Yes... Metallica is the shizz. No question, in my mind. I tend to love their earlier music. Kill ’em all. Ride the Lightening. Master of Puppets.
But... In MY opinion... their BEST music was on Kill ’em All. (their first album)
Little known fact... Dave Mustaine (heroin addict extraordinaire) was the dude who wrote most of the songs/music on that album.
Fast forward... Megadeth... Dave Mustaine’s new band. Killing is my business... and business is good.
Great album. My point is... IMHO, Metallica has never been the band that they could have been. Dave Mustaine is a better song writer, he’s a better music writer, and he’s a better musician.
That said... Metallica has enjoyed more success than Megadeth, though, again in my opinion, Megadeth has the better music.
IMNSHO - Metallica, if they had kept Dave Mustaine (who, once again, wrote all of the music for their best album) would have been in a category of the Stones, Zeppelin, or the Beatles**.
**I think the beatles absolutely suck. They were pedestrian musicians, at best, but their fame, for whatever reason, preceded them.