I would be willing to be that the calculations were based off the published IRS "average" deductions for taxpayers in that income bracket.
here is a link to numbers based on 2004.
http://www.cch.com/wbot2007/026AvgItemizedDeductions.asp
the problem is, the average is based off of all returns in that income bracket who actually claimed an itemized deduction for that category, without factoring in all of the returns that were zero. As such, the "average" is an average of the deductions claimed, not the average amount that all taxpayers in that bracket received.
Most families of 5 at 45,000 would not itemize.
Using the 2004 "average" of $17,981 and assuming the family contributed 8,000 to a traditional IRA (the max.) the family would qualify for the following deductions:
Personal Exemptions: 3400 x 5= 17,000
IRA Contribution: 8,000
Itemized Deductions: 17,981
Total: 42,981
leaving a taxable income of: 2,019
Tax due: $201
Assuming the 2007 itemized deduction averages were higher, you might get to 0 tax. In order to get the refund claimed above, the family would have to qualify for the earned income credit, or some other "refundable" credit. none of the deductions above, even if significantly larger, would generate a refund.
Assuming that the family has a qualifing child, and the family made the 8,000 IRA contribution, it would receive the earned income credit, and actually receive a refund without paying any tax in. So, in theory the numbers stated above work.
the problem is this family after paying the itemized deduction expenses (including the 7.5% cut for medical) and the IRA contribution will have 23,206 to live off of. out of that the family would have to pay the principal payment on the mortgage, insurance, food, transportation, credit card interest, child care, entertainment, utilities, etc.
the reality is that the family can not afford to make the 8000 IRA contribution. without that, the family does not qualify for the earned income credit and gets no refund.
just my .04