Another thing to consider with regards to the style of cut you choose is the fact that the cut does have an impact on flavor.
For a dramatic demonstration of this take a cigar with a good deal of body and flavor (preferably one that you are very familiar with), choose a large ring size and punch a hole in it. Smoke it for 3 or 4 inches and then cut it as you would with a guillotine. You should notice a distinct differnce in the flavor of the smoke.
This is typically due to the tars that accumulate around the edge of the hole that a punch or v-cut produce. The larger the ring, the more pronounced this often rancid flavor becomes and this is why I personally use a guillotine religiously.
However, this is just a suggestion. Ultimately the right cutter for the job is the cutter that produces the cut you enjoy most. Cigars are very subjective and while suggestions and advice from others is often very helpful, you should continue to experiment in order to determine what cut produces the best result for you.
Allright, that's my two cents. Now where the hell did Steve hide my cutter...