Maxplayer14
Monday, September 8, 2008 7:17:00 PM
Let's take a married household earning about $45,000, with three dependents, owns a home, and gives slightly more than average to charity.

For tax year 2007 this household would pay $0 in federal income tax. In fact, not only would they pay $0, but they would get over $2400 from the federal government. This is not money being refunded to them - it's free money from the government.

Now, if this same household had filed using 1999's tax laws (Similar to what Obama proposes), they would have owed $950. That's a $3,300 swing in the wrong direction.

So, over the next year or so as the Bush tax cuts are debated, the phrases, "tax cuts for the rich" or "tax cuts for the wealthiest 1%" or any derivation thereof, are hereby banned.

Whistlebritches
Monday, September 8, 2008 8:07:00 PM
Agree wholeheartedly..........Obama screws the rich and the middle class.Redistribution of wealth to the non working freeloaders the dems so love.Isn't that the same as paying people to vote for you????

Ron

pacman357
Tuesday, September 9, 2008 1:48:00 AM
Where did you get these numbers? The amount of interest they are paying on the house, whether they purchased it that same year (thereby possibly taking advantage of additional deductions associated with the house purchase), how much they gave to charity, and whether they have enough deductions to rise to the level of "above the line" deductions all can affect how much tax they pay or refund they receive.

Tax rates in 1999 were 15%, 28%, 31%, 36%, and 39.6%

Tax rates in 2007 were the same in the lower brackets, but topped out at 35%. Thus, those in the highest tax brackets in 1999 would pay less in 2007 on the same amount of income.

Additionally, capital gains were taxed at a lower rate in 2007 for long-term capital gains and collectibles held for more than one year (they were lowered in 2003).

The most common capital gains are realized from the sale of stocks, bonds, precious metals and property. This is generally the realm of more wealthy citizens, since poor people have a tough time buying any such assets, and lower middle class incomes (such as a household of five earning $45,000) can't really afford much of that type of assets either.

Add to that the fact that we are missing other specifics in your example, such as whether the family includes a married couple or persons cohabitating, whether (if married) the adults are filing jointly or separately, and whether they qualify for any special tax credits, then your example is painfully lacking in any real numbers, and your argument that a family that is likely to be struggling to make ends meet on that money (depending on where they live) has nothing to do with how much money corporations and wealthy taxpayers pay, well...

you really haven't proven a damned thing about your "Intersting Tax Facts".

pacman357
Tuesday, September 9, 2008 1:50:00 AM
BTW, even if you had provided any sort of reasonable analysis, I doubt anyone here would abide your "banned subjects" proclamations. Or did you also purchase these boards along with wheelrite?
pacman357
Tuesday, September 9, 2008 2:49:00 AM
I just realized part of my response was inartfully worded. Whether they have enough deductions to make it worth their while to itemize (vs. taking the standard deduction) will affect how much tax they pay or refund they receive, with "above the line" deductions being more helpul.
ticklestick
Tuesday, September 9, 2008 3:49:00 AM
Could a couple whose income is 45K a year with 3 kids even afford a house?
herfidore
Tuesday, September 9, 2008 6:06:00 AM
^ What he said. And why in the hell do they have 3 kids that they can't afford?
neopuritan
Tuesday, September 9, 2008 6:13:00 AM
^ The Bible says, "Be fruitful, and multiply..."

First commandment in the Bible.

JPR
  • JPR
  • Herf-A-Holic
Tuesday, September 9, 2008 6:21:00 AM
I do several tax returns a year (used to do hundreds).

I can say from experience that we are taking a big risk tax-wise if we elect Obama. I haven't done an in depth analysis but between the returns that I prepare and my own, I have seen greater refunds in recent years, in all income categories, than I even have.

For that matter, the last 5 years, I am in better economic standing than I ever have been.

Again, I am not recommending any candidate or I haven't done any models to support that position (just from experience). However, I don't you guys have either.

Take it for what it is worth but I am a CPA and I might have some more experience than the others in this forum.

Thanks

herfidore
Tuesday, September 9, 2008 6:31:00 AM
Neo, it sure does. And that is certainly one way to look at it. My Bible of personal responsibility says don't have more kids than you can afford, thereby you will never need assistance from any government or charity.
delarob
Tuesday, September 9, 2008 6:36:00 AM
"Charity begins at home and justice begins next door," - Charles Dickens
Sardious
Tuesday, September 9, 2008 7:06:00 AM
It is OK they will pay 990 but he will increase welfare and give them free health insurance so they will still be in the positive
jojoc
Tuesday, September 9, 2008 7:58:00 AM
I would be willing to be that the calculations were based off the published IRS "average" deductions for taxpayers in that income bracket.

here is a link to numbers based on 2004.

http://www.cch.com/wbot2007/026AvgItemizedDeductions.asp 

the problem is, the average is based off of all returns in that income bracket who actually claimed an itemized deduction for that category, without factoring in all of the returns that were zero. As such, the "average" is an average of the deductions claimed, not the average amount that all taxpayers in that bracket received.

Most families of 5 at 45,000 would not itemize.

Using the 2004 "average" of $17,981 and assuming the family contributed 8,000 to a traditional IRA (the max.) the family would qualify for the following deductions:

Personal Exemptions: 3400 x 5= 17,000

IRA Contribution: 8,000

Itemized Deductions: 17,981

Total: 42,981

leaving a taxable income of: 2,019

Tax due: $201

Assuming the 2007 itemized deduction averages were higher, you might get to 0 tax. In order to get the refund claimed above, the family would have to qualify for the earned income credit, or some other "refundable" credit. none of the deductions above, even if significantly larger, would generate a refund.

Assuming that the family has a qualifing child, and the family made the 8,000 IRA contribution, it would receive the earned income credit, and actually receive a refund without paying any tax in. So, in theory the numbers stated above work.

the problem is this family after paying the itemized deduction expenses (including the 7.5% cut for medical) and the IRA contribution will have 23,206 to live off of. out of that the family would have to pay the principal payment on the mortgage, insurance, food, transportation, credit card interest, child care, entertainment, utilities, etc.

the reality is that the family can not afford to make the 8000 IRA contribution. without that, the family does not qualify for the earned income credit and gets no refund.

just my .04

borndead1
Tuesday, September 9, 2008 8:44:00 AM
For tax year 2007 this household would pay $0 in federal income tax. In fact, not only would they pay $0, but they would get over $2400 from the federal government. This is not money being refunded to them - it's free money from the government.

-----------------------------------------------

So lemme get this straight...you advocate this? Getting free (MY) money from the federal government? It doesn't make sense...you are advocating socialistic policies but are anti Obama, who is a socialist.

PecanPi1
Tuesday, September 9, 2008 9:47:00 AM
QUOTE:

"...Obama screws the rich and the middle class.

Redistribution of wealth to the non working freeloaders the dems so love."

This has been the Democratic agenda for the last 80 years, but particularly so in the post-WW2 era.

Roosevelt legitimized it during the depression; other dems recognized the popularity of give-aways and made them planks in every Dem presidential platform ever launched since then.

The wrinkle now is, with burgeoning lower classes, the middle class will be squeezed even harder until the lower classes "come on stream," go to work, and fund their own social welfare programs.

The rich are bulletproof and always have been.

The middle class is targeted because it is the least organized and least vocal about its raping.

pacman357
Tuesday, September 9, 2008 11:40:00 AM
Obama's tax plans may indeed be problematic. I just don't see how a household of 4 or 5 living on $45K a year constitutes "rich" unless maybe they're living in Uganda or something.
HockeyDad
Tuesday, September 9, 2008 11:41:00 AM
Tax them anyway. We need to be worrying about those making $25K a year. It is all relative!
big chief
Tuesday, September 9, 2008 11:45:00 AM
Pac, 16,

At $45k in Uganda, they would be 'President For Life'.

Homebrew
Tuesday, September 9, 2008 11:46:00 AM
Have you actually read Obamas tax plan?????

I think not.

I will not be voting for Obama, or McCain, as both are too liberal to me. We can vote for a tax and spend liberal, or a borrow and spend liberal. Either way we get the shaft.

Vote Libertarian, the only party that TRUELY is for less government.

The Two Major Parties, are playing Ya'll like a fiddle.

Dave (A.K.A. Homebrew)

DrMaddVibe
Tuesday, September 9, 2008 11:48:00 AM
#7...they were PUNISHED!