If it is the only place in 100 miles and you feel it's worth it, then go for it.
With his rules and restrictions, especially the locker nonsense, even if he was the only one around, I wouldn't pay his fees.
Now if he truly was the only one in a 100 mile radius and I had kids that I didn't want to expose to smoke or see me smoking, then maybe I would sign up. But his "even though you are paying a membership fee, you can't bring your own cigars" still isn't going to fly with me. What if I have cigars that he can't legally sell? I'm paying a fee to be there, I should be able to smoke them there.
If I buy a membership at a private golf course, they don't make me buy or rent equipment from them to play their course. I can bring my own clubs and I can buy my golf balls from wherever the hell I want to.
I'm up by Sacramento and I have yet to find a B&M in the bay area where you can not smoke inside, but I haven't been to all of them so I'm sure there's one somewhere. Heck, even the one in the Arden Mall (three story indoor shopping mall) allows smoking in the store.
PS: Thanks for not taking things personally, a lot people who are new around here don't realize that with the regulars around here things aren't personal.