alxaps
  • alxaps
  • Connoisseur Topic Starter
Thursday, January 13, 2005 3:19:00 PM
I've always been wondering why some cigars will produce voluminous amounts of smoke (which I think adds to the smoking experience), while there'll be others that'll make you think you're smoking a cigarette by the stingy volume of smoke output. Is it due to tobacco leaf curing/preparation methods, tobacco leaf type, skill of the rollers or aging of the finished product?

I tried to search this board for previous posts on this subject but could'nt find any. If this is a rehashed question that'll make you oldtimers gnash your teeth, I apologize. Feel free to hammer. Just want to broaden my knowledge on cigars.

usahog
Thursday, January 13, 2005 4:11:00 PM
alxaps, Welcome to the CBid Forums...

I myself have found this very same question picking at my mind on occasions with each different cigars I've smoked...

I also find it a very good topic although it has been discussed a few times here and on other BB'ds....

to be honest I haven't figured it out as yet either...

but along the lines of what you listed in your post:

"Is it due to tobacco leaf curing/preparation methods, tobacco leaf type, skill of the rollers or aging of the finished product?" I think also has to do with how well maintained the cigars are kept even after they reach their final destination??

and as I have sat many times smoking the cigar with this same question on my mind... I've kind of came to an assumption IMO in the order of many of your above questions...

in order:

tobacco leaf type

curing/preparation

skill of the rollers

AND aging of the finished product

Storing of the finished product...

as like my woodburner in the shop..I've sat in front of it enjoying a cigar and compaired the burning of the wood inside the stove to many of the cigars I've smoked in comparison I see that a good seasoned wood will burn well and consistant and produce not only allot of smoke but also a good Warm/hot systematic coals or ambers.. where as I've cut wood and it not being that well seasoned (no matter what type wood it was) it would smolder rather then burn and not produce the warm/hot coals or ambers as well as the seasoned wood, but the smoke is fully more then I feel would be coming from a well seasoned woods... with the consistancy of a fine tobacco leaf and in it's stages from preperation to finished product to storage of... I have found this to be comparable to a good seasoned wood....

Hog

bassdude
Thursday, January 13, 2005 4:24:00 PM
good question.

I have no answer although the curing process seems suspect. Also a wet gar produces less smoke.

I smoked a Monte #2 that was so stingy on smoke I about threw it out.

Colt45
Thursday, January 13, 2005 4:32:00 PM
I agree with the above. I've found that the cigars that produce alot of smoke are the ones that draw well. For me this usually means a cigar that is not over humidified, is densely packed, but not rolled too tight.
usahog
Thursday, January 13, 2005 4:55:00 PM
Colt.. I'm not sure I agree with the thought of "densely packed, but not rolled too tight." I do however think the rolling process is a major contributor to the smoke volume.. I've got some Cohiba ISOM's and also some SLR A's that are rolled so tight construction they feel like bricks and they produce tons of smoke... I've also noticed this in some of the Non ISOM's in the Padron lines and Fuente lines Ashton Cabinet is another one of these....

Hog

Jdllizard
Thursday, January 13, 2005 5:06:00 PM
I've never had a cigar with a tight drawn put out enough smoke for my liking. I'm guessing it is from being over humidified, or to tightly rolled or both.

John L

Colt45
Thursday, January 13, 2005 5:08:00 PM
Hog, I agree-some of my smokiest cigars have been hard as rocks-I actually prefer them this way over cigars with

"give". As for density and tightness, again, to me, this is all relative to draw. I think we mean the same. I

suppose that ring guage also is a factor.

usahog
Thursday, January 13, 2005 5:18:00 PM
not sure about the ring guage being a factor either.. I've got some EDM's that are not even bigger then my pinky finger that produce a boatload of smoke... course there a little powerhouse of a cigar anyways.. I'm not even sure their not machine rolled??

Hog

usahog
Thursday, January 13, 2005 5:24:00 PM
John, don't confuse the tight draw with a tightly rolled cigar, this isn't what I or I think others were refering to?? I was refering to when rolling the cigar in your fingers while smoking or not... you will/can feel how well the construction of the cigar is rolled IE: tightly rolled or lumpy (as I call them) soggy is another name used... I've got some (suspected farm rolled) cohiba Esplenditos (sp)ISOM's in my humi that I needed a poker to punch through them and they still do not produce smoke nor taste a bit to the extent of their name... Plugged is the word I use for these expensive POS's LOL

Hog

bassdude
Thursday, January 13, 2005 5:28:00 PM
mmmmm SLR A's
Jdllizard
Thursday, January 13, 2005 5:30:00 PM
usahog,

I was just stating what I have come across in my limited time of cigar smoking. The ones I have had that did not produce enough smoke, also seemed to draw really hard. However I am still pretty new to this compared to the FOGs here. I have had some gars that were rock hard and smoked great.

John L

Colt45
Thursday, January 13, 2005 5:32:00 PM
I guess I have had some small cigars that produced alot of smoke. Monte #5s that drew terribly, but smoked like banshees.
usahog
Thursday, January 13, 2005 5:35:00 PM
I understand John.. I was more less clerifing for others also... I'm still a newbie myself ;0)

Hog

alxaps
  • alxaps
  • Connoisseur Topic Starter
Thursday, January 13, 2005 6:06:00 PM
I very much appreciate the input you guys gave. Guess it's several factors...

Hog, thanks for your welcome. I actually discovered C-Bid and it's forum sometime Sept. of last year and have been posting occasional comments on certain threads (lurker?).

Though I've been smoking cigars for ten years now, I haven't seen a cigar forum where the camaraderie and helpfullness of it's members is at such a high level as it is here at C-Bid. I make it a point to read the posts each night for education as well as good entertainment.

Back to the thread - I've had some panatelas several years ago (forgot the brand) that would outsmoke some of the torpedos and belicosos being sold now so I am not really sold on the idea that ring gauge really matters.

alxaps
  • alxaps
  • Connoisseur Topic Starter
Thursday, January 13, 2005 6:07:00 PM
I very much appreciate the input you guys gave. Guess it's several factors...

Hog, thanks for your welcome. I actually discovered C-Bid and it's forum sometime Sept. of last year and have been posting occasional comments on certain threads (lurker?).

Though I've been smoking cigars for ten years now, I haven't seen a cigar forum where the camaraderie and helpfullness of it's members is at such a high level as it is here at C-Bid. I make it a point to read the posts each night for education as well as good entertainment.

Back to the thread - I've had some panatelas several years ago (forgot the brand) that would produce more smoke than some of the torpedos and belicosos being sold now so I am not really sold on the idea that ring gauge really matters.

alxaps
  • alxaps
  • Connoisseur Topic Starter
Thursday, January 13, 2005 6:10:00 PM
I very much appreciate the input you guys gave. Guess it's several factors...

Hog, thanks for your welcome. I actually discovered C-Bid and it's forum sometime Sept. of last year and have been posting occasional comments on certain threads (lurker?).

Though I've been smoking cigars for ten years now, I haven't seen a cigar forum where the camaraderie and helpfullness of it's members is at such a high level as it is here at C-Bid. I make it a point to read the posts each night for education as well as good entertainment.

Back to the thread - I've had some panatelas several years ago (forgot the brand) that would produce more smoke than some of the torpedos and belicosos being sold now so I am not really sold on the idea that ring gauge matters.

alxaps
  • alxaps
  • Connoisseur Topic Starter
Thursday, January 13, 2005 6:12:00 PM
oops, sorry about that.