Smashed247
Saturday, October 18, 2008 5:12:00 PM
I know I had posted some questions before. I have some more questions/ need help.

A couple years ago I bought a road bike which I really enjoyed. It was a 56cm 2007, Trek 2100 (ZR).

While I enjoyed riding it, I found that I it was much easier for me to get to a trail. I just don't have great roads in my area for riding. The trail I ride on is mostly dirt, and has a little bit of gravel. I have taken my rode bike there but it is not a fun nor comfortable ride.

I was wondering about some bikes to explore. I am not sure if it is more beneficial to get a hybrid such as the Gary Fisher Mendota, or Trek 7.5 FX. Or a hardtail mountain bike. My main goal is fitness. I am also thinking that a hybrid may give me less of a workout. I would like some people's thoughts on this. I know some helped me out with thoughts on my Trek 2100 purchase.

05busa
Saturday, October 18, 2008 5:17:00 PM
You have to make it comfortable. Is the seat adjusted right---height & angle,is it the right size frame for you,do you have the right tires for your ground & last but not least are you wearing hot pants while you ride,HAAAAAA!!
andytv
Saturday, October 18, 2008 5:21:00 PM
I have a Giant "comfort" bike you can have.
Double D
Saturday, October 18, 2008 5:23:00 PM
I have a Cannondale Silkglide hybrid..most comfortable geometry of any bike I've ridden.
law492
Saturday, October 18, 2008 5:39:00 PM
^ You said, "My main goal is fitness." If that is the case, you may want to rethink your strategy completely and spring for something like a Schwinn Airdyne indoor machine. True you won't be out bouncing on trails but if you want a daily workout that's the ticket. I've been using my Airdyne for the past 12 years. I do 90 minutes days days a week on it. You pedal and pump with your arms at the same time. I've had two minor rebuilds and one major on it and I'm getting near the point of having to replace it as it is literally wearing out. I had a cheap DP model with the same action (pedal and pump) and I eventually broke it. I've been doing this for the past 16 years and I really enjoy it as I get a low joint impact workout and can still muster that "runner's high" with the correct audio cues (like some Lynard Skynard on the Street Walkman). My goal was a hard aerobic workout for cardio and endurance benefits as opposed to building muscle mass. BTW, good cardio equates to good circulation.I'm 58 and intend to keep up the 90 minute routine the rest of my life. I know it sounds like a big time commitment, I am usually up before 5 AM but it gets to be a happy and if I don't get my workout in first thing, I get cranky. It's a great stress reliever as well. I've worn out or sweat rotted all kinds of headsets but the best of all have been the Sony Street Walkman model which goes behind the head. When I have gone trail riding, it's really more fun when you have the leg muscles to do things you might have otherwise only done when you were a kid. Anyway, that's been my experience, good luck.
Gene363
Saturday, October 18, 2008 7:18:00 PM
A hybrid is not going to be as useful on trail. I like your hard tail mountain bike idea. The wider tires will do better on trail and it will ride fine on pavement. Not as efficient as a road bike but that helps a little on the work out side.

You may want a tire that is a little less aggressive/knobby to make it smoother on the road.

I have ridden my old Cannondale many miles on the road and enjoyed it very much. It also matched my speed closer to my wife when she was on her road bike.

MACS
Saturday, October 18, 2008 7:27:00 PM
Get a gym membership. They have all kinds of cardio equipment, so you can vary your routine.

You can lift weights, use the machines, or even join a spinning class. I'd bet the spinning class would kick your ass.

I understand the need to be outside, riding, too. My neighbor, Doug, used to ride all the time and sometimes I'd go with him. Very fun and very beneficial for the cardiovascular system... I can't see how you can do the same thing day after day after day and not want to climb a clock tower, though.

I like the variety the gym offers. Looking at the hot chicks in tight clothes is cool, too.

teedubbya
Saturday, October 18, 2008 7:27:00 PM
I am an ex cyclist that had to quit for health reasons..... and have approxipately 5 bikes (5 frames but probably not enough components to outfit them all)

My roadbike is my favorite. If your trails are dirt, small, technical etc then yes get a true mountain bike. I rarely did that kind of riding and have a fisher wahoo with little use.

If your trails are cinder, cement etc you may want to think about a cross country.... basically a glorified road bike with different gearing and larger tires etc....

I do have an actual hybrid I never liked.......

it really depends on what you want to do....

as for the airdyne.... I never got into riding inside even though I have rollers and a spinning bike (the one with the cast iron wheel and fixed gear.

Its a tough call.... when you look around what are others riding....and what does your local recommend?

8trackdisco
Saturday, October 18, 2008 7:30:00 PM
'..Cycling Question..'

----------------------------

I usually take the needle for about 6 weeks, then go off for two. I like looking natural.

teedubbya
Saturday, October 18, 2008 7:31:00 PM
helps beat the tests too

poppy73
Saturday, October 18, 2008 7:36:00 PM
hey smashed, I would recommend going to your LBS and talking to the guys there, they know the trails in your area better than anyone here. They should let you test ride any bike in the shop and when YOU decide what will keep you riding pay them to professionally fit the bike to you, may cost $100 for the fit but it will take a couple hours and be the best money you spend. Good luck!!!
teedubbya
Saturday, October 18, 2008 7:38:00 PM
agree on the fit (if they are good). Learned to do it myself with a little bit of help
Smashed247
Saturday, October 18, 2008 7:50:00 PM
Thanks for all the help.

To the suggestions about cardio/gym. I consider myself a gym rat, im there plenty. I used to be VERY into bodybuilding. As far as cardio, I utilize all the crap at the gym and run/train all year long. I have run several marathons. I don't consider myself a cyclist, I just like different scenery and versatility.

That said, im pretty set on a hybrid/commuter/city bike. I prefer straight handles, and also the shifting. The path requires larger tires then your road bike, but not so fat you need a hard tail. It is simply hard pan dirt. I don't know enough about the spec set-ups of bikes to know what is good and bad. I was just trying to get some ideas about which hybrids to consider. Buying a hybrid for me is similar to a non-cigar smoker going into a local. I don't want to walk out with a Macanudo. As I said, so far I like the Gary Fisher Mendota, and Trek 7.6 FX.

TV- I might take you up on that offer but, I want something on the quicker side. A frame and fat tires that you needed to support the weight of the rider would not be optimal for me. Thanks though.

teedubbya
Saturday, October 18, 2008 7:58:00 PM
smashed if they are reputable they will steer you right
Smashed247
Sunday, October 19, 2008 5:54:00 AM
Teedub,

One of the problems I run into is this. There are plenty of bike shops in my area. One sells only Trek, another only Gary Fisher, and so on. They aren't steering you in the wrong direction but they are selling you what THEY carry. That is the reason I was looking for some opinions.

teedubbya
Sunday, October 19, 2008 6:20:00 AM
understood..... although ulnless something has changed in the last year or so gary fisher is part of trek so your problem runs deeper 🙂

I never liked trek until I was liiking for a Giant team frame I was going to fit it with Campy. While looking I found an already fitted trek oclv with all campy and love it. Trek was like budweiser to me at the time..... but it is now my favorite bike.

My take is unless you are going elite (and I am not talking road bikes here cause I would add a few like bianchi, colnago, serotta etc)Trek, Specialized, Fisher, Giant, and a couple others will suit you fine.

Most components are going to be similar on similarly priced bikes. You are better served learning the shimano lines (or sram) and making sure your rear derailuer and shifters (imo) are what you want them to be and you can cut cost on front, brakes etc. Cheaper effects performance on the former but only weight on the latter.

If you generate a lot of power then you may worry about cranks etc.... but I'm talking extreme power. Not because of fear of breaking them but more for flex and loss of power..... if you are training rather than worrying about times probably a moot point.

In reality if you came up with a price range and looked at all the reputable brands you will find them similarly outfitted. Depending on your range some may have better rear derailueres than others but they all will most likely have the same front, cranks, brakes etc.

Then its about the frames. Again depending on $$ many of the frames accross brand are made at the same place (it used to be giant made most frames for all brands.... I think that has lessoned). (Mountain bikes have the front fork as another option..... it shocks... don't get me started on this its pandoras box)

My advice once you decided type of bike (which is worth discussing with any B&M) look around and find a cool frame. Make sure the rear d. is up to snuff and go crazy. Thats what I did with my Fisher wahoo and I love it..... (although I upgraded components from a Trek X000 sitting next to it.)

teedubbya
Sunday, October 19, 2008 6:21:00 AM
oh yea

and I found that while trek is like bud (everyone has them and they are not all that exciting as a result) they seem to have an economy of scale thing going and a nice balance of components and frame for the $..... in general.

teedubbya
Sunday, October 19, 2008 6:35:00 AM
I have an old heavy Giant cro moly (it was one of my first) frame that would be excellent for what you are doing. It would be excellent for training because it is heavier than hell (hard up hill.... but smooth anf fast downhill)

I'd give it to ya but it would need to be outfitted (which I do myself with odd components from all over) and I ride a 60cm so it would be too big. But something similar in aluminum could be had brand new for cheap. They are much MUCH cheaper than road bikes.

drop dead entry point on road bikes several years ago used to be 1G. For me it was 2. My good roadbike has about 5G in it.

Mountain and hybrids can be had at $400 I'd guess. and up fromthere for components etc.

go aluminum. you will not regret it. unless you want to spend $$ and do better

xddco
Sunday, October 19, 2008 6:44:00 AM
^

Aliminum is right.. I have a 20 year old Klein Pinnacle frame that I still take off road..... it rocks.

teedubbya
Sunday, October 19, 2008 7:09:00 AM
klein.... another I have always liked. love their paint jobs