From another Steve*R.
Cigar manufacturers are extremely hush-hush about the statistical sales of their brands and blends.
While I've never seen numbers, it's pretty well accepted that Macanudo remains the #1 selling cigar in the U.S., and, it, of course, is very mild. RyJ, Partagas, H.Upmann, Don Diego, and Montecristo in their mildest blends are also acclaimed best sellers.
CBid, it appears, has many closeouts which were made during the boom, but didn't sell, and have rested in warehouses for years. Brands like Colinas, 1876 Reserve, Costa Rican Especiales, Cumbres, Don Felo, Eladios,