alxaps, Welcome to the CBid Forums...
I myself have found this very same question picking at my mind on occasions with each different cigars I've smoked...
I also find it a very good topic although it has been discussed a few times here and on other BB'ds....
to be honest I haven't figured it out as yet either...
but along the lines of what you listed in your post:
"Is it due to tobacco leaf curing/preparation methods, tobacco leaf type, skill of the rollers or aging of the finished product?" I think also has to do with how well maintained the cigars are kept even after they reach their final destination??
and as I have sat many times smoking the cigar with this same question on my mind... I've kind of came to an assumption IMO in the order of many of your above questions...
in order:
tobacco leaf type
curing/preparation
skill of the rollers
AND aging of the finished product
Storing of the finished product...
as like my woodburner in the shop..I've sat in front of it enjoying a cigar and compaired the burning of the wood inside the stove to many of the cigars I've smoked in comparison I see that a good seasoned wood will burn well and consistant and produce not only allot of smoke but also a good Warm/hot systematic coals or ambers.. where as I've cut wood and it not being that well seasoned (no matter what type wood it was) it would smolder rather then burn and not produce the warm/hot coals or ambers as well as the seasoned wood, but the smoke is fully more then I feel would be coming from a well seasoned woods... with the consistancy of a fine tobacco leaf and in it's stages from preperation to finished product to storage of... I have found this to be comparable to a good seasoned wood....
Hog