If you are like me, and tend put them down, and forget them, stick to matches, or buy the cheapest lighters in bulk.
If you can hang onto them, there are several reliable (IMO) lighters: Ronson, Colibri, DuPont for butane jet torch lighters. I'd add Zippo, but they only seem to be available in the liquid fuel lighters, and those always turn up empty when you want to use one. The BIC and Cricket lighters are standard flame, rather than torch, so they are more difficult to use when lighting a cigar.
I was always partial to the "strike anywhere" kitchen matches, but I think they stopped making those several years back.