#1, Jet,
'...how much would it cost to switch to natural gas...?'
Main cost would be the furnace itself--probably about $1300-$2000, plus the cost to remove/replace unit, install gas lines, perhaps adjust venting.
Bottom line, probably close to a wash for the first year or so.
We used oil for our last two homes. It was cheap heat, noisy, but cheap. However, if I had a choice 'twixt oil and nat gas, I'd go the gas route.
But we don't have nat. gas here.
So when it came time to make a decision on heat source with this house, we went with heat pump for two reasons the need to control humidity, and cost.
So far, after only one winter, I LOVE MY GADDAM HEAT PUMPS.