As to what has been said here, it's mostly accurate as far as it goes. I use a Swiss army Knife cutter (SAK) and a double guillotine cutter, a punch (if I could only invent one that was durable AND didn't have a half that you always lose!) and depending on the situation, I'll say they are ALL the best. A punch DOES concentrate the smoke, which is not a bad thing if you are smoking a milder gar and want to strengthen the taste up a tad. A good cut will give you TONS of creamy smoke pouring forth from a good cigar, and not restrict it in the least, and a punch is not even an option, (nor is a 'V' cut I beleive) on a Torp, although you also run across fans of the "****** Cut" on Torps. So it would be foolish to try to stick with just one method, or even try to have a favorite, except for a specific method on a specific Cigar/shape/size combo! I'm sure that I have now thouroghly confused you, so I'l now just say Welcome!