The Normal Retail price would be the guide. We would all have to rely a bit on the honor system here - but as the average price of the Domestic "Premiums" being considered here is a minimum of aprox $9-$10 each and up - we all know the type of cigars that fall into this category.
Taking a 1926 PAM Torpedo and replacing it with an AF Double Chateau (Green Label) would not be a fair trade - this in no way knocks the AF stick which is a fine smoke - but it does violate the spirit of the Pass.
Nor would taking the Padron Anniversario and replacing it with 5 Pirate's Gold sticks be allowed. - This is also a "No-Go".
The pass is like for like. PAM for a Diamond Crown - ok....Opus X for a Greycliff...ok, Cohiba Esplendido ISOM for an Upmann Sir Winston ISOM, ok.. and so on.
All Takes and Puts would be published on the forum at each stop of the box pass. I would set out the initial make-up of the Pass and then the person who gets it next would list each cigar he takes and what he puts in its place. He/she would then send it to the next person on the list Insured and with the Tracking Number published.
The rest of the group involved I'm sure will chime in if there is an "Inadvertent Violation" and we would rely on the honesty of the fellow Pass member to make up the shortfall.
Again, we are merely testing the waters here - this may not work --- but if it does - it could be a really good adventure as long as everyone is pretty close on their definition of "Premiums" --- and doesn't confuse the term with their "favorite" smokes ---they may or may not be the same thing. We are all looking to be fair here and not score the bargain of the century..