I'm actually not looking for loud, just something I can mix and match effects.
What I'm really looking for is a combo where I can get a death metal type distortion with a noise gate, and add-on a reverb / delay, and maybe chorus or flange. The all-in-one units seem nice.
The distortion / overdrive / amp simulator of the Pod seemed to have the distortion sould that I liked, however, I was looking basically for the downsides of the device.
Here's my situation:
When I have the time and the inclination (mainly the inclination part is my biggest problem), I'm presently designing my own effects. I'm really at the point of just setting up a low-end Linux box, and developing audio-processing software with JACK. I've already done it with Windows, but the latency (without spending the cash to get a ASIO sound card) is a BIG problem. Making a bunch of analog effects requires a lot of experimentation (especially if you want a high-gain overdrive), and I ain't spending $100.00 for a frickin' death metal pedal high-gain, especially if it does not incorporate a noise gate.
The only way I can eliminate propagation delay is to analog. If I go the "make your own" route, a simple high-gain distortion will require (I think) a 4-stage overdrive section, and three-band EQ, and Twin-T notch filter / buffer stage on the input. Hand-wiring that stuff on a protoboard is a b*tch, fabricating my own PCBs can be just as annoying, and breadborading all the stuff takes a lot of time and fiddling.
Or - and I have a capability to do this - I can "create" a full-fledged DSP, and program the thing. Of course, since most of the chips have over 40 pins on them, you almost have to have the circuit board prefabricated, and populated before I write a lick of code. And I better hope that - a novice like me - didn't screw up anywhere in the circuit or PCB design. This costs hundreds of dollars just for one lousy prototype.
Or, I can buy all discrete pedal effects, at about $100.00 a pop. After a distortion, noise gate, chorus, reverb, and maybe something else, I'm up in the $400.00 range.
Or I can buy one of these all-in-one, inexpensive effects. Ergo, my query.
I guess, my question should be: are the Line 6 Pods worth the money, and (specifically) can I get a Sevendust-like sound out of the guitar. Or are there other / better - INEXPENSIVE - rigs I can get. I want to keep the cost under $200.00.