bloody spaniard
Tuesday, November 18, 2008 5:42:00 AM
And outlaw inhumane torture? Why not? Obama may be on to something.

Why torture with sleep deprivation, a little water boarding, empty threats, and lousy music? Then, we turn around & provide free room and board- food in observance of religious preference, companionship, prayer rugs/material, health care, etc. Hell, most of us should have it so good. Besides, over 50 of these harmless fellows have been freed & found fighting our troops again. The summer camp vacation must have reinvigorated them.

IMHO, kill most enemy combatants/insurgents/terrorists (take your pick) on the battlefield and turn the important ones over to the Egyptians who REALLY know how to make 'em sing 'n dance.

Either that or get ready to further clog up our courts defending their civil rights.

"Amerika, whata countreee!!"-- Yakov Smirnoff

Country
Tuesday, November 18, 2008 5:46:00 AM
If I was a pirate I'd anchor my ship just off the coast of the Guantanamo Bay.... and then this would never be a problem again.

Country

MCpapa
Tuesday, November 18, 2008 5:47:00 AM
Is it so much to ask that we comply with international agreements, laws, and basic human rights? Not getting the problem here.

Defending Guantanamo puts you on the lunatic fringe from any global, even national perspective.

andytv
Tuesday, November 18, 2008 5:49:00 AM
Close Gitmo, build a nice resort, and move the secret prison to one of the leper islands.
neopuritan
Tuesday, November 18, 2008 5:50:00 AM
Sure, close it. Put them on a plane w/ a computer pilot, fly directly over Cuba for a 60's vintage MIG to have target practice. If they don't go for it, shoot it down, and blame the Cubans anyway, be "outraged" and pontificate at the UN... and it will be old and forgotten news in a month.
lofty1
Tuesday, November 18, 2008 6:06:00 AM
"Is it so much to ask that we comply with international agreements, laws, and basic human rights? Not getting the problem here. "

yes, it is. it's like bringing a knife to a gunfight. these people don't recognize basic human rights. for that reason, they should not be afforded what we consider to be basic human rights.

andytv
Tuesday, November 18, 2008 6:11:00 AM
^most criminals do not recognize basic human rights.
MCpapa
Tuesday, November 18, 2008 6:15:00 AM
What a peculiar way of thinking about human rights: they only apply if you practice them. Huh. Terrible implications, of course. But I imagine you're more interested in blowing off steam than thinking carefully about this sort of question.
lofty1
Tuesday, November 18, 2008 6:25:00 AM
it's not about blowing off steam. it's not abandoning logic, as you imply. it's, in fact, quite logical. you're not going to stop the brainwashing machine that convinces this group to operate the way they do without using the same tactics they use.

tell you what, you can love these guys all you want while others torture them. let's see who gets answers first. since your dedication to human rights would dictate that you put them on the same level as yourself, we can assume you'll be killed by their hands immediately. now, the torturers may not get the information they need, but they'll live. technically, they didn't win the competition, but i'm still going to choose their team if i have to play.

RICKAMAVEN
Tuesday, November 18, 2008 6:49:00 AM
Yakov Smirnof

wow what a memory

RICKAMAVEN
Tuesday, November 18, 2008 6:51:00 AM
still more hose pucky about the morality and the effectiveness of torture.

only the ignorant thinks (assuming the ignorant are capable of thinking)torture works.

it doesn't and it demeans the authorities that allow it.

JDELLLL
Tuesday, November 18, 2008 7:18:00 AM
#3. Now why did I know that would be your take on it? The lesson learned is not to take any prisoners. And don't bother using the argument that "they'll do it to our guys". THEY DO. This country could be under a hopeless overwhelming attack and you liberals would still be screaming about human rights. Get your head out of the sand.
lofty1
Tuesday, November 18, 2008 7:22:00 AM
i wish i lived in the reality where everyone was civilized and no one meant harm on anyone else. i wish bad things didn't have to happen to good people.

unfortunately, where i live, bad things happen all the time. there are bad people. bad things sometimes need to happen to bad people for the sake of securing the welfare of the good. the truth isn't always pretty, and life flat out isn't fair, but i won't hide these truths from my children just because i don't like them.

law492
Tuesday, November 18, 2008 7:28:00 AM
^ 12 Don't argue with him, you don't understand, he has a degree in Sociology.
chiefburg
Tuesday, November 18, 2008 7:30:00 AM
Whether you like to believe it or not, torture does work in many cases. It's unfortunate that it has to come to this but it is a necessary evil from time to time.

I can't say I'm fond of the whole torture thing but I am a realist and understand it has its place. As I've said here before, terrorists aren't willing to give up their secret plans just because you give them coffee and donuts - it doesn't work that way. Some of the freedom you enjoy today was achieved by means you don't support.

It's ugly, unfortunate and not for the weak of heart. But, it does have its place and has gone on since the beginning of time. We certainly wouldn't need to do this in a perfect world, but we aren't in a perfect world.

JonR
Tuesday, November 18, 2008 7:30:00 AM
Yo littler than most:

Torture does work, you prove that it does work every time you post. 98.6% of the people on this board say reading your posts is equivalent to being water-boarded.

JonR

snowwolf777
Tuesday, November 18, 2008 7:51:00 AM
Truly amazing. Some folks should never stop playing video games and watching Spongebob. Stay in that magic unicorn and rainbows fantasy world and let the adults handle the adult problems.

The people we're engaging on the battlefield know nothing of Geneva Convention. They are religious fanatics, bent on the worldwide extermination of anyone who doesn't see it their way. Quite evident in their use of knives to cut off prisoner's heads while they videotape it. Watch a couple of those. With the sound turned on. Then come cry your San Fransisco wine and cheese party BS about waterboarding and sleep deprivation.

JDELLLL
Tuesday, November 18, 2008 7:51:00 AM
#14. Yes, now I remember. I'm sorry. My mistake. For the future, I must rememer that HE HAS A DEGREE IN SOCIOLOGY. He also has a screw loose.
Charlie
Tuesday, November 18, 2008 8:13:00 AM
Why accord human rights to someone/somebody who is not even remotely humanane in any way.

These people are terrorist, do you do gooders miss this point? They cut American citizen's heads off to advance their cause and they use children to deliver bombs into crowded areas such as cafes where families are enjoying themselves.

Why would anybody defend this lower than fish crap on the bottom of an aquarium? They are murderous trash with one goal in mind destroy the USA and Europe......they do not care if you are a liberal or a conservative...you are an American and that is enough for them...KILL us all and they would be happy.

Rights, they should have no rights. They really do follow the Geneva Convention LOL, what a bunch of mindless fools some folks are to whine and cry for these terrorist.

Charlie

bloody spaniard
Tuesday, November 18, 2008 8:13:00 AM
My point being that I agree w/Obama for different reasons. Why continue Guantanamo if it is a weather vane for negative PR? The prisoners probably see it as a reprieve from battle as their lawyers line up to protect their rights. Fruitful "interrogations" of enemy captured are already probably being done by CIA operatives and their allies throughout the middle east.

However, I would maintain a force there if nothing else but to irritate the despot, Fidel.