Not a fan.
Not at all. No songs sound good to me, and he keeps on yelling "1, 2, 3" during the damn songs, regardless.
And truly, I can't tell his guitar playing (or lack thereof). He (and the other really old guy) seem to be just a minor sound in the cacophony. All horns and piano, to me. When he did the windmill ala Townsend, I chuckled my ass off. He wasn't even strumming in time to the beat. The swinging around his neck was all for show, he didn't bother hitting the strings other than to grab the neck.
I dunno, maybe it looked cool.
As a songwriter, ok. Not my cup of tea, but I can see some of the appeal. Goes on way too long for me, though.
As a singer, he's horrible.
As a guitar player, even worse.
fret
My $.02