lou2row
  • lou2row
  • Herf-A-Holic Topic Starter
Monday, December 15, 2008 6:21:00 AM
Looking at getting a lower end 46"-50" at Costco for Christmas.

Which is best in terms of longevity? I don't want to be buying new tvs every 4 years.

IUROX
Monday, December 15, 2008 6:23:00 AM
LCD is the newer technology. Plasmas never really impressed me that much.I bought a DLP instead of a plasma, but LCD's were still very expensive then.

If I buy another soon it would be LCD.Plasma is headed out.

IUROX
Monday, December 15, 2008 6:24:00 AM
You might lok around to Lou,tons of sales on T.V.'s right now.Good buys everywhere. You may find something better than Costco.
usahog
Monday, December 15, 2008 6:29:00 AM
Also check Circuit City.. they are closing allot of stores and may have overstocked items cheap??

The Big Bolivar
Monday, December 15, 2008 7:11:00 AM
They are 2 different animals really.

Plasma typically available in larger screens 60-65" runs warmer due to the high voltage it takes.

More expensive to make than an lcd, but less expensive in larger formats. (not cost efficient to make in smaller units) That's why you see them 42 and larger.

Lcd not really a true black (getting better) viweing angles are not as good as a plasma, lighter, cooler operating than plasma due to backlights rather than high voltage.

In my opinion get what you like.

I would buy the extended warranty if you plan on operating one trouble free for 4-5 years. They won't last like the good ol CRT units did.

I have had several here taken apart, and they build these things cheap!

The Big Bolivar
Monday, December 15, 2008 7:33:00 AM
As a matter of fact I had a Samsung lcd computer monitor that was less than a year old fail.

I had some time yesterday to bench it, and it turned out it had 3 bad capacitors in the power supply section. Changed those out and I'm back in biz!

Crappy design and cheap components, oh and **** soldering to, I've seen many with poor solder joints that go bad in time.

plinytheelder
Monday, December 15, 2008 8:12:00 AM
I had the power supply on my plasma fail.

They said it would be 6mos before they could get another power supply to fix it. I returned it, voided the extended warranty, and got a DLP.

If it was me, I'd get an LCD.

Charlie
Monday, December 15, 2008 8:15:00 AM
Lewis

The costco here has some great deals on Panasonic, Vizio and Sanyo....I would go with LCD...I have three of them and they are all great (LCD's) a Sony, Sanyo and a Vizio.

Sharp is expensive as is the Sony......but Vizio is really nice set for the bucks.

Charlie

f16devils
Monday, December 15, 2008 8:21:00 AM
Bought a toshiba 40" 1080P lcd in october. Great picture, just wish comcast had more hd stations available.
andytv
Monday, December 15, 2008 10:07:00 AM
If the thickness is not a big issue (if you are not mounting it directly to a wall), consider a rear projection HDTV.

They are a quite a bit cheaper and the service plans cover the lamp.

I got a Sony 60" Bravia for around the same price as a quality 42" LCD, and it's only about 14" deep.

Charlie
Monday, December 15, 2008 10:31:00 AM
My 42 inch Sony is a rear projection HDTV and I have had it for four years....if it breaks, I will just buy a new one, since they are so much cheaper today.....next one will be another LCD 48 to 54 in size.

Charlie

cbc812
Monday, December 15, 2008 10:35:00 AM
I've never done plasma but I heard it's wild.

LCD is great if you have a whole weekend and it doesn't have too many chemicals in it. Sugarcubes are the preferred delivery method. Stay away from mirrors.

Hope this helps.

andytv
Monday, December 15, 2008 10:40:00 AM
In college, I'd sell plasma two or three times a week for extra cash.

I had no idea it was going into televisions.

nabentroth
Monday, December 15, 2008 10:58:00 AM
For all the info you ever need regarding HDTVs...http://avsforum.com/

In short, quality Plasmas are a bigger bang for the buck all around when you are looking at 42"+. Plasmas will usually have the edge in image quality, black reproduction, viewing angle, performance in lighting conditions, etc when compared to a similarly priced LCD when dealing in the low-mid budget range.

When hitting mid-high to high price range, it goes back and forth.

LCDs will suck less power, are better for running in smaller rooms where Plasmas have been known to heat up, and can be lighter to move around.

_____________________________________

Common myths to debunk

-Current gen plasma's do not have burn in issues, though some care if necessary during the first 100 hours.

-Plasma's do not have a short light span with current gen plasma's having a general span of something like 15+ years running at 5 hours a day at which point they will be at half brightness.

-1080p is not always worth the extra cost unless you are getting a TV size over 65" or viewing it within 3 feet. Scientifically, most people's eyes cannot pickup the additional detail past past a certain range. (I.e. In most situations, a 720p 50" tv will be a better investment for the cost than a 1080[ 42")

Solid Plasma Brands: Panasonic, Pioneer

*There have been some great deals at sears lately on 50" 720p panasonic's to the tune of $899 or less.

I have owned plasma's for almost three years now and went from a 720p 42" panasonic to a 50" 720p panasonic this summer when Sears had the 50 for $1100....wonderful upgrade as the 50" offers like 35-40% more surface area. Funny how that same TV is now only $900 or less when on sale.

If you have any doubts to what I say, feel free to dig through avsforum. It is a killer community with people that have 1000% more knowledge that I. I simply know what I know today by doing way to much research on that site 3 years ago before buying all my home theater equipment.

nabentroth
Monday, December 15, 2008 11:05:00 AM
nine999
Monday, December 15, 2008 11:18:00 AM
^thanx dude.
nine999
Monday, December 15, 2008 11:21:00 AM

soo... this "runs hot" issue- really, what are we talking about?

do smoke alarms go off? or do you have to walk up to it and touch it?

does the heat radiate and warm the room?

i mean, don't all tv's feel hot if you put your hand in the right place? (huh huh...)

nine

teedubbya
Monday, December 15, 2008 11:25:00 AM
thats HOT
nabentroth
Monday, December 15, 2008 11:25:00 AM
Actually in my living room, I don't even notice the TV adding heat to the room. Basically a 50" 720p plasma sucks up 330 watts. A 1080p sucks up even more. Side effect of that many watts is going to be some heat.

I have just heard some people using 42-50" plasma in smaller bedrooms and the TVs producing a bit too much heat for the small room. The TVs ran fine, just the room was often too warm.

I notice the same thing with my computer in my smaller office as I am running a beast of a machine with a 24" CRT monitor 🙂

lou2row
  • lou2row
  • Herf-A-Holic Topic Starter
Monday, December 15, 2008 11:58:00 AM
Thanks for all the tips. Haven't kept up on this stuff lately. This gives me some ideas and I've went and checked out avs forum.