lsfire
  • lsfire
  • Aficionado Topic Starter
Sunday, December 12, 2004 6:45:00 AM
Ok, I've check the newbie thread, have read other sources, understand it probably boils down to personal preference. That being said, question

I have read a thread and material that have discussed the various types of cuts. Some like the v-cut, some like scissors, some bite. What do you do with what type of cigar and most importantly WHY? What is it you look for in your cut? How far or how much do you cut? Given the cuts importance lets discuss the particulars.

Jdllizard
Sunday, December 12, 2004 7:57:00 AM
Never cut the cap off completely, you need to leave some or the cigar will unravel. I only cut about a dimes thickness off. If it is a torpedo I cut about 1/4inch. I use a Xicar muti tool, it has a cigar scissors that I love. For smaller ring gauge cigars I will V-cut or use a punch, it just depends on my mood.

John L

pabloescabar
Sunday, December 12, 2004 9:23:00 AM
I cut what need's ta be cut start low, and punch what need's a punch ...
CWFoster
Sunday, December 12, 2004 9:35:00 PM
I cut Torps at an angle, so as to create a larger area aperture (search for ****** cut) and punch milder cigars and cut stronger ones, or smaller ring gauges that can't be punched
rayder1
Sunday, December 12, 2004 9:44:00 PM
I cut about 1/8" without taking the whole cap off.

I just use my scissor cutter. Nothing fancy. I take a test draw and cut more if needed.

lukin
Sunday, December 12, 2004 10:33:00 PM
it all depends what I have on hand. I usually cut the "newbie" way by placing the cigar head down on the counter in between my cutter and slicing...I have used a punch in the past, but kept getting tar ooze too often and ditched it. I have punched with a pen cap, a match, and a drill bit, and have bit the end off.
jcherri
Monday, December 13, 2004 5:02:00 AM
As others have said.. it depends..

Smaller ring sizes seem to work well with the V cutters..

Anything between 40 and 50 I tend to use a normal cut.. I have found that the dual bladed guilatine cutters tend to cause less damage to the cap sometimes.. I have had tearing from a single blade cutter.. probably wasn't sharp enough.. I only shave off the cap end..

On larger guages I have had good luck with a punch.. I have one with a larger diameter that makes a good size hole so the bigger gauges draw easier.. A lot of the guilatines have too small of an opening to cut the larger gauges properly.. Have had the same problem with V cutters..

ryantp
Monday, December 13, 2004 5:32:00 AM
I use a butter knife and cut right through the band.

Wait, no, that's a lie.

cexshun
Monday, December 13, 2004 5:36:00 AM
I only use a guilletine. Although my current one is dull beyond belief and crunches through the gar instead of cuts. Bummer, it was one of the nice all metal ones from CI. Was hoping it would last longer then aprox 60 cigars. Have a Xikar on order though to replace it.

I've never used a punch and don't plan too. Anything to large for my guilletine cutter gets the Swiss Army Knife treatment.

KNOF
Monday, December 13, 2004 5:38:00 AM
For me it depends on my mood and how much I've already had to drink and what I'm smokin will dictate if I use a punch, scissors, or my favorite V-Cutter. I even use V-cuts on my torpedos. I've experimented with a double V-Cut on torps too, and I like!!!
THL
  • THL
  • Herf-A-Holic
Monday, December 13, 2004 6:28:00 AM
I usually v-cut. Like knof said, on torps I do it twice. I use a Gladiator v-cutter and it works great up to 52 or so ring gauge. I seldom buy cigars larger than that anyway.
dave97402
Monday, December 13, 2004 6:39:00 AM
I just hack the ends off. Just a little, usually with a gillotine cutter.....but have been known to just use my thumb nail and pop off the cap.

Dave

Skatty2hotty
Monday, December 13, 2004 6:45:00 AM
Hey cexshun, while you're waiting for a new cutter. Try cutting your cigars with the cellow on. You'll be surprised by the results. Only do this trick with a dull blade, because it will ruin a sharp one.
dankeeler
Monday, December 13, 2004 11:33:00 AM
I remember seeing a thread like this one a month or so back. Someone mentioned using a razor-sharp swiss army knife blade to just cut the cap. I tried it and have been hooked. It doesn't even effect the end of the whole cigar, only cut deep enough to pop the very end of the cap off. This way there's enough cap left not to unravel the cigar, and it leaves all the leaf ends intact, no litte bits of tobacco to spit out on the first few draws.I just keep that thin little blade razor sharp. Torpedos....that's a different story, I just use a very sharp pair of cigar scissors.
Brandon@CigarBid
Monday, December 13, 2004 12:01:00 PM
Another thing to consider with regards to the style of cut you choose is the fact that the cut does have an impact on flavor.

For a dramatic demonstration of this take a cigar with a good deal of body and flavor (preferably one that you are very familiar with), choose a large ring size and punch a hole in it. Smoke it for 3 or 4 inches and then cut it as you would with a guillotine. You should notice a distinct differnce in the flavor of the smoke.

This is typically due to the tars that accumulate around the edge of the hole that a punch or v-cut produce. The larger the ring, the more pronounced this often rancid flavor becomes and this is why I personally use a guillotine religiously.

However, this is just a suggestion. Ultimately the right cutter for the job is the cutter that produces the cut you enjoy most. Cigars are very subjective and while suggestions and advice from others is often very helpful, you should continue to experiment in order to determine what cut produces the best result for you.

Allright, that's my two cents. Now where the hell did Steve hide my cutter...

SteveR@CigarBid
Monday, December 13, 2004 12:10:00 PM
I ruined a perfectly good Avo 22 with a punch cut. Normally a mild-bodied smoke that burns smooth and creamy, I noticed an extremely harsh flavor after I got about halfway through. So bad, I couldn't even finish it.

However, I do use a punch and/or v-cutter quite often. Whenever I use a punch cutter, it's on a thicker ring cigar, and I put 2 or 3 holes in the head. When I use a v-cutter, I always cut the head in one direction, turn the cigar 90 degrees, and cut it in the other direction, making an 'X'. I really enjoy this method.

SteveR@CigarBid
Monday, December 13, 2004 12:25:00 PM
Brandon, I didn't take your dang cutter. Use your teeth.
Cigar_Fiend
Monday, December 13, 2004 1:57:00 PM
I am a double guillotine guy myself. However, I have come to realize that a #11 scalpel works great when you forget your cutter at home. Just watch out for your fingers.

-Chris

cexshun
Monday, December 13, 2004 2:06:00 PM
When working in the garage, a quick zap on the belt sander does NOT work!
tornado
Monday, December 13, 2004 2:12:00 PM
If the belt sander doesnt' work, just try it on the table saw with a rip fence.