MCpapa
  • MCpapa
  • Connoisseur Topic Starter
Sunday, December 7, 2008 4:07:00 AM
I'm sure this has been done here, but why not ask again after his awesome performance yesterday.

Will Tebow be a legit NFL QB, or destined to be another (albeit very special) version of Wuerffel, Frazier, even Vince Young?

I don't see him as an NFL player. Slow delivery, no real zip on his passes, and not nearly athletic enough to step out and be either a back or tight end. As well, the super Christian mentality - weird homeschooling and all - won't make him a good fit for the culture of the NFL. For better or worse, you gotta fit in a little bit. I can't see him fitting in.

I might be wrong. He seems like an A+ kid, so I hope I am wrong. But even as I watched him dominate 'bama (yes!) in the 4th quarter, I couldn't transpose him onto the NFL turf.

Thoughts?

andytv
Sunday, December 7, 2008 4:10:00 AM
I think Tebow can succeed in any venue so long as nobody has kryptonite.
Sunday, December 7, 2008 4:15:00 AM
Part of the problem with young QBs is that they are rushed to start way before they are ready. I remember years ago when someone like Tebow would sit on the bench for 3 years before earning a start. They often developed well and became good/great QBs. There are always exceptions, but now too many are rushed to the front lines too soon.

c3s

IUROX
Sunday, December 7, 2008 4:16:00 AM
I think Tebow could start on several NFL teams NOW!

He is a hell of a motivator,I love his energy.

He could have 2 titles and 2 Heismans. Looks at how many teams could use a good QB. Plus several are reaching the end of their career.

I do live in Florida but rarely watch the Gators, his year I have tuned more often,mostly because of Tebow.

I think he would be nuts not to go for the draft.

MCpapa
  • MCpapa
  • Connoisseur Topic Starter
Sunday, December 7, 2008 4:34:00 AM
I think the kryptonite is basically faster linebackers (try running in the NFL...he'll get crushed) and so much better DBs. Slow delivery and lack of zip. How many times have we looked backwards and said, yeah, we shoulda seen the flop coming?

I think his best bet is as a tight end. That way, he can use his running skills and power, but beef up in the first couple of years in the NFL.

Not sure the homeschooled personality will translate to the NFL. He's tough and reasonably skilled, but do you see those weak passes making connections in the NFL? Really? I mean, "character" and "motivation" mean little in the NFL, with the skill and speed. I've not yet seen that skill and speed from Tebow.

Whistlebritches
Sunday, December 7, 2008 4:51:00 AM
I think Tebow is definately NFL quality........and as for his,and I quote MCpapa

"the super Christian mentality - weird homeschooling and all - won't make him a good fit for the culture of the NFL."

The NFL needs more young men just like Tebow to change this NFL culture.This CULTURE is ruining the sport.......it's getting as bad as the NBA and turning into the WWF.Don't get me wrong there are some fine young men in the NFL..............it's the 30-40% of absolute asholes that are ruining the face of the NFL.$$$ has ruined the game as well,they literally hand over millions to kids that have 0 self discipline.There are so few actual role models in the game anymore I hate to see kids attracted to it.Tebow with his CHRISTIAN MENTALITY and that whole HOME SCHOOL thing is just what the NFL needs for future role models,provided he's not corrupted by the whole system as well.I've personally given up on professional sports for the most part with the exception of the NHL.......and some of the stunts there are wearing a little thin on me.I guess thats why I have drifted to all college sports.............MOST still have discipline in their program.

Ron

IUROX
Sunday, December 7, 2008 5:11:00 AM
His skills will improve as time goes on. The QB market in the NFL is wide open,of course he will make.

Will he be Joe Montana, well time will tell.

As for nimrod's comments i chose to completely ignore them. Can you not just make a FOOTBALL post without judging the kids beliefs?

MCpapa
  • MCpapa
  • Connoisseur Topic Starter
Sunday, December 7, 2008 5:16:00 AM
I'm not ridiculing the kid's beliefs. Take a deep breath. I was clear: he seems like an exceptionally good person. But I'm saying that succeeding in the NFL, like any professional organization, means fitting in. You can't be a leader if you don't fit in. This was a problem for Wuerffel a handful of years back. It's been a problem in many sports (the Twins in the 80s are a perfect example).

I don't support that part of sports, but, hey, that's what it means to be on a team and that's the reality.

I'd also say that it is problematic to judge the profession or league by some bad examples. The overwhelming majority of NFLers are just fine as people and role models.

Joe Montana is a good example for Tebow, actually. Not the best arm, but an insane sense of the game. Now, I've not seen that in Tebow's passing game, but it might develop (it was of course part of Joe's game at ND).

IUROX
Sunday, December 7, 2008 5:20:00 AM
LOL yea he is no leader,LMAO he sure does not seem to have a grasp on pulling his team together or pumping them up.No energy what so ever.

Probably why he will have back to back National Championships.

YAWN...

8trackdisco
Sunday, December 7, 2008 5:25:00 AM
'..Tebow : future or no?..'

---------------------------

Yes, as an athletic, Jason Witten type TE and a #3 QB.

MCpapa
  • MCpapa
  • Connoisseur Topic Starter
Sunday, December 7, 2008 5:26:00 AM
Missed my point. We're talking about the NFL. How many flops in the NFL were fabulous leaders? Nearly all of them.

Surely you've noticed that excellence in college football does not equal excellence in the NFL, right? Thus, the discussion...

MCpapa
  • MCpapa
  • Connoisseur Topic Starter
Sunday, December 7, 2008 5:27:00 AM
^ for #9
DrMaddVibe
Sunday, December 7, 2008 5:32:00 AM
If he ends up in Detroit, he's screwed.
Charlie
Sunday, December 7, 2008 6:00:00 AM
"Going to Kansas City, Kansas City here I come......

Charlie

JadeRose
Sunday, December 7, 2008 6:01:00 AM
Charlie.....Tebow or Chase Daniel for KC?
JadeRose
Sunday, December 7, 2008 6:02:00 AM
Lotsa people say Daniels is not a good NFL fit. Too small, etc. 2 words.....Drew Brees
Charlie
Sunday, December 7, 2008 6:19:00 AM
Actually I am quite happy with Tyler Thigpen, and hope they draft another burner wide out or go for DeMarco Murray of Oklahoma (but not in the first round).....who knows, Chiefs have youngest team in NFL and can only build to be better and have a good base to draft from.

Daniels is is good but so is Todd Reesing and Clint McCoy and the gunner from Texas Tech, lots of good qb's out there.

Charlie

burgess_b
Sunday, December 7, 2008 9:20:00 PM
Heisman trophy QBs have very varied NFL careers...i agree his arm strength is suspect, but they can fix that.

he is a leader. and i think all people, ALL people respect natural leaders. maybe he does not exactly fit in, but that does not mean he will not earn their respect.

i also agree with C3S--slower is better, but doubt he gets a team that keeps him on the bench.

and i like what 8 said, just because i am a dallas fan, and witten is AWESOME! dallas has had some great TE's.

andytv
Monday, December 8, 2008 4:13:00 AM
McPapa......your observation about Tebow's faith and manner made me think immediately about Troy Palomalu.......very soft spoken, polite, friendly, and extremely pious; we make wagers in jest on how often he makes the sign of the cross on camera each game....one game we lost count at around twenty five. At any rate, the guy prays before and after every play.

Troy is a pretty good NFL player too.

jetblasted
Monday, December 8, 2008 4:18:00 AM
He's a Great Football Player, and I think he's got the physical skills to achieve greatness in the NFL . . .

However, I'm not so sure the players in the pros will take to his style of motivation . . .