Alright, the results are in!

Here is how I scored the trade:

Lance...................256
Gan.....................260
Average score...........258

Here is how Lance scored the trade:

Lance...................173
Gan.....................191
Average score...........182

I was surprised at the range of scores, especially between lance and myself. This made it difficult to score. I found the best way to determine a final score was to use the average score of each trader. Since they varied so widely, I felt it was only fair to declare the closest average scores to EACH of ours as the winners...........

Beatdragon's average score was only .5 different from Lance's average tally, so he is one winner.

Stogeeboy's average score was only 2 points different from my average tally, so he is the other winner.

Looks like tenners going out to each of these BOTLs this week. Please e-mail me with your snailers.

gandalf907
at
yahoo

Thanks to all for taking the time to play. Hope it was in interesting excercise in the subjectivity of our taste in cigars.

Gan,

Are you going to post how you two scored the cigars? I am curious what you came up with.

Also thanks for the contest!

Castlewa

Chris, let me work on that. I have my stick for stick scoring, but only received Lance's totals. I'll e-mail him for the details.

after reading this and the original thread I had to see how I scored it.

Lance 170
Gan 174

That is a close trade.

Kewl Thanks!!!!

I finally won one of thses things!!!

e-mail on the way

wow i finally won something. cool contest

just for the record. i tried to put in cigars for the winners, but gan wouldn't have anything to do with that.

another class move by 1 of the finest botl i associate with. all winnings were out of gan's humi.

congrats to the winners.

i had fun with this, too.

blacky