With variety, price and quality as factors I would pick
1. Bucanero
2. Padron
3. El rey Del Mundo
4. Hoyo

CAO
Torano
Perdomo
AVO

No particular order.

wtf, they all end in o.

ooohhhh so good.

Hmm... I have favorite lines for certain categories (Like Padron for maduros, LFD for medium naturals....) but I guess to judge the whole line and consider variety... I'm assuming we're differentiating between AF and Ashton, etc?
1. Bucanero
2. CAO
3. AF
4. Tie: Carlos Torano & Padron
5. LFD (may move up with the new double ligeros...)

this was done very quickly, and I'm sure I will start thinking more about the many offerings of the different lines and realize I made a mistake, but my life is already filled with so many regrets, I'm sure this will be on the bottom of the list that plagues me on my death bed....

-Ethan

In no particular order,
CAO
HDM
Bolivar Fuerte
Padron
Partagas

GT, we have similar tastes but CAO would have to be in there along with La Perla.

I was going to say La Perla...but I always reach for a Black Pearl. With the other brands, I'm not as picky. Plus, it doesn't end in o.

CAO
Perdomo
Temple Hall
Padron
or whatever suits the mood/situation

Bucanero

My top five:
1. Padron
2. Cupido
3. AF
4. CAO
5. Perdomo

gotta say Bucanero is in my top 10 🙂

Padronero, or is that Bucaron?

Barry

My Top five, or six
1. Padron, but maybe A.Fuente
2. Cao, but maybe Perdomo, who makes CAO.
3. Joya de Nic's, but maybe Hoya de selecta, no stick with the Antono 1970's
HELL I DON'T KNOW.
Later
Dave (A.K.A. Homebrew)

Hmmmm...this is a tough one...

1. Arturo Fuente
2. Montecristo
3. Punch
4. Romeo y Julieta
5. CAO

CAO
Padron
AVO
Joya De Nic

1. HDM
2. Partagas ISOM
3. Estavan Cruz
4. Perdomo
5. Oliva
6. Etc;

Bucanero
La Perla (Nats and Maddies)
Padron
Oliva O (Maduro)
Montesino (SG & Maduro)
La Gloria Cubana (Series 4 maduro)

in no particular order

I like the "anything that ends in 'o'" idea.

I like the "anything that ends in a vowel" idea.

1.LONEWOLF
2.LONEWOLF
3.LONEWOLF
4.LONEWOLF
5.LONEWOLF (LOL) now that I got your attention

Padron/Fuente (maddies, anejos, heck anything these two make is a great smoke)
Montecristo ISOM
Bucanero
Perdomo LTCS Maddie
Ashton
PSD ISOM
No particular order