I got to looking thru my cigars and tried to figure out which one is far and away the most coveted cigar I own.

As near as I can tell I have a ISO Romeo y Julieta Churchill that is 15-18 years old in a very protective aluminum tube.

I rate it my most prized cigar based in part on age and it has been very well kept.

I'm in the minor leagues, but I have two Anejos, one of which is a Shark, that al'Thor forced me to take from him. Because I know they are from him, they top my list.

The one in my mouth.

I have one Hemingway Classic Sungrown...awesome cigar but can't find anymore. So I can't smoke it...

Hmmmmmmmmm,

I have most of CAs top 20 and they're all good, I think I would say my favotite is the PAM (1964). Trinidads and Monte 2s are second, and FF O X is third.

Fritz

Just bought a few 'holiday' cigars: Ashton VSG Torpedo, Diamond Crown Maximus Toro #4, and I've had the Fuente Between the Lines for some time now. I'll have to go with the Diamond Crown though.

For now...

a 3 yr old swisher sweet! 😛

I have FFOXs, PAMs, PANs, and VSGs at just about any given time. But I am bad (or good, depending on who you ask) about smoking them within a year or so of purchase. Don't have any ISOMs in stock. Too chicken to buy them, so I only get them gifted very occasionally. Again, I smoke 'em within a year or less. I guess I'm a really poor collector. But a fanstastic consumer!

I have an original AF Anejo (no cedar, no ribbon).

A friend gave me a Punch Churchill Habana that was the last of a box he smoked, so it was in his humidor for, I am guessing, 3-4 years and has been in mine for a year.

A 1996 FFOX "A". X

A hand-rolled ISOM made by Rodolfo Taboada....one of the best rollers in the World. It is by far the best cigar I have. It's value to me, is Wayyyy over 100 bucks.

ISOM Cohiba EL 2001 takes a far away second place.

DC Maximus

WOAM

PAM Torp

Anejo Sharks

Perdomo Edicion De Silvio

858 SGrown 2001

858 SGrown 2002

858 SGrown Rosada

...and a bunch of others that are top-shelfers....but not nearly the best I own.

billy, you make me all warm and fuzzy inside...but you better smoke that puppy, there's always more where it came from!!!

As my collection is still a young pup, I have a few that I would like to hold on to for a while before smoking - nothing too amazing just yet - I'd say my most prized cigar right now is the one that I'm giving out w/ the bands that I made for my son's birth. The band looks like crap, the cigar is pretty good, but the sentiment is what makes it special...

Without a doubt my favorite cigar is the Cuban Cohiba, so I would have to say that one. I have a few of them left.

Next would probably be the AF Anejo 77 "Shark" I got from DrMaddVibe. I have it onboard the ship with me right now in my baby humi, so it will be toasted sometime in the next 2 weeks.

Last would be the Stoie's Stogie 7 year aged Robustos I got. Only 4 of them left.

ISOM Cohiba, Fonseca, and Partagas 150

My last Padron Millenium is one of my most cherished. Only 996 years untill the next release.

My last Cuban Punch Churchill from 1998 probably rates as my second most cherished cigar. I could probably replace it but not cheaply or easily.

There are plenty of others that are dear to me, but they could all be replaced in time if I really wanted to try.

Barry

Probably a PAM Torpedo since I only have 1. Got a box of Exclusivos on the way. Got some ISOMs too and they are great, but I've not yet run into a cigar that beats a PAM.

my favorite cigar,

would be one of the many HarleyDave sent me today.

my first arturo fuente between the lines.

i have plenty of top shelf, and plenty of isom.

but only one BTL.

so that is my favorite.

hdking

Mine would have to be my Opus "Toast Across America" cigar.

I also have a Camacho Liberty that was gifted to me by my good buddy Ethan that I am waiting for the right time to smoke... Maybe at his son's birth I will finally give it a try.

I love having favorite cigars around but I love sharing them even more...

Vegas Robaina "Famosos" 08/00