What cigars have you won/were gifted/ordered that ended up being far better than you expected? Could've been a budget smoke or one that was getting bad reviews etc.
This is the opposite of ordering what you assumed would be a spectacular smoke and turned out an expensive mistake.
I ask because I'm sitting here smoking a Gispert Piramide from my local B&M and dammit, its very tasty. Never knew they were this good.
I don't know if its a matter of lowered expectations or what but I wish it would happen more often.