jojoc
  • jojoc
  • Herf-A-Holic Topic Starter
Monday, September 22, 2008 12:44:00 PM
http://www.cnsnews.com/public/content/article.aspx?RsrcID=32368 

what say you? for or against a school voucher program?

daveincincy
Monday, September 22, 2008 12:56:00 PM
I didn't read the article, but if it pertains to shipping kids from different districts I'd say I'm against it. For the most part, it probably means busing in kids from inner cities to the suburbs. And, well, I don't think it's a good idea. Around here the lower ranked schools (usually inner city) keep asking for more money, and the gubmint keeps throwing money at them thinking it's going to improve their situation. Unfortunately, you still have parents that don't care much to contend with. If they aren't interested in their kids education, sending them to another school isn't going to help, except for the fact those kids will be in a school with other kids (and parents) that value education.

...and if none of my response applies to the article then I guess you know how I feel about vouchers from a different perspective. 🙂

rfenst
Monday, September 22, 2008 12:56:00 PM
Against school vouchers that can be used to attend private schools.
jojoc
  • jojoc
  • Herf-A-Holic Topic Starter
Monday, September 22, 2008 1:01:00 PM
rfenst hit it on the head.

the article discusses Obama bashing McCain for supporting vouchers that would allow parents to choose what school (including private) their children go to. However, Obama's solution to the failing public school system is more money dumped into the system. Although Obama does seem to also support more charter schools.

jpotts
Monday, September 22, 2008 1:02:00 PM
Michigan has a "schools of choice" program, with is somewhat like a a voucher.

We live in a good city, but our school district is terrible. So, we put our kids in the lottery of for a "school of choice" and they now go to one of the best schools in Michigan.

Consequently, a lot of people in this perticular bad school district, have done the same thing. The city in question is predominantly black, and they are sending their kids out of the city to get a good education.

In short: this is positive for low to moderate-income minorities who live in crappy school districts.

So, I'm all for allowing parental choice into the equation when it comes to education.

As for school vouchers: one politician noted a potential issue with such a system. School vouchers are tied to government funds, and thus those school districts that want to "cash in" on the vouchers outside students bring into their systems, they mat become hamstrung by the various strings attached to these funds (because that's how government regulates your life by attaching strings to tax dollars). So the best recommendation is to implement a tax refund to those people who send their children out of district. That way, the government cannot regulate where that money goes after it reaches your bank account.

jpotts
Monday, September 22, 2008 1:03:00 PM
The fact is:

1) They're your kids.

2) It's your money.

daveincincy
Monday, September 22, 2008 1:20:00 PM
(just read part of the article...I guess I'm an Obama supporter now LOL)

We send our kids to a private school. I'd love to be able to take some of my tax dollars that go to our local public schools and be able to use it towards the tuition we pay, but I don't think that's gonna happen. I guess that's the price you pay for living in an area with good schools and high property taxes, even though we still went the private school route. I guess I don't fully understand the school voucher system. I can understand McCain's position in being able to send children to another district when the child's current district is failing, and how it can force schools to improve (or close?). Around here a lot of the money being requested is to improve the actual schools in terms of renovations (buildings in poor condition, installing a/c, etc), not teacher salaries and books...things that actually go towards improving education. If school vouchers were allowed, however, I think you'd have a big influx of students into other schools that would create quite a disruption. That gets back to students and parents that really don't place much value on education, and the parents would take advantage of the vouchers thinking there's better teachers somewhere else to raise and discipline their kids as if it's the teacher's responsibility.

HockeyDad
Monday, September 22, 2008 1:32:00 PM
The government should not be running schools at all. Just another set of rights and responsibilities that have been given away.
jimmy@ctconnect.com
Monday, September 22, 2008 1:39:00 PM
Against school vouchers ...

- if you want to send your kids to private school, then by all means, do so - but do it at your own expense. There is no real savings by removing 10 children from a school of 600 ... so why should the school budget have to shell out $60k or more to reimburse the parents for private school?

- also, let's quit shipping in children from other towns to bring diversification to our schools ... I moved here so my kids CAN go to this school, not so that some other kids from the projects can come here and sell dope or to have to be selected at random to have my kids have to go to a ghetto school ...

Let's quit wasting taxpayers dollars on programs that do not benefit everyone.

The next thing in line will be giving the "school voucher" money to the "home schooling welfare mothers" because she "homeschools Johhny" and that's why he's not in school!

tdtall70
Monday, September 22, 2008 1:43:00 PM
We took my son out of a school that was underachieving, and put him in a charter school. It’s not private, but at least the parents give a rat’s ass about their kids’ edumacation. They ask us to donate a certain amount per student- some do, some try to. His old school was becoming full of Hispanics that couldn’t even speak English- which was becoming more of a problem each year. I’ve heard parents actually tell the teachers that it wasn’t their job to read to their own kids! Now, it’s almost like a big family (which has its own problems, of course). But at least now my son is with other “overachieving” kids that have parents that speak the language/care for their children’s education. So, I’m kind of against vouchers, unless it means better students/parents having better opportunities.

“High achievement always takes place in the framework of high expectation”.

DaQueenBeez
Monday, September 22, 2008 1:52:00 PM
Okay, I'm sure I'm missing something important here but....I pay the same taxes as everyone else in my town. When a school bond is passed, It costs me as much as it does everyone else. However, my kids see none of the benefit of those $$$ because we pay for them to go to a private school. How is it unfair for school vouchers to be used for private schools? From my perspective, it's unfair that I have to pay for two schools - one for my kids and one for my neighbor's kids.

Tammy

DaQueenBeez
Monday, September 22, 2008 1:56:00 PM
I might also mention that every high school in our district FAILED to meet standards again this year. The rest of the schools in the district are either failing as well, or not much better. It really warms my heart to see all those tax dollars that benefit me not one bit being put to SUCH good use.

Tammy

jojoc
  • jojoc
  • Herf-A-Holic Topic Starter
Monday, September 22, 2008 2:09:00 PM
I have mixed feelings on a voucher program. I like the concept of parents being able to choose the school their child will go to (public/private/charter) and end up with some public funds being allocated to that school as a result. However, I would hate to see good schools get stuck with all of the "strings" that fed/state funding could bring along.

in my home town, a charter school opened a number of years ago. it has a great program on a small budget (compared to the district schools). The two district high schools have improved some as a result of many of their top students choosing the charter school.

I like the idea of the voucher, but seems like charter schools are a more realistic option for giving parents a choice. Also, the charter school is a public school, so it receives the same per child state funding as the district schools.

jimmy@ctconnect.com
Monday, September 22, 2008 2:19:00 PM
... it's a system that is getting abused, therefore, I am totally against it.

I need be, just move to another school district.

herfidore
Tuesday, September 23, 2008 6:51:00 AM
The voucher system is a great idea, and will be a reality one day. Just a thought, it takes $10,800 per student per year in public school. The same cost in private schools? $7,200. Why? Bureaucracy of course. Get the government out of education, and let the educators do their jobs.