Andy, Chief understand the importance of documenting meetings--especially when it comes to possible work comp savings.
But recordings can really be misconstrued simply because it only represents a portion of what is going on (rolled eyes, winks, grins, gestures, other facial expressions, all are left out...).
Maybe have meeting (safety meetings?), have secretary type up essence of what was discussed, get reviewed and signed off by those necessary.
Heap safer, but possibly Chief being paranoid!