ZRX1200
Saturday, October 31, 2009 9:36:00 PM
Beatles have there place.....

Mustane was a drunk and was hurting the band. You can actually hear him play with them if you want on garage days MAC. Dave apologized to the band a few years back to heal a burned bridge, I think someday you may see a small collaboration. But James is a drunk prick himself.

IMHO Both bands rock.

MACS
  • MACS
  • Herf-A-Holic Topic Starter
Saturday, October 31, 2009 9:47:00 PM
Look, brother... I'm taking nothing away from either band's musical ability. Their respective reputations precede them.

Dave was not the only drunk in that band. He was, by most accounts, doing too much heroin.

I applaud him for apologizing to his band mates. But the fact remains that James Hetfield is a prick. Lars Ulrich, along with being a pedestrian drummer, is also a fat prick. Kirk Hammett, while he is a very, very good lead guitarist, is most certainly not as good as Dave Mustaine.

So, as I intimated in my original post, I am a big fan of Metallica (own ALL albums) I am also a HUGE fan of Megadeth. Success, at least in this respect, does not equal talent.

ZRX1200
Saturday, October 31, 2009 9:57:00 PM
Drinking was all Dave talked about in an interview I read....

And I hear you. I just don't think IMO if Dave woulda stayed, some BS wouldn't have just come up 1-2 years later anyways. And there is no way they would have even come close to Zep, GFBOAT bar none.

I own all but Metallica's last 2 albums, but from the tracks I've heard the last one is worth the money!

I would have rather seen future material of Dimebag Darrell rather than a Dave induced Metallica....

MACS
  • MACS
  • Herf-A-Holic Topic Starter
Saturday, October 31, 2009 9:58:00 PM
Yes... Metallica is the shizz. No question, in my mind. I tend to love their earlier music. Kill ’em all. Ride the Lightening. Master of Puppets.

But... In MY opinion... their BEST music was on Kill ’em All. (their first album)

Little known fact... Dave Mustaine (heroin addict extraordinaire) was the dude who wrote most of the songs/music on that album.

Fast forward... Megadeth... Dave Mustaine’s new band. Killing is my business... and business is good.

Great album. My point is... IMHO, Metallica has never been the band that they could have been. Dave Mustaine is a better song writer, he’s a better music writer, and he’s a better musician.

That said... Metallica has enjoyed more success than Megadeth, though, again in my opinion, Megadeth has the better music.

IMNSHO - Metallica, if they had kept Dave Mustaine (who, once again, wrote all of the music for their best album) would have been in a category of the Stones, Zeppelin, or the Beatles**.

**I think the beatles absolutely suck. They were pedestrian musicians, at best, but their fame, for whatever reason, preceded them.

MACS
  • MACS
  • Herf-A-Holic Topic Starter
Saturday, October 31, 2009 10:20:00 PM
Well, then our musical tastes diverge, my friend.

I was never a Pantera fan. Tell me this... what Metallica Album, excepting Kill 'Em All, was better than Cryptic Writings.

I can find at least a couple songs on most Metallica albums, that I don't care for.

Cryptic Writings? Best. Album. Ever..

JohnE1000
Sunday, November 1, 2009 3:01:00 AM
Band success does not rely on one single talent; it is a team work. The fact that Metallica has achieved more success than Megadeath indicates that people like them better.

Taste of music is subjective. One cannot say this music is better than another. To each his own.

I like Metallica and I will buy a Metallica album, before I buy a Megadeath album.

For the record, I like the Black Album the best.

duwan
Sunday, November 1, 2009 3:55:00 AM
I prefer Metallica, but I do like Megadeath also.
DrMaddVibe
Sunday, November 1, 2009 4:58:00 AM
In head to head voting...my vote is for MEGADAVE!

He's NEVER turned out a "St. Anger" release.

His newest album..."Endgame"...is one of the if not the best rocking album of the year.

DrMaddVibe
Sunday, November 1, 2009 5:06:00 AM
seaborn
Sunday, November 1, 2009 5:12:00 AM
I guess you never heard The Archies.

They had a couple top 10 hits and could have been huge if Jughead didn't get all strung out on the horse.

calavera
Sunday, November 1, 2009 5:31:00 AM
I think that Metallica was a better band. Before the death of Cliff Burton.

Kill em All, Ride the Lightning and Master of Puppets are three of the best albums ever. And Justice for All was pretty good also, but it was the end of the line. Everything after had some high points but was not the same. St Anger ate steamed dog crap.

Megadeth had their two best albums in Rust in Peace and Countdown to Extinction. Killing is my Business was okay as was So Far so Good.

I have not heard any of Cryptic Writings other than Trust, which is an okay song. The only song that I have heard from Endgame is Head Crusher, which I do not like.

All other things being equal, I would expect that future releases from Megadeth would suck less than future releases from Metallica.

J

PS The Beatles do suck.

DrMaddVibe
Sunday, November 1, 2009 5:36:00 AM

What has Metallica done recently to rival this?

DrMaddVibe
Sunday, November 1, 2009 5:58:00 AM
I agree with the Cliff Burton comment.

With that said, if he was alive today I think he'd be in Megadeth. There is no way in hell Cliff would've allowed Lars to run his piehole like he has the last decade.

Everything Metallica has is garnered from the 1st 3 albums they recorded. The Black Album might've had some leftover stuff from the Cliff days. The reason I say that is because it doesn't sound like the stuff that Jason had done previously to joining Metallica.

Now, if this 2 bands want to really kiss and make up...TOUR TOGETHER!

THAT would be the most AWESOME show EVAH!!!!

seaborn
Sunday, November 1, 2009 6:11:00 AM
DrMaddVibe
Sunday, November 1, 2009 7:18:00 AM
#14...that song was supposed to be done by the Monkees.

They refused to do it because they had developed into a real functional band and not the Milli Vanilli face of one.

The guys behind the scenes developed the Archies into a pop band to vent their songs through.

ZRX1200
Sunday, November 1, 2009 7:23:00 AM
Agree with all above, cliff was a big loss.

MACS, I don't know why but Ride the Lightning I can listen too on repeat......Can't say thats true for me with any Pantera album. What I was geting at is I would buy any future Pantera album blind, not so with any Metallica album from black on.

teedubbya
Sunday, November 1, 2009 7:33:00 AM
I vote megadeath. it was close until metallica went all napster on us. not the action just using that as the time point. st. anger came out after that but they went down the suck path just prior to st anger.

but then again I like the beatles. very talented group.

MACS
  • MACS
  • Herf-A-Holic Topic Starter
Sunday, November 1, 2009 9:12:00 AM
I also agree Cliff Burton was a huge loss. Metallica's first 3 are THE best, but I do like some of the black album and some of Load, too. Bleeding me kicks ass.

I just think Dave Mustaine would have made that band so much better over the years, but yeah... he made his own bed.

Cryptic Writings is an album I can listen to over and over. I have to listen to Endgame and see what it's like.

gorob23
Sunday, November 1, 2009 1:35:00 PM
1. Author: MACS Date: 11/01/2009 01:58 AM Reply

**I think the beatles absolutely suck. They were pedestrian musicians, at fcuking best, but their fame, for whatever reason, preceded them.

And SIR

It is because of people like you that served our great Country that you and I can Disagree. We can argue more about this Friday 😉

Rob

DrMaddVibe
Sunday, November 1, 2009 2:08:00 PM
Rob!

Throw MACS a bass and have him play a "pedestrian" bass line from say..."You Won't See Me" or "The Night Before" or "Yer Blues".

INNOVATOR.

While Paul McCartney isn't one of the most notable bassists. I will say that his use of 8ths and 16ths as well as his use of 3/4 to 4/4 timing and in and out will have you pulling out your hair trying to play his stuff. The magic of the Beatles is the sum of its many parts including their producer. On their own, they floundered and were exposed for the world to see. Popish, lazy, uninspiring or so far out there that you had to be high as a kite to get the "message".

No, the Beatles earned their place in Rock royalty. From the Hamburg halls to the Cavern to Candlestick Park. The did it. They did it all. Their body of work is small in comparable to The Who or the Rolling Stones (whom they were compared to), but look at who they inspired to pick up a bass or guitar and play. Everyone from KISS to Oasis. Their songs have been covered by some of the best and in most cases...not as well.

MACS...I love ya...but I know you're a hard rockin' kinda a guy. I let stuff like that slide under the radar 'cause I know where he's coming from. Sir Paul isn't going to bust out any tune to rival "Symphony Of Destruction", but then again...Mustaine isn't going to be knighted or have the legacy of the Beatles. Apples and Oranges. On their own, something different. Mix them with alcohol and you have a really good drink.