pmn1
  • pmn1
  • Herf-A-Holic Topic Starter
Tuesday, May 27, 2008 6:19:00 AM
Thousands of Iraqi and Afghanistan veterans are returning home only to become casualties of war - at their own hands. Suffering from psychiatric injuries, 1,000 veterans under Veterans Administration care are attempting suicide each month. Almost 40 percent of the young men and women returning from combat almost have proven mental health injuries that include Post Traumatic Stress Disorder, major depression and traumatic brain injury.

But when they seek help, disabled veterans face a claims system so mismanaged and inefficient that they often must wait more than five years for any assistance. The Department of Veterans Affairs is choking on a backlog of some 600,000 unresolved benefits claims. Even after their eligibility has been established, thousands of veterans cannot obtain adequate mental health treatment. While they wait for the care they are owed, veterans are dying. About 126 veterans per week commit suicide. Vast numbers of veterans are living with mental illness, sometimes so severe that they are unable to work. Nationally, about 154,000 veterans are homeless on any given night and twice that many are homeless at some time during the year.

In a federal court lawsuit tried in San Francisco last month, two veterans' organizations asked Judge Samuel Conti to order the VA to streamline its systems for deciding benefits claims and obtaining mental health treatment. A decision is expected within a month.

During the trial, the VA vowed to do better, but history warns us against taking the VA's promises on faith. For example, a year ago, the VA adopted a Mental Health Plan for Suicide Prevention, which included many well-meant resolutions. But, in practical terms, none of the recommendations in this plan has been implemented, and none of its stated goals has been met. The suicides continue.

The VA's mental health professionals who work directly with veterans are skilled and caring, but the attitude of the VA bureaucracy is apparent from an internal e-mail from the VA's head of mental health, Dr. Ira Katz, that surfaced during the trial. At a time when the VA was publicly reporting only 790 veteran suicide attempts in all of 2007, Katz wrote, "Shh! ... Our suicide prevention coordinators are identifying about 1,000 suicide attempts per month ... Is this something we should (carefully) address ... before someone stumbles on it?" The VA seems to rate "damage control" as more important than caring for veterans who have been injured while serving our country.

Nonprofit organizations, such as Swords to Plowshares in San Francisco, try to pick up the pieces of veterans' broken lives, but they cannot possibly meet the overwhelming need. In San Francisco, these nonprofits can provide only a few hundred beds where veterans can receive targeted, residential mental health treatment, while at least 1,200 to 1,500 veterans live on the street, and hundreds more sleep in cars, parks and churches.

We learned from the experience of Vietnam veterans that allowing this situation to persist will lead to epidemics of unemployment and underemployment, homelessness and family breakdown. Sens. Barbara Boxer D-Calif., and Kit Bond (R-Mo.) have introduced the Honoring Our Nation's Obligations To Returning Warriors (HONOR) Act, which would improve efforts to prepare soldiers for the stress of combat, and provide supportive services for families. Please ask your congressional representative to support the Honor Act and to demand that the VA fulfill its mission of caring for our wounded soldiers after they come home.

Some numbers we should not forget

-- The suicide rate of veterans is at least three times the national suicide rate. In 2005, the suicide rate for veterans 18- to 24-years-old was three to four times higher than non-veterans.

-- About 154,000 veterans nationwide are homeless on any given night. One-fourth of the homeless population is veterans.

-- There are more homeless Vietnam veterans than the number of soldiers who were killed during that war.

-- It takes at least 5.5 years, on average, to resolve a benefit claim with the Veteran's Administration.

-- More than 600,000 unresolved claims are backlogged with the Veteran's Administration.

-- Approximately 18.5 percent of service members who have returned from Afghanistan and Iraq currently have Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder or depression.

-- 19.5 percent of these veterans report experiencing traumatic brain injury.

-- Roughly half of those who need treatment seek it, but only slightly more than half of those who receive treatment receive at least minimally adequate care, according to an April 2008 Rand Report.

jpotts
Tuesday, May 27, 2008 7:04:00 AM
http://blogs.tnr.com/tnr/blogs/the_plank/archive/2007/11/16/department-of-apples-and-oranges.aspx 

Department of Apples and Oranges

Andrew links to a shocking article in The Times of London that suggests an epidemic of suicides among veterans:

More American military veterans have been committing suicide than US soldiers have been dying in Iraq, it was claimed yesterday.

At least 6,256 US veterans took their lives in 2005, at an average of 17 a day, according to figures broadcast last night. Former servicemen are more than twice as likely than the rest of the population to commit suicide.

Such statistics compare to the total of 3,863 American military deaths in Iraq since the invasion in 2003 - an average of 2.4 a day, according to the website ICasualties.org...

The suicide rate among Americans as a whole was 8.9 per 100,000, but the level among veterans was at least 18.7. That figure rose to a minimum of 22.9 among veterans aged 20 to 24 – almost four times the nonveteran average for people of the same age.

The implicit suggestion is that the toll of the Iraq war is higher than we ever dared imagine, that even after they return to the States, traumatized vets are as much, or even more, at risk for their lives as they were on the battlefield. The problem with this comparison is that there are vastly more U.S. veterans than soldiers who are serving, or have ever served, in Iraq. According to the 2006 census, there are 23.7 million veterans in the United States, of whom 9.2 million are over 65 and 8 million served in the Vietnam era; by contrast, just 1.9 million veterans are under 35. The Times article essentially admits as much in its 7th graph: "There are 25 million veterans in the United States, 1.6 million of whom [i.e., between 6 and 7 percent] served in Afghanistan and Iraq." Moreover, the suicide rates cited by the Times appear to come from data going back as far as 1995, indicating that most of the deaths tallied predate the Iraq war.

None of this is to suggest that post-traumatic stress and other mental and emotional problems among veterans are not pressing issues. And they're almost certain to get far, far worse when the soldiers who have been serving in Iraq (and, to a lesser extent, Afghanistan) return home. But inflammatory comparisons between the number of soldiers killed in Iraq and the number of veterans (out of a vastly larger population) who commit suicide obscure far more than they clarify.

jpotts
Tuesday, May 27, 2008 7:06:00 AM
http://www.redstate.com/stories/war/a_suicide_epidemic_among_veterans 

A "Suicide Epidemic Among Veterans"?

"They are the casualties of wars you don’t often hear about - soldiers who die of self-inflicted wounds. Little is known about the true scope of suicides among those who have served in the military."

"But a five-month CBS News investigation discovered data that shows a startling rate of suicide, what some call a hidden epidemic"

So reads the lede from the CBS News website version of a CBS Evening News story aired last night.

I was anxiously awaiting this story because on the Veterans Day holiday (nice touch) a CBS News publicist fired this off to selected bloggers:

"We are breaking a huge military story tomorrow and I wanted to give you a heads up and even see if you wanted to write something about it on your blog, I would be happy to help with information, graphics and more."

"Below are the stories and a quote I got from Armen Kateyian - our chief investigative correspondent - for your blog. Please let me know if I can be of any more help."

So, what have these five-months produced?

Read on.

Were I an operations researcher professor critiquing this I would have two comments. First, the plural of anecdote is not data. Second, post hoc ergo propter hoc is not an analytical technique.

I hope we can all stipulate up front that suicide is a tragedy for all, but especially those left behind. They are left with the lingering and unresolved questions of whether there were warning signs they should have caught, whether there was something they could have done. The cases highlighted by CBS News are otherwise healthy young men, and gender is an important part of the equation, who had served in the military and in Iraq.

But the issue raised by CBS News is not one of individual tragedy but rather two distinctly different theses. First, that veterans, particularly those who have served in Iraq and Afghanistan, have unusually high suicide rates. Secondly, and we'll have to see that part tonight according to the promo, a hapless Department of Veterans' Affairs is doing jack in response to this onrushing locomotive, in fact, they don't even know about it.

A bit of background here.

Veteran status has been part of the standard death certificate since 1939. The National Vital Statistics System, however, is a terribly decentralized system in which the states voluntarily paricipate. The federal government is a subscriber to that data and pays for it on a per record basis through grant agreements with the states. That data element, veteran status, has never been collated at the federal level. So while the data exists on an existential level it might as well not exist in any practical sense.

So kudos to CBS for collecting data sets from 45 states going back to 1995. This represents some 20 million plus entries and it had to have been fun compiling the database for analysis.

We don't know much about how they went about doing this so from this point on we're going to take a leap of faith and presume that their analysis of the veteran suicide rate is correct.

The Claim

"In 2005, for example, in just those 45 states, there were at least 6,256 suicides among those who served in the armed forces. That’s 120 each and every week, in just one year."

"Dr. Steve Rathburn is the acting head of the biostatistics department at the University of Georgia. CBS News asked him to run a detailed analysis of the raw numbers that we obtained from state authorities for 2004 and 2005."

"It found that veterans were more than twice as likely to commit suicide in 2005 than non-vets. (Veterans committed suicide at the rate of between 18.7 to 20.8 per 100,000, compared to other Americans, who did so at the rate of 8.9 per 100,000.)"

"One age group stood out. Veterans aged 20 through 24, those who have served during the war on terror. They had the highest suicide rate among all veterans, estimated between two and four times higher than civilians the same age. (The suicide rate for non-veterans is 8.3 per 100,000, while the rate for veterans was found to be between 22.9 and 31.9 per 100,000.)"

National data for 2005 has not been published at this writing but data for 2004 and earlier is easily available through two public use databases managed by the Centers for Disease Control and Prevetion's National Center for Injury Prevention and Control. (here | here).

It is also worth noting that veteran status does not imply service in a combat zone and any attempted linkage of this annotation on a death certificate and actual combat duty is impossible.

Before moving into the issue of veterans let's take a side trip to active duty suicides. If service in Iraq and Afghanistan are contributing factors then one might expect the unique nexus of stress, imminent danger, family separation, and access to a veritable smorgasbord of deadly devices one finds in Iraq and Afghanistan would produce a higher than normal level of suicides. According to Department of Defense:

The Army Suicide Event Report, which tracks suicide attempts and completions and the factors involved, showed that in 2006 there were 99 suicides within the Army, 30 of which occurred in Iraq or Afghanistan. This is an increase from 87 suicides in 2005 and 67 in 2004.

According to the report, the Army’s suicide rate for 2006 was 17.3 suicides per 100,000 soldiers. This compares to the overall U.S. population rate, for the same age and gender group, of roughly 19 suicides per 100,000 people.

Suicide rates in other services aren't as easy to find but I think we could make a completely valid assumption that Army rates more than likely represent a ceiling to the active duty suicide rate rather than either a floor or a midpoint.

A key point to remember here, which this pull quote hits, is that the veteran population in not comparable to the civilian population of the same age. The active military population is about 85% male, the veteran population, reflecting the manpower policies of less enlightened times is a significantly higher percentage male.

I spent some time trying to duplicate the "other Americans" suicide rate variously given as 8.3 and 8.9 per 100,000 with limited success. It appears that number is derived from capping the age group at age 24 and extending it downward. If we look at standard age breaks, this is what we get as rates per 100,000 for all races and ethnicities and both (or however many we're recognizing these days) sexes in 2004:

15-19 years, 8.2; 20-24 years, 12.4; 25-34 years, 12.6; 35-44 years, 15.0; 45-54 years, 16.5; 55-64 years, 13.8; 65-74 years, 12.3; 75-84 years, 16.3; and 85+ years, 16.4.

So, at first blush, we compare the CBS story's figure of "between 18.7 and 20.8 per 100,000" and we get a significantly higher figure. But we know that the veteran population is overwhelmingly male. If we run the age cohorts as male only we get a different picture:

15-19 years,12.6; 20-24 years, 20.8; 25-34 years, 20.3; 35-44 years, 23.0; 45-54 years, 24.7; 55-64 years, 22.0; 65-74 years, 22.5; 75-84 years, 34.8; and 85+ years, 45.0.

Lo and behold, 20;8 per 100,000 is the exact same number as the rate of 20-24 year old males regardless of veteran status.

If we run it again as white males because the military is majority white (58% across all services and components with wild variations among occuapational specialties) and male (about 85%):

15-19 years, 13.5; 20-24 years, 22.0; 25-34 years, 21.7; 35-44 years, 25.6; 45-54 years, 27.5; 55-64 years, 23.9; 65-74 years, 24.1; 75-84 years, 37.0; and 85+ years, 48.3.

It would seem, that once the suicide rate is adjusted to reflect the demographics of the veterans population that the sucide rate among 20-24 year olds is statistically indistinguishable from that of the general population.

The story could end there but singular data points are rarely useful in analysis. One could argue that as suicides among 20-24 year olds in 2004 only totaled 2,607 then an "epidemic" of suicides among veterans in that age group could easily have skewed the data for males and white males making the veterans suicide rate look the same as the non-veteran rate of the same population.

If I am correct, then the suicide rate among the 20-24 year old male cohort, which I am using as a proxy for veterans, should remain similar over time. If CBS is correct, there should be a rise in that rate in 2004. If we go back about 30 years this is what we see:

1979 -- 26.5

1980 -- 26.8

1981 -- 25.7

1982 -- 25.2

1983 -- 24.0

Going forward ten years:

1993 -- 26.5

1994 -- 28.0

1995 -- 27.0

And since the Long War began:

2002 -- 20.8

2003 -- 20.2

2004 -- 20.8

Statistically, the suicide rate for this age cohort has remained unchanged since at least 1999.

None of this should be interpreted as saying some veterans have not committed suicide because of their experience when serving in Iraq and Afghanistan, or that more should not be done to provide mental health services to veterans but the CBS story does not contribute to the discussion.

The data they use are necessarily incomplete and their analysis flawed in concept and myopic in scope.

Of course they only had 5 months to do it in.

jpotts
Tuesday, May 27, 2008 7:08:00 AM
By the way, the VA might save some money, and increase efficiency in claims processing by privitizing. That's what Medicare and Medicaide did.

I'm not sure if their claims processing is a public or private entity.

jpotts
Tuesday, May 27, 2008 7:17:00 AM
http://cei.org/gencon/019,05977.cfm 

Junk Science: Military Suicide Mystery

Milloy article in FoxNews.com

by Steven J. Milloy

June 15, 2007

Researchers and the media did their best this week to scare military personnel and their families with the widely reported headline, “Military Service Doubles Suicide Risk.”

“Male veterans are twice as likely as their civilian counterparts to die by suicide,” Portland State University professor Mark Kaplan told the Atlanta Journal Constitution. “We don’t know why. But this finding may foreshadow what is going to come with the current cohort of military personnel who have served in Afghanistan and Iraq,” he added.

Published in the Journal of Epidemiology and Community Health (July 2007), Kaplan’s study consisted of 320,890 men who were followed for 12 years. As it is a statistical correlation study – rather than an investigation into whether an actual cause-and-effect relationship exists between military service and suicide – I naturally was skeptical. From the very beginning, the study didn’t disappoint me.

The study summary stated that the veterans’ suicide rate was 2.04 times that of non-veterans. When I read the study to see how the 2.04 figure was derived, I found no explanation. Mysteriously, the 2.04 figure did not even appear in the study itself – that’s pretty unusual.

I did, however, find a bar graph in the study that presented 2.13 as the difference in suicide rate between veterans and non-veterans.

You might think that this solved the mystery. A typographical or editorial foul-up must have inadvertently led to the 2.04-figure, rather than the 2.13 figure, being spotlighted in the study summary, right? We’ll get to that later. In the meantime, my discovery of the 2.13-figure only deepened the mystery.

Kaplan wrote in his study that the 2.13-figure represented the difference in suicide rates between veterans and non-veterans after statistical adjustment to account for other potential risk factors for suicide, including age, marital status, living arrangement, race, education, family income, employment status, geographic region, interval since last visit to a doctor, self-rated health and body mass index.

This list seemed impressively comprehensive and ostensibly strengthened the case for his claimed result – until, that is, I discovered that a key potential suicide risk factor apparently was omitted from his statistical adjustment.

There’s a table in Kaplan’s study in which he presents the difference in veteran suicide rates by individual risk factors, including age, race, marital status, living arrangement, education, employment status, region of residence, urban/rural locality, self-rated health, body mass index, psychiatric conditions and activity limitation.

With the exception of race, education and activity limitation, none of these risk factors were statistically significantly associated with increased suicide rates. But since race, education and activity limitation were associated with increased suicide risk, all three should have been among the potential risk factors Kaplan considered when he did his statistical adjustments to produce the 2.13-figure.

If you compare the above-mentioned lists of suicide risk factors, however, you’ll note that while activity limitation was identified as a significant risk factor for suicide, it apparently was not included in the statistical adjustment that produced the 2.13-figure.

And of the three statistically significant risk factors for suicide, activity limitation was by far the greatest – veterans with activity limitations had a 4.44 times greater rate of suicide than veterans with no activity limitations, as compared to race (3.23) and education (2.67).

Is the omission of the activity limitation factor another study typo? Was it inadvertently omitted from the statistical adjustment? Or was it omitted from the analysis because it would produce a non-result that rendered the study non-publishable and non-newsworthy?

It certainly cannot be said that Kaplan was ignorant of the significance of the activity limitation risk factor. “According to Kaplan, the risk of suicide was highest among men whose activities were limited by health problems,” reported the Atlanta Journal-Constitution.

Kaplan also published a study earlier this year entitled, “Physical illness, functional limitations and suicide risk: A population-based study” in the American Journal of Orthopsychiatry (Jan. 2007) in which he stated, “After controlling for potential [confounding risk factors], functional limitations were shown to be a significant predictor of suicide.”

When I contacted Kaplan about these issues, he immediately acknowledged that the 2.04-figure was a typo and that the 2.13-figure was correct. Interestingly, he also provided me with a dubious error bar for the 2.13 figure. When I asked him about that, another acknowledgment of error was made. These may seem like small errors, but they certainly build no confidence.

As to the crucial omission of activity limitation as a risk factor, Kaplan deferred responding, writing that he needed to consult with one of his statistician co-authors.

As of the time of this column, I had not heard back from Kaplan on that point. But you might think that a lead study author who gave many media interviews this week would be readily familiar with such a key component of his analysis. Of all the researchers I’ve interviewed over the years about their results, none has ever failed to immediately provide an answer to such a basic question.

I don’t know whether Kaplan ultimately will produce a satisfactory explanation for the activity limitation omission – the study’s remaining mystery. In some ways it doesn’t matter.

The study’s other shortcomings – particularly that veteran suicide rates weren’t higher across the vast majority of demographic groups examined, which indicates that military service itself isn’t a causative factor in suicide – are alone enough to debunk it and the scary headlines it spawned.

But the wide reporting of a paper with such major and easily discoverable problems – as well as Kaplan’s questionable effort to foment concern about suicide risk among veterans of Afghanistan and Iraq – reflects poorly on him and his co-authors, the publishing journal and the media.

jpotts
Tuesday, May 27, 2008 7:30:00 AM
http://www.nchv.org/background.cfm 

Who are homeless veterans?

The U. S. Department of Veterans Affairs (VA) says the nation's homeless veterans are mostly males (4 % are females). The vast majority are single, most come from poor, disadvantaged communities, 45% suffer from mental illness, and half have substance abuse problems. America’s homeless veterans have served in World War II, Korean War, Cold War, Vietnam War, Grenada, Panama, Lebanon, Operation Enduring Freedom (Afghanistan), Operation Iraqi Freedom, or the military’s anti-drug cultivation efforts in South America. Forty-seven percent of homeless veterans served during the Vietnam Era. More than 67% served our country for at least three years and 33% were stationed in a war zone.

How many homeless veterans are there?

Although accurate numbers are impossible to come by -- no one keeps national records on homeless veterans -- the VA estimates that nearly 200,000 veterans are homeless on any given night. And nearly 400,000 experience homelessness over the course of a year. Conservatively, one out of every three homeless men who is sleeping in a doorway, alley or box in our cities and rural communities has put on a uniform and served this country. According to the National Survey of Homeless Assistance Providers and Clients (U.S. Interagency Council on Homelessness and the Urban Institute, 1999), veterans account for 23% of all homeless people in America.

Veteran Specific Highlights:

23% of homeless population are veterans

33% of male homeless population are veterans

47% Vietnam Era

17% post Vietnam

15% pre Vietnam

67% served three or more years

33% stationed in war zone

25% have used VA Homeless Services

85% completed high school/GED compared to 56% of non-veterans

89% received Honorable Discharge

79% reside in central cities

16% reside in suburban areas

5% reside in rural areas

76% experience alcohol, drug, or mental health problems

46% white males compared to 34% non-veterans

46% age 45 or older compared to 20% non-veterans

Service needs:

45% help finding job

37% finding housing

pmn1
  • pmn1
  • Herf-A-Holic Topic Starter
Tuesday, May 27, 2008 7:40:00 AM
But when they seek help, disabled veterans face a claims system so mismanaged and inefficient that they often must wait more than five years for any assistance. The Department of Veterans Affairs is choking on a backlog of some 600,000 unresolved benefits claims. Even after their eligibility has been established, thousands of veterans cannot obtain adequate mental health treatment. While they wait for the care they are owed, veterans are dying. About 126 veterans per week commit suicide. Vast numbers of veterans are living with mental illness, sometimes so severe that they are unable to work. Nationally, about 154,000 veterans are homeless on any given night and twice that many are homeless at some time during the year
jpotts
Tuesday, May 27, 2008 7:49:00 AM
^ No arguing that.

It's called government-run healthcare. The same type of healthcare they want to force everyone into.

It'd probably be more efficient (and cost less) if they privitized.

Gene363
Tuesday, May 27, 2008 4:45:00 PM
jpotts

DFTT

donutboy2000
Tuesday, May 27, 2008 4:47:00 PM
Obama's nationalized health care system will be much better.
RICKAMAVEN
Tuesday, May 27, 2008 6:44:00 PM
wow 5 or 6 posts .
RICKAMAVEN
Tuesday, May 27, 2008 6:52:00 PM
the congress and the senate have government sponsored health care. i don't hear them bitching about it.
jpotts
Tuesday, May 27, 2008 8:18:00 PM
There are always sheep who think that the farmer's haircut is the equivalent of being completely sheared.
GreenWolf70
Tuesday, May 27, 2008 9:14:00 PM
ROFLMAO. Now that ^ is funny.

Nationalized Health Care, or even any drop in the rate of rising health care costs, can not work until the government recognizes that health care is not a price competitive market and moves to regulate those costs.

Blue Cross ran a market analysis back in the 1980's that attempted to show that when there are two or more hospitals in an area, health care costs go down. However, that analysis clearly proved in stead that the more hospitals the higher the health costs. Its seems the more doctors there are, the more they talk and the higher health care costs rise. According to the law, once a market is proven to not be price competitive, the government can move to regulate it. That is why utilities are regulated.

Yes, VA sucks. They constantly require me to send them paper copies of my medical records when I know for a fact that they have all my medical records stored electronically and that those files contain everything I have and even information that I have never seen. Yet, if I have lost my paper copy I may never receive some benefits. Most of the doctors there seem to not be Americans, or maybe just recently naturalized. Yup, they suck. If you can fix it, you have my blessing.

If you are truly worried about the plight of veterans, then join the military. The service to your country will make you a better man and it will improve your perspective. If you are too old to serve, then write your Congressman and tell him that vets should not have pay taxes since we have risked our lives to protect a country that is more concerned about political correctness than actually winning the war.

I was talking to my son a year ago about current tactics in house to house fighting and discovered that they no longer use grenades in clearing a room. Seems someone made the decision not to use grenades because they might harm nearby non-combatants. That stupid little decision alone greatly increases the chance that you will take casualties. It is strictly a PC decision to make you folks sitting on your comfy little couch at home feel better about yourselves, it matters little that your little feel good costs American lives. After all, we volunteered to make you little snits feel better, didn't we. JMHO.