We actually export gasoline to Mexico because they don't have enough refineries....and PEMEX is a horrible company.
Our dependency on foreign oil won't change because it is still cheaper for Exxon to drill for oil in Nigeria than in ultra deepwater off the US Coast that maybe Congress will open up for drilling. The business model of all US oil companies is to find the cheapest oil in the world regardless of national boundaries. We would have to nationize the oil industry to change that and a nationalized US oil industry whose sole purpose is to use US-only crude oil will mean much higher prices as we drill for expense oil at home instead of cheap oil abroad.
Something everyone loses sight of with the US oil industry is that exploration programs are all worldwide in scope. Exoon isn't going to drill in 12,000 of water in the Gulf of Mexico to produce oil at $100 a barrel in raw cost when they can drill and produce oil in Iraq for $20 a barrel. Shell or Chevron will go grab that $20 oil instead and Exxon can't stay in business.
All the talk about opening up US oil drilling is just a nationalistic, anti-foreign smokescreen. If you are the executive of a US oil company and your staff comes to you for $5 billion dollars for a drill program off California that will net cost $100 a barrel or an equivalent program off Brazil that will net cost $50 a barrel including tanker costs, or an equivalent program in Iraq that will cost $20 a barrel, you have a business decision to make. It is possible that political stability might make you spread your dollars in Iraq and Brazil but that "go-USA" $100 oil isn't gonna happen.