FuzzNJ
  • FuzzNJ
  • Herf-A-Holic Topic Starter
Thursday, September 4, 2008 2:15:00 PM
I'll post a bit here and the rest at the link. It's posted for those who might find it interesting also and discussion if you would like to comment. Yes, it's a cut and paste, complain if must.

How Anti-Intellectualism Is Destroying America

Terrence McNally: Have things gotten worse? How were things different as you were growing up?

Susan Jacoby: Well, I have just been told that all of my memories of growing up are wrong, because memory is absolutely inaccurate. It's only a "narrative."

I'll give you an example of how stupid this country has become. I'm one of the village atheists on Faith, a panel sponsored by the Washington Post and Newsweek. In a recent post I wrote that when I was 7 years old, I was taken by my mom to visit a friend who had been stricken by polio and was in an iron lung. Polio has basically been eradicated, but I grew up when polio was still a real threat to children, before the Salk vaccine.

This childhood friend had been playing and running only three weeks before, and now he was in an iron lung. And I asked my mom, "Why would God let something like that happen?" And to her credit, instead of giving me some moronic answer, my mother said, "I don't know."

After posting this on Faith, I received an e-mail saying, "All childhood memories are unreliable. We construct narratives to justify what we now think."

Of course it would be stupid if I'd said I became an atheist at the age of 7. But I hadn't said that, only that I remembered this childhood experience as making me begin to question what I'd been taught. The whole tone of the e-mail was that nobody's memory about anything could possibly be accurate -- no fact could possibly be true.

TM: That doesn't sound like a typical evolution doubter. It sounds like an attack on rationality from a rational person.

SJ: That's right. One of the points I make in my book is that unreason pervades our culture. It's not just a matter of right-wing religious fundamentalism. There are all kinds of unreason and suspicion of evidence on both the Right and the Left.

TM: Misinformation may well have been the deciding factor in a close election in 2004. I worry not just about the lack of information and knowledge, but also the active disparagement of those who would even care about such things.

SJ: Contempt for fact is very important.

I'll give you a great example that's already obsolete. At the end of the primaries, both Hillary Clinton and John McCain endorsed a gas tax holiday for Americans this summer. Every economist, both liberal and conservative, said this would do nothing to help matters. And when Hillary Clinton was asked by the late Tim Russert, "Can you produce one economist to support the gas tax holiday?" she said, "Oh that's elite thinking."

Now to say that economists have nothing intelligent to say about whether a gas tax will give people economic relief is like saying that you don't ask musicians about music; you don't ask scientists about science. It's not just an attack on a political idea; it's an attack on knowledge itself.

TM: And this from a woman who was in the top of her class at Yale Law School.

SJ: Of course, she doesn't believe it for a minute. It shows that a lot of politicians think they have to play to ignorance and label anything that goes against received opinion as elitism.

I was quite encouraged that the actual majority of Americans -- both Republicans and Democrats -- said the gas tax was just a stupid gimmick.

http://www.alternet.org/story/95109 

jrupertnh
Thursday, September 4, 2008 2:27:00 PM
So she has a book out bemoaning "anti-intellectualism", (was the secondary title "See Superior I Am?"?), and you and the clip with the part where she's relieved that Americans on the whole intuitively agreed with the intellectuals.

Sweet.

A pretty good (IMHO) review of one of her books.

http://www.philly.com/inquirer/entertainment/20080316_America_anti-intellectual__Now__lets_think_this_out.html 

jrupertnh
Thursday, September 4, 2008 2:28:00 PM
#2

doh!

"and you and" = "and you end"

andytv
Thursday, September 4, 2008 2:32:00 PM
If you are saying that ignorance of the truth is a NEW problem, then obviously you have no idea what you are talking about.
jpotts
Thursday, September 4, 2008 2:33:00 PM
"Now to say that economists have nothing intelligent to say about whether a gas tax will give people economic relief is like saying that you don't ask musicians about music; you don't ask scientists about science. It's not just an attack on a political idea; it's an attack on knowledge itself."

I'd take issue with that.

With the politization of sciences, just because you have an "expert" or group of "experts" saying yea or nay to an idea does not mean that the principle behind it is proven or flawed (respectively). Many experts - especially the most easily recognized ones - are experts through self-promotion, and not actual accomplishments. This happens a lot, especially in acedemic circles, and big business.

Furthermore, any area of study is generally in a state of flux, and is subject to change based on previously unknown conditions. One prime example is stagflation which, by most economic experts at the time, was a condition that couldn't exist. Yet it did exist, and it changed economic theory from the 1970s on.

So, the experts aren't always right. And their predictions are subject to essentially the same speculation as anyone else.

Generally, when someone throws the title of "intellectual" or "intellectualism" around, they should immediately be suspect. The terms are used mainly by inferior minds to somehow elevate their dim, inexperienced views above those who actually know what they're doing.

Just my two-cents.

But yes, it was an interesting interview, in many ways.