Shiloh,
Don't get me wrong, there is nothing else like a Davidoff Melli. It's a complex smoke with finesse. It is a tad mild though. And I do enjoy them on the rare occasion that I'm willing to spend that much on a milder stick.
As for the relationship you built up with your tobacconist, that is exactly why online vendors will never replace brick and mortar shops. I could hang out and chat for hours at one of my locals and not be expected to buy a single thing.
Unfortunately most of my business goes to the online vendors bcause of CA "sin" taxes.
Bottom line - Enjoy the Davidoff Melli! Do not let others tell you what you like. A wise man on another forum says, "Smoke what you like - Like what you smoke"