I've been using Vonage for a couple years and not had any serious problems.
The only minor problem I've had is when I'm downloading a movie and use the phone, the person on the other end of the phone says the sound is breaking up a bit. I just pause the download while I finish the call, and all is fine. (I use cable internet with a home wireless network.)
The other drawback vs a land line is that the vonage box is plugged into your modem and relies on your internet connection and household electricity. If you lose power or your internet, you also lose phone. A standard land line carries it's own power and doesn't rely on power from your home.