#4 Quite a bit of difference to my taste. The OSGs are a lot mellower, not as strong. RPSGs are quite spicy, and I'd say med-full. Right in my taste buds' sweet spot. I like the OSG's OK, but if I were buying and paying the same price for either, I'd take the SG's over OSGs any day. If you think the OSGs are strong, the SGs will likely kick your butt.
6,7 and 9. I like the 3000 maddie. Hadn'tr tried them before, but visited the Padron shop in Little Havana earlier this year. I had hoped their more expensive lines would be quite a bit cheaper buying from them directly, but no dice. Since we had called, scouting for a trip to the store the next day and the Padrons waited for us, I didn't want to stiff them. Picked up a box of the 3000 maddie and love them. Strong cigar, but IMO, not comparable taste to the RPSGs. Two noticeably different, strong and spicy cigars, both quite good in their own right.
#8 I agree with the chupacabra. While I like the CRs, I prefer the less expensive and (IMHO) better tasting RPSGs.