pacman357
Thursday, August 28, 2008 3:40:00 PM
Deny the problem exists. Yeah, I know...he's probably disavowing the speaker at this point or will soon, but it's funny (to me, anyway) that someone who can get microphone time and is apparently part of the campaign would spew such "let them eat cake" nonsense:

A health care policy adviser for the McCain campaign told a newspaper reporter that nobody in the United States is technically uninsured, because everyone has access to hospital emergency rooms.

"So I have a solution [to the health care crisis]. And it will cost not one thin dime," John Goodman, president of the National Center for Policy Analysis, told the Dallas Morning News in an interview published Thursday.

"The next president of the United States should sign an executive order requiring the Census Bureau to cease and desist from describing any American – even illegal aliens – as uninsured. Instead, the bureau should categorize people according to the likely source of payment should they need care. So, there you have it. Voila! Problem solved."

MACS
Thursday, August 28, 2008 3:47:00 PM
Well... they MUST treat you. You can't be turned away.

But they WILL bill you, and any prescription they write... have fun getting that filled with no money to pay for it.

jpotts
Thursday, August 28, 2008 6:23:00 PM
There are people on this board that work at hospitals, and they will verify that everyone has access to free healthcare.

The McCain guy is correct: you can get free treatment at the emergency room. With extended treatment, the hospital will pick it up for free.

Doctors regularly give out free medication, and pharma companies have numerous programs that provide perscriptions for free.

If you don't have insurance and have the dignity to pay, hospitals will often provide healthcare at reduced rates, or offer payment programs.

In fact, free healthcare is so destructive to hospitals, many have to close their emergency rooms, or close up shop altogether. This is especially true in California, where illegal aliens have done extensive damage to the system. They go in for aid, and take off without paying.

You may not like the "let them eat cake" attitude, but the fact is that while the healthcare system in this country may not be perfect, it does not have the major shortcomings that healthcare systems in other countries.

There is no such thing as a perfect system. And people should be suspicious of those who promise one.

teedubbya
Friday, August 29, 2008 5:57:00 AM
you can be turned away. EMTALA requires nothing more than emergency treatment and only stabilizing treatment at that. I happen to be very involved in investigating those damn things.

the real McCain solution (why is insurance even part of the solution?) has something to do with soilent green.

FuzzNJ
Friday, August 29, 2008 7:28:00 AM
Washington, D.C. — The American College of Emergency Physicians (ACEP) today lambasted McCain health policy advisor John Goodman’s assertion that anyone with access to an emergency department effectively has health insurance, and called his logic flawed and his statement irresponsible toward all patients, insured and uninsured alike.

“The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention’s latest report showed visits to emergency departments climbed 32 percent over a ten-year period, and there is no sign that this trend is slowing,” said Dr. Linda Lawrence, president of ACEP. “Emergency departments are the nation’s health care safety net, but that net is breaking under the load, in part because so much of the care goes uncompensated. To suggest that there are no uninsured patients is to cast a blind eye toward the needs of all emergency patients, insured or not, who are waiting longer and longer for care, sometimes with deadly consequences.”

“We urge the McCain campaign to rethink the reckless suggestion by Mr. Goodman that the tragedy of uninsured patients can be erased by the magic of emergency departments,” said Dr. Lawrence. “Emergency physicians can and do perform miracles every day, but taking on the full-time, medical care for 46 million uninsured Americans is one miracle even we cannot perform. Access to care in the emergency department is no substitute for the comprehensive health care reform policy that should be at the heart of the platform of any presidential campaign.”

HockeyDad
Friday, August 29, 2008 7:35:00 AM
"Just show up at the ER and call it a healthplan" versus "expensive nationalized healthcare".....

President Obama might promise to lower income taxes for 99% of the country but he will take it all back and more in other places.

ante up!

FuzzNJ
Friday, August 29, 2008 7:42:00 AM
At this point, whatcha gonna do though HD? We've spend hundreds of billions of dollars on wars, all off book, money we don't have so we are borrowing it, all while cutting taxes, that's unsustainable. The healthcare system is the same thing. It's unsustainable the way it is now. I'm just glad I don't have to crunch those numbers, I have trouble remembering my phone numbers.
Sardious
Friday, August 29, 2008 7:55:00 AM
even ilegals get emergency room care and if you can't pay the government WILL help you. so "technically" that is true. Still an idiot move to say that.
jpotts
Friday, August 29, 2008 8:43:00 AM
The hundreds of billions spent on wars pales in the trillions of dollars we've spent on social services in this country over the last three decaded.

As for the healthcare system being unsustainable, seeing that it is in the private sector, individuals will "sustain" whatever system we have because they are making the decisions regarding their care.

It only becomes "unsustainable" when a third party takes it over and decides how it will be funded when matched against its obligations.

HockeyDad
Friday, August 29, 2008 9:24:00 AM
FuzzNJ,

My plan is to move to Argentina shortly before the United States files bankruptcy and either retire comfortably or swoop back in with Euros and buy everything up for pennies on the dollar (amero).

ScottHar
Friday, August 29, 2008 9:26:00 AM
^[jotting this down and filing under "Retirement Plan."]

ScottHar

teedubbya
Friday, August 29, 2008 9:58:00 AM
"even ilegals get emergency room care and if you can't pay the government WILL help you. so "technically" that is true. Still an idiot move to say that. "

not emergency room care..... emergency care.... big difference

under EMTALA they are entitled to care if their life, limbs, etc are in immediate peril. And then it is only to stabelize. Triage, Stabelize, dump.

emergency room care would include non emergent care.... urgent care or even routine care..... hospitals can turn non paying folks away for these things.

I have an case (yes I work with this ****) I am working on right now where the person has no $$ and no insurance, but has CKD (chronic kidney disease).

No dialysis unit will take her and the hospitals will not treat her until she is in danger of losing her life or limb (actually the definition is not this clean...but none the less) (EMTALA). SOOOOOOOO

She goes to the hospital every day, they are required to establish (triage) her condition and when she is near death they give her dialysis.

Its a great world we live in.

Pregnancy is not considered an emergent situaiton unless the baby is about to "emerge" lol. So no prenatal care.... yes to baby popping out.... good riddence to mom and baby

no routine care is covered under EMTALA

teedubbya
Friday, August 29, 2008 10:00:00 AM
oh yea

bottom line on the ckd person.... everyone is just waiting for her to die. If she had money she would live.

oh well.

Sardious
Friday, August 29, 2008 10:06:00 AM
you have obviously never needed emergecy room care and had to sit next to an illegal with a jammed figer, yes they fix it, no the illegal does not pay. Per the rules the illegal does not get care and gets deprted for being here illegal. In reality he gets care and then stays here to work for money under the table. If you think the "emergency care" is followed to a T you are naive. Sad thing is that I know you are not. My wife has a cousin, does not work, lives off welfare, no insurance, gets as good of medical care as mee and usually gets away with paying nothing because "I can't pay I have no job" even though no job is by choice. I see it happen I know it happens. You can in fact get medical care with no insurance and if you can't pay....yes you will get help. you may pay some over time but a far reduced cost.
HockeyDad
Friday, August 29, 2008 10:10:00 AM
Merge with Mexico and form the North American Union. Illegals getting health care for free is solved.

The HockeyDad, part of the solution.

RICKAMAVEN
Friday, August 29, 2008 10:11:00 AM
6. Author: HockeyDad

what other places?

RICKAMAVEN
Friday, August 29, 2008 10:13:00 AM
7. Author: FuzzNJ

http://tinyurl.com/5kjwzg 

jpotts
Friday, August 29, 2008 10:17:00 AM
For everyone's information:

http://www.emtala.com/faq.htm 

EMTALA applies only to "participating hospitals" -- i.e., to hospitals which have entered into "provider agreements" under which they will accept payment from the Department of Health and Human Services, Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS) under the Medicare program for services provided to beneficiaries of that program. In practical terms, this means that it applies to virtually all hospitals in the U.S., with the exception of the Shriners' Hospital for Crippled Children and many military hospitals. Its provisions apply to all patients, and not just to Medicare patients. (See Section 15 below.)

What is an "emergency medical condition"?

An attempt is made by the statute to provide a definition, but as usually happens, the legal definition leaves much to be desired. The determination is ultimately a medical one rather than a legal one. That is not to say that it is sheltered from review. As is the case with any medical decision, it must often be made quickly, with such information as is available, and is subject to critical retrospective review by physicians testifying as expert witnesses in the alien setting of the courtroom, in the event of litigation.

The definition provided under the statute is:

"A medical condition manifesting itself by acute symptoms of sufficient severity (including severe pain) such that the absence of immediate medical attention could reasonably be expected to result in --

placing the health of the individual (or, with respect to a pregnant woman, the health of the woman or her unborn child) in serious jeopardy,

serious impairment to bodily functions, or

serious dysfunction of any bodily organ or part, or

"With respect to a pregnant woman who is having contractions --

that there is inadequate time to effect a safe transfer to another hospital before delivery, or

that the transfer may pose a threat to the health or safety of the woman or her unborn child."

Does civil liability attach for claims under EMTALA?

Yes. The following provisions apply:

A hospital may be held liable to an injured person in a civil action for damages under the statute, with no maximum on the liability. Unlike a number of other Federal statutes enabling a civil remedy, there is no provision for an award of attorneys' fees to a successful plaintiff.

A hospital may also be held liable to another hospital in a civil action for any financial loss suffered by the second hospital, to the extent available under State law.

Precisely what that means is uncertain. It is not clear what, if any, remedies were available under common law to a hospital which received a patient in transfer from another facility. Presumably, the receiving hospital could recoup from the transferring hospital any expenses and liabilities which were not reimbursed by Medicaid, Medicare, or third-party medical insurance. Depending on State law and/or the applicable contractual language, a third-party payor, such as a medical insurer, may become subrogated to the claim, meaning that it would be entitled to recover from the transferring hospital the amounts that it paid on behalf of the patient. It would not require much of a stretch for a court to conclude further that the statute would entitle CMS to recover the benefits paid under Medicare or a State to recover benefits paid under Medicaid if a violation is found, even if there is no specific provision for such a recovery elsewhere in the Medicare statute.

Doesn't EMTALA simply restate in a different way the general obligation to provide appropriate treatment when it is needed?

No. To some extent, of course, the obligations of EMTALA and of a State's substantive tort law are coextensive. EMTALA does impose an affirmative obligation to conduct an assessment and to provide treatment, even when State law may not have so required.

It would be overly simplistic to assume that compliance with the standard of care will automatically entail compliance with EMTALA. The statute imposes certain limits on a transfer and certain requirements as to treatment which go beyond the ordinary standard of care requirements.

One Court has held that the obligations under EMTALA are absolute, and that the patient must be treated even when that treatment would not be necessary under State law and even when treatment, in fact, may be ethically inappropriate and/or a violation of the standard of care. In In re Baby K, 16 F.3d 590 (4th Cir 1994), the Court found that EMTALA imposed an obligation to intubate an infant and to provide mechanical ventilation, in the case of an anencephalic infant who had no hope for conscious awareness or for any form of what most people would think of as human existence. Even though all parties agreed and the Court found that, under the common law of the Commonwealth of Virginia, under generally-accepted principles of medical ethics, and under the standard of care, intervention could and should be withheld, the Court ruled that EMTALA imposes an affirmative (and ongoing) obligation on the hospital to provide such intervention and care to the infant.

HockeyDad
Friday, August 29, 2008 10:18:00 AM
Medicare

Social Security

Gasoline

Capital gains

excise taxes

Federal sales tax/VAT tax

etc.

Regardless of who is President, the USA will need massive tax increases to balance the budget or we will continue to borrow trillions and pass the debt to the next generation and the ultimate bankruptcy of the USA. The USA government is already at the mercy of domestic and foreign credit markets.

Right now Obama and McCain both propose adding a few trillion to the national debt.

I blame old people for the problem.

teedubbya
Friday, August 29, 2008 10:19:00 AM
Sardious - A large part of what I do involves EMTALA cases. I am not speaking from anecdotal evidence of a time I went to an ER, I have the cases in front of me and am/have also been involved in the investigations on site.