jimmy@ctconnect.com
Friday, September 19, 2008 10:04:00 AM
- just trying to get some other perspectives on this issue .. I've already got an opinion (like you didn't expect that, right?) and I'm just curious of what/how some others feel.

First, it would help to know if you've ever been in the military or not.

Second: In your opinion, should he be awarded the MOH or SS?

DrafterX
Friday, September 19, 2008 10:09:00 AM
Who the heck told you newbies that you could have a poll???!!
Goathead50
Friday, September 19, 2008 10:10:00 AM
Present!
8trackdisco
Friday, September 19, 2008 10:12:00 AM
No military background.

Which is probably why I have no idea what you are talking about.

tdtall70
Friday, September 19, 2008 10:15:00 AM
Desert Shield/Storm Army vet (3rd generation).

I really don't know which award his mother should be presented with.

jimmy@ctconnect.com
Friday, September 19, 2008 10:15:00 AM
Re: #1

It may help if I add the link:

http://www.foxnews.com/story/0,2933,425143,00.html 

(must be a noob mistake)

tdtall70
Friday, September 19, 2008 10:15:00 AM
Fargin' noobs.....
jojoc
Friday, September 19, 2008 10:16:00 AM
who?
pgje51
Friday, September 19, 2008 10:28:00 AM

no military background here either.

With that said, I have to believe that the military has both due process as well as precedence to sort out the decision.

DrMaddVibe
Friday, September 19, 2008 10:51:00 AM
Yes. US Army

Seeing as how the President even cited his heroism, how can you NOT award the soldier the MoH?

Buckwheat
Friday, September 19, 2008 10:56:00 AM
No military experience here. First off, you didn't really ask a yes or no question. You asked a "this or that" question. I think that if there is a doubt as to the specifics of what happened then they shouldn't award the MOH. Particularly, given that the accounts of the events dramtically differ in what happened.
DrMaddVibe
Friday, September 19, 2008 11:02:00 AM

Mother of Marine Who Fell on Enemy Grenade to Make Son's Case for Medal of Honor

Thursday , September 18, 2008

CAMP PENDLETON, Calif. —

The mother of a Marine who witnesses say covered a grenade with his body to save comrades in Iraq plans to appeal to Congress to award her son the nation's highest military honor after learning it was denied by Defense Secretary Robert Gates because of questions about his final act.

Rosa Peralta said Thursday she made the decision after a Marine general told her that her son, Sgt. Rafael Peralta, would be awarded the Navy Cross rather than the Medal of Honor because the nomination was tainted by reports he was accidentally shot by a fellow Marine shortly before an insurgent lobbed the grenade.

"I'm going to see what can be done, because I'm not satisfied with what they want to do now," she said in Spanish.

President Bush singled out the Marine's actions in a 2005 Memorial Day speech, saying Peralta "understood that America faces dangerous enemies, and he knew the sacrifices required to defeat them."

"The president spoke of him. So how is this now possible that they do this," Rosa Peralta said.

She said she was considering rejecting the Navy Cross, the second-highest award for valor in combat that can be awarded to a Marine. Peralta will be the 24th recipient of the Navy Cross for actions in Iraq and Afghanistan.

"I still don't know what I'm going to do," she said.

The question about whether to award Peralta the Medal of Honor centers on whether the mortally wounded Marine, who was shot in the head and upper body, could have intentionally reached for the grenade and covered it with his body.

"There was conflicting evidence in the case of Sgt. Peralta as to whether he could have pents, Peralta lay mortally wounded on the floor of a house and grabbed a grenade lobbed by fleeing insurgents. His body absorbed the blast and he died immediately.

In a rare move, the Marine Corps Thursday released a redacted copy of the Medal of Honor nomination by Lt. Gen. Richard Natonski and a investigative report detailing the "friendly fire" shooting of the sergeant.

The report found sufficient evidence existed to believe that Peralta was probably shot by a fellow Marine and that a gunshot wound to the head and injuries to the head from a grenade caused his death.

The nomination, which relies on witness statements, forensics, bomb fragment analysis and an autopsy, concluded that although Peralta was shot in the head, he made "a conscious, heroic decision to cover the grenade and minimize the effects he knew it would have on the rest of his Marine team."

The nomination details Peralta's actions in the final minutes of his life, with several witnesses recounting how the Marine lay face down and used his arm to pull the grenade to him. It also says a forensic analysis of Peralta's clothing and flak jacket show the grenade was underneath him when it exploded.

Peralta, who was assigned to Hawaii's 1st Battalion, 3rd Marine Regiment, moved to San Diego from Tijuana as a teenager. He was 25.

There are two distinct protocols for awarding the Medal of Honor. The first and most common is nomination by a service member in the chain of command, followed by approval at each level of command. The other method is nomination by a member of Congress (generally at the request of a constituent) and approval by a special act of Congress. In either case, the Medal of Honor is presented by the President on behalf of the Congress.

[edit] Evolution of criteria

Several months after President Abraham Lincoln signed Public Resolution 82 into law on December 21, 1861, a similar resolution for the Army was passed. Six Union soldiers who hijacked the General, a Confederate locomotive were the first recipients. Raid leader James J. Andrews, a civilian hanged as a Union spy, did not receive the medal. Many Medals of Honor awarded in the 19th century were associated with saving the flag, not just for patriotic reasons, but because the flag was a primary means of battlefield communication. During the time of the Civil War, no other military award was authorized, and to many this explains why some seemingly less notable actions were recognized by the Medal of Honor during that war. The criteria for the award tightened after World War I. In the post-World War II era, many eligible recipients might instead have been awarded a Silver Star, Navy Cross or similar award.

During the Civil War, Secretary of War Edwin M. Stanton promised a Medal of Honor to every man in the 27th Regiment, Maine Infantry who extended his enlistment beyond the agreed upon date. Many stayed four days extra, and then were discharged. Due to confusion, Stanton awarded a Medal of Honor to all 864 men in the regiment.[21]

In 1916, a board of five Army generals convened by law to review every Army Medal of Honor awarded. The commission, led by Nelson Miles, recommended that the Army rescind 911 medals. This included the 864 medals awarded to members of the 27th Maine, 29 who served as Abraham Lincoln's funeral guard, six civilians (including Dr Mary Edwards Walker, the only woman to have been awarded the medal), Buffalo Bill Cody, and 12 others whose awards were judged frivolous. Dr. Walker's medal was restored posthumously by President Jimmy Carter in 1977.[21] Cody's award was restored in 1989.[22]

Early in the 20th century, the Navy awarded many Medals of Honor for peacetime bravery. For instance, seven sailors aboard the USS Iowa received the medal when a boiler exploded on January 25, 1904. Aboard the USS Chicago in 1901, John Henry Helms received the medal for saving Ishi Tomizi, the ship's cook, from drowning. Even after World War I, Richard Byrd and Floyd Bennett received the medal for exploration of the North Pole.[23] Thomas J. Ryan received it for saving a woman from the burning Grand Hotel in Yokohama, Japan following the 1923 Great Kant? earthquake.[24]

Tiffany Cross version of the Medal of HonorBetween 1919 and 1942, the Navy issued two separate versions of the Medal of Honor, one for non-combat bravery and the other for combat-related acts. Official accounts vary, but generally the non-combat Medal of Honor was known as the Tiffany Cross, after the company that manufactured the medal. The Tiffany Cross was first issued in 1919 but was rare and unpopular, partly because it was presented both for combat and noncombat events.[25] As a result, in 1942, the United States Navy reverted to a single Medal of Honor, awarded only for heroism.[26]

Since the beginning of World War II, the medal has been awarded for extreme bravery beyond the call of duty while engaged in action against an enemy. Arising from these criteria, approximately 60% of the medals earned during and after World War II have been awarded posthumously.[27] Capt. William McGonagle is an exception to the enemy action rule, earning his medal during the USS Liberty incident, which the Israeli government claimed was friendly fire.[28][29]

jetblasted
Friday, September 19, 2008 11:22:00 AM
He, who ?
jimmy@ctconnect.com
Friday, September 19, 2008 11:27:00 AM
chiefburg
Friday, September 19, 2008 11:33:00 AM
I'm in the military. The MOH is the ultimate award and is reserved for documented acts of bravely above and beyond the call of duty. From reading this article, there appears to be some doubt by the officials making the decision and the witnesses.

In this case, you have to go with the folks who have the whole story (or inside story) of what really happened. Anything less will devalue those who have undoubtedly earned theirs in the past.

Sounds like this doesn't really require a vote afterall. . .

Thunder.Gerbil
Friday, September 19, 2008 11:37:00 AM
One ex-Navy guy checking in here.

I'm sure the Fox news story isn't presenting all the pertinant info so I really can't say.

jojoc
Friday, September 19, 2008 12:32:00 PM
no military service.

without seeing the whole report, I would not venture to say yes or no. however, I feel that to reject the Navy Cross would be wrong. being awarded the MOH will not bring him back.

MACS
Friday, September 19, 2008 1:57:00 PM
20 year Navy Vet.

I say the Navy Cross is probably sufficient. The people making the decisions are privvy to the ENTIRE report. We are not.

However... in the case of the Navy SEAL who did the same thing (Michael Monsoor) and was awarded the MoH, I was deployed with that team and heard the account, firsthand, of what happened.

He was not wounded at all and he fell on the grenade, knowing full well it would kill him. This action may have been downgraded (I am purely speculating, I have no idea) because he might have known he was about to die anyway.

Since we don't know the whole story, how can we say for sure? If his comrades, who were there, feel he deserves it, he should get it.

Goathead50
Saturday, September 20, 2008 5:56:00 AM
^
burgess_b
Saturday, September 20, 2008 7:08:00 AM
agree with MACS' last sentence entirely. the guys that were there are the only ones that truly know what happened.