I know this question has been asked in the past...What are the Worst, Best, and Favorite cigars yall have tried? Mine are worst lone Wolf, Anclas, and a few others, Best Flor De Olivia Grand Camaroon and La Luna Africans, Favorites are Monteros Todd

Worst: any Tamboril "product" (I can't call them cigars); Best: Napa Reserve Canary Islands (Thanks Slim); Fave: varies based on mood, time of day, and what's available, but favorites include Puros Indios (these are a "Love 'em or hate 'em cigar), Aristoff Black (when you get a good one you wonder why they're discontinued), Sinatra My Way (for an easy, mild smoke), and FDO Grands.

Joe, thanks for selecting the Aristoff, since I introduced you to those, and I agree on the Napa Reserve as the best ever! Favorites: Aristoffs, Padrons, Partagas Black Labels! Worst: Any Tamboril, Hamilton House, Lone Wolf and Dutch Masters! Special place of Honor goes to Montecristo #2 ISOM! Charlie

I agree with tailgater about how the good ones vary. The bad ones don't get better, though. Recent and all from CBid (except the Lone Wolf, an old mistake)- Worst: Lone Wolf, Black Stallion; Best: Perdomo Cabinet Selection mad.#4; Favorites: Padron 3000, Cupido Crillo.

Worst: Lone Wolf (no consistency - one was good the rest crap). Best: 1995 La Gloria Cubana Corona Gorda (aged in my 'dor for 6 years) Favorite: Partagas Naturales (day in day out a great cigar)

the best monte "A" and monte "5". the worst was from the las vegas cigar club. they wouldn't even flush.

Worst: Aroma de San Andreas, Don Tomas, Flor del Todo, any cigar from Mexico. Bests/Favorites: Padron Anniversario Maduro, Perdomo Estate Seleccion, Ashton VSG, Cupido Toro Negro.

Fav: Carlin, R&J Isoms, Cedro Deluxe 2
Best: Monte #2, Perdomo
Worst: FD Todo, Espinosa, Bering

BEST: that secret cigar they make in the Cohiba factory in Havana. I've never had one, but its still my favorite. (aren't 'best' and 'favorite' the same thing?) WORST: Any cigar from Nazi Germany. (I actually have 2 boxes. You can imagine the little Gestapo **** running around with them in their mouths.)

Rick,

They plugged up the toilet??? DAMN !!!! Not even good ****.

You've got to be kidding me! Nobody has said Acid as the worse???? You guys are always bashing them.

OK, Acids are by far among the worst.........Forgot about them while posting, but they are all time honor as worst, and for another favorite, LaGloria Cubana, always great! Pithy enough? Add Lars to worst list! Charlie

WORST: Tamboril, Te-Amo, Dom. Estates BEST: HdM ISOM, VSG, Perdomo Estate FAVORITE: HdM 1066, Excalibur, Padron. I haven't tried many "super premiums"(ie. Opus, PAM, CAO's etc...), so my "bests" are from a limited selection.

I put an acid in a small tupperware container with a humid stick. The acid started out dry, but sucked ALL THE MOISTURE from the humidstick. Amazing. It was soaked. We smoke this stuff? What's in them?

thanks bill. i thought it was diabetes that was making my so thirsty. it's the acids that WE smoke.
i have had good **** and those cigars weren't. hell they were still lit after several attemps to flush them.

Worst: V centennial, anclas, anything Rookie recommends. Best: Cupido Toro Negro, La Perla maduro anything.

Worst: I've blocked them from my memory, but most cheap cigars I find are not worth the time. I'd rather smoke less often and smoke better cigars.
Best Ever: Aged ISOM Cohiba Esplendido
Favorites: CAO Cameroon Churchill and Toro, Perdomo Estate Selecion, Puros Indios, AF Don Carlos robustos (if they have sat a few months in the humi).

Worst: ornelas, hoja yellow band
Best: Ashton churchill
Favs: fdo, lgc, and all perdomo brands I've tried so far

Worst: don diego (weak and bland), Best: anything Indian Tabac , CAO Maduro, Acid (yeah i know here come all the so-called purists to rip me), Hoyo De Monterrey 135 anniv., Punch rothchild, Favorite: CAO L'anniversary MAduro, Indian Tabac Boxer Maduro.

Which ACID? If it's the ACID ONE, then I'm with ya 🙂