao

Double Happiness by La Aurora

Gurkha Castle Hall

Rocky Patel Connecticut

Te-Amo

-------------------------------------------------------

-------------------------------------------------------

NO IMPROVEMENT NOTED AFTER AGING:

Indian Tabac Limited Reserve

Joya del Jefe Connecticut

Liga IV

-------------------------------------------------------

ALL either IMHO or in the opinion of the person I heard the info from and as always YMMV.

Stickbow
Monday, September 3, 2007 2:53:00 AM
I guess I'm in the minority. I smoke cigars I don't collect them. I smoke Brazilias, Padron Maduros, RP 92 right out of the box.....................

stic