usahog
  • usahog
  • Herf-A-Holic Topic Starter
Saturday, November 15, 2008 2:21:00 PM
anyone out there hunt with a crossbow?

because of my medical status.. I am entitled to this from the State...

I've applied to proper paperwork and documentation a few months back and should be hearing something back hopefully before next archery season... in the meantime... I will be looking for a good crossbow to purchase and do not have a clue as to what to look for/get??

any input would be greatly appriciated..

TIA

Hog

andytv
Saturday, November 15, 2008 2:26:00 PM
I say get a gun instead and spare the animal the agony of injury or slow death!
usahog
  • usahog
  • Herf-A-Holic Topic Starter
Saturday, November 15, 2008 2:31:00 PM
^ gun works fine..

I'm not one to pull the thing out of the box and go play elmer fudd in the woods...

Practice makes for better kill ratio...

Hog

andytv
Saturday, November 15, 2008 3:16:00 PM
Sorry......but this is a pet peeve of mine.

Bullets do an excellent job of dispatching quarry.....bolts are LESS effective by a huge margin.

Think of the impact energy of the two.

Killing a deer with an arrow or bolt is much like "stabbing" a deer; with a rifle, the velocity literally BLOWS UP the internals..............quick death.

My opinion is what it is because I am a landowner and I find deer every year that have died from starvation, infection, gangrene, etc from arrows. I have shot deer before that I had to dump because the entire body was infected as a result of an arrow from earlier in the season.

Now........one may say "I practice.....I am an expert". I have assisted such "experts" in trying to find deer that they stuck. The last occasion, we found it two months afterwards.......it was a good hit......a perfectly placed shot, but the deer lived for at least a few days after being hit by the sharp stick.

It sickens me. A responsible hunter has an obligation to use the BEST means possible to allow the animal to die with the least amount of pain (in my opinion).

The best tool for achieving this goal, and still preserving meat is the rifle.

usahog
  • usahog
  • Herf-A-Holic Topic Starter
Saturday, November 15, 2008 3:38:00 PM
Andy I totally understand about the landowner part...

my brother & sis-n-law own 54 acres one place and another 44 acres at another.. each season.. (shotgun) they find anywhere from 3-6 dead deer on their properties...

But, although an Arrow or bolt does not have velocity of a shotgun or high power rifle.. it all comes down to the hunter, not the weapon used...

I have seen bow hunted deer taken and it is not a slow death unless they were shot in the wrong area.. the broadhead arrows/bolts available today leave as much if not larger (bleed) area then shotgun and damn sure rifle (that is if the rifle was clean shot not hitting any bone/cartledge)

many hunters do not have a clue as to a deer's energy of flight after they hit it with any weapon... and 9 times out of 10 a hunter will not wait to go capture his kill... thus the flight/run of the deer... then it is either an unskilled or plain lazy hunter who will not attempt to track his game... even deer with heartshot can have the explosive "Flight" edrenelin (sp) to run up to a mile before realizing they were dead when initially hit...

Hog

usahog
  • usahog
  • Herf-A-Holic Topic Starter
Saturday, November 15, 2008 3:42:00 PM
a hunter will not wait to go capture his kill...

^ good rule of thumb is Wait 15-20 minutes after initial shot...before approching the area last spoted.. including if it was a drop on spot shot...

Hog

Whistlebritches
Saturday, November 15, 2008 3:50:00 PM
Some states,as in Hogs case(Illinois),have very short rifle/muzzleloader seasons.Yet their bow season may last for a month or more.I feel for the people of these states as well as the game.I am blessed to live in Texas where we have a month long bow season very few utilize and a 2 month gun season that assures if you need to fill the freezer it's almost a guarentee.

You can hunt with a crossbow/bow here during gun season but during bow season you would need a special permit due to some medical limitation to use a crossbow.

I personally believe in the 25-06 method myself.

Ron

andytv
Saturday, November 15, 2008 5:09:00 PM
Hog.......I still don't buy it. It is a matter of impact energy, accuracy, etc.

Put it this way.......if you had access to expert medical care what would you rather be shot with......a bullet or an arrow?

Ask yourself the same question if you DIDN'T have medical care and almost ANY injury could be fatal.

My neighbor is an EXPERT shot with a bow..........this guy has the latest greatest fastest bow and can group them in a 3" circle at forty yards.

The last deer he shot was a clean lung shot.........by the time we found it (months) it was rotten.

There is a reason why we don't use bows in warfare......they are not as effective as rifles. I have a deep respect for my quarry and feel that I should use the BEST method available to dispatch them cleanly.....and that is not a sharp stick.

Thunder.Gerbil
Saturday, November 15, 2008 5:18:00 PM
wtjvj
Saturday, November 15, 2008 5:27:00 PM
Andy, bow season has its ups and downs, but its still a season and hunters are allowed to hunt.

I`m sure you have seen some hunters with rifles that could not hit a garbage can at 50ft, so you could use the same argument about rifles.

So if you ask me would I rather be shot by a bow or a fifle, I guess that would depend on who was doing the shooting.

andytv
Saturday, November 15, 2008 5:36:00 PM
^ that argument doesn't hold water.

It boils down to this.....rifles are MORE deadly than bows..........period.

There are **** with bows and there are **** with rifles. Leave the **** out of the discussion (you can't prevent **** from hunting).

Bow hunters claim that the appeal of bow hunting is the "challenge".......which when diluted means that it is HARDER to kill a deer with a bow.

So...........by this logic, the bow hunter holds his own ego and his need for a challenge in higher regard than the animal's right to a humane death.

It's simple really, rifles kill better than bows. If anyone can prove otherwise, then I'd be ALL FOR a bow season.

In the meantime, I'll continue to collect deer off my property and burn their carcasses.......ones who have died slow painful deaths from arrows.

wtjvj
Saturday, November 15, 2008 5:51:00 PM
Today was oppening here, 250,000 hunters in the woods. 248,000 of them don`t have a clue. And I mean don`t have a clue.

During the bow season we have about 80% less hunters in the woods.

So if we look at the odds of how many deer are stuck with tooth picks and how many deer are missing limbs from the clueless,

Andy, I don`t hunt during rifle season any more, its not safe being in the woods for deer or humans, even on your own property. The **** have takin over.

andytv
Saturday, November 15, 2008 5:53:00 PM
^that's why I rarely hunt any more.
usahog
  • usahog
  • Herf-A-Holic Topic Starter
Saturday, November 15, 2008 6:24:00 PM
Ahem.. if your neighbor is an excellent shot and can group a 3" circle at 40 yrds.. why did the numb nutz choose a lung shot to begin with?

shooting a target and shooting a living breathing creature of nature.. is entirely a diffent platform all together and I do not care who the hells doing the shooting... everything changes when it's living/breathing

Hog

JadeRose
Saturday, November 15, 2008 6:30:00 PM
...and all this is why I do not hunt at all. I shot a big buck with a shotgun when I was young. It was not a clean hit. we followed the blood trail as far as we could but never found the deer. I felt so bad, I've never intentionally killed another animal. Not a tree hugger and have no issue with those who enjoy it. I just don't.
grmcooper
Saturday, November 15, 2008 7:57:00 PM
^^^Girl
JadeRose
Saturday, November 15, 2008 8:13:00 PM
Just leaving more for you out there in the MO timber cooper
diverbelow72
Sunday, November 16, 2008 2:34:00 AM
HOG, Welcome back brotha.

I am not a fan of Crossbows, only because some call it archery. Just my opinon though. I do think it is a nice alternative for those with disabilities.

As far as Andy's comments I must also disagree, with respect for him of course. I took up archery and bowhunting a few years back but haven't been recently due to no availability at my current duty location. While it is true that most bowhunters consider hunting with a bow more challenging, it has nothing to do with the necessity to put the perfect shot on an animal. Whether you hunt with a rifle, a shotgun, a pistol, a crossbow, or a bow (compound or traditional) , shot placement is critical. The challenge for most bowhunters is being able to either, get close enough to your intended future meal or draw it to you. Then, you must have the ability to slowly take aim, draw, and sometimes wait for the perfect window (shooting lane) to shoot so as not to spook the animal. To get within 20-40 yards (most archery hunters range) of a deer is not an easy task, then make limited movement/sound prior to geting off a shot is tough, more so than with a rifle. All a rifle hunter has to do is bring the rifle to his/her shoulder, take aim, release the safety and fire at distances up to 100+ yards. I have seen broadheads shatter bone, bore vitals and drop animals dead in their tracks...

Bottom line...shot placement is key no matter what you hunt with. Another reason I like archery is that you do not see many archery hunter take a shot a sound they heard 50 yards in front of them. Archery hunters for the most part have an actual visual on an animal and will only shoot a clear shot as we know a limb will send an arrow in the complete opposite direction, but with a bullet or buckshot, you have a chance at hitting the deer you think you saw, or was it a person? Am I against gun hunting? No, not at all. I just feel safer when I know that there is no one else out there with a gun when I am hunting. I will gun hunt as well when given the oppurtunity, but only on private property.

Just my two cents, this is a controvery that will live on long after my days, but this archery hunter will always take the best shot and do everything in my power to recover anything I shoot, if and when I ever get back to the world.

Diver

usahog
  • usahog
  • Herf-A-Holic Topic Starter
Sunday, November 16, 2008 4:43:00 AM
Thanks Diver... good to be back..

And also well stated.. that is what I was trying to say LOL...

I shot a doe so the heard wont grow...

We have about 2 months of bow season here in IL.. as whistle points out above...

Shotgun season we have two, 3 day weekends.. the second season is actually 4 days.. but that is it... then another muzzle loader/handgun season later..

I quit handguning because of it being so late and these doe's have already started their term with baby's...

I myself will not go into the woods not knowing what the hell I'm doing or how my weapon of choice will preform... I'm there for one thing... food for the freezer.. cannot chew the antlers and really do not care for the Bucks meat compared to doe meat.. doe's do not have the glands rush running through them and the meat is a bit more tender IMO...

Hog

andytv
Sunday, November 16, 2008 4:59:00 AM
Hog.....it might be a regional thing, but the lung shot is considered the high percentage kill shot here.....and if you ever get the chance to hunt in Germany, the ONLY acceptable shot among the traditionalists.