Contempt? No.
Realist? Yes.
If you were older than twelve, you would be able to read what happened during the 80's, when marginal tax rates were lowered from 75% to 35%. The reverse is true, when marginal (sorry for the three syllable word, look it up) rates go back up productivity will go down.
He is calling 'em like they are. This is a matter of fact, and history. Sticking your head in the sand and saying "it ain't so" won't change that.