Toby Gerhart had more rushing yards, more TD's and a better year.

Ingraham wasn't even in the top 10 in TD's. Gerhart was #1 in rushing yards AND TD's.

But he's a white running back, so no dice, bro... sorry for your tough luck.

What a crock of ****.

I'll give you the fact Ingraham had a good year, and he is going to the title game with an undefeated team, but Gerhart was the better player this year.

They gave the award to Alabama.

The way the media was pushing ingrahm I figured it to already be a lock. The trophy going to someone who was not even a honorable mention 3 weeks ago. 1 good (TV) game and he's the new heisman trophy winner. What a route!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Ingram is a stud....Gerhardt is a stud...

I will take Ingram over Toby G.....both are damn good.

Guy who will best in NFL out of the top 5 is Suh of Nebraska. He is a damn mountain that moves (fast)....

All 5 have loads of class and are what makes college football great.

Charlie

First Heisman ever for University of Alabama...that is something when you consider the legendary program and great teams they have had.

Charlie

Charlie, you'll get no argument that Ingraham will be the better NFL player, but the Heisman is supposed to be given to the most outstanding player in college football.

That was Toby Gerhart this year.

Toby Gerhart may as well been Amelia Earhart as he was lost in a weak Whack10.

Being on tv east of Nevada would help.

Plus, I liked him before when he was Tommy Vardell.

ROLL TIDE!

"Charlie, you’ll get no argument that Ingraham will be the better NFL player, but the Heisman is supposed to be given to the most outstanding player in college football.

That was Toby Gerhart this year"

.

.

.

.

.

+1, robbed for "hope and change"

Geri's happy....can't be all bad.....

Who gives a Shi##? Most Heimans have sucked in the pros!

Show me the Supervowl Heisman winner - very few!

c3s

^ and it's good to see her too!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

13 for 9&11

"but he's a white running back..."

Huh?

Is that allowed?

You must mean FULL back, right?

To me,the Heisman lost all credibility when Gino Torretta was given the award..

wheel,

C3S--heisman trophy to Superbowl MVP

Roger Staubach: 1963 Heisman, Super Bowl VI MVP

Jim Plunkett: 1970 Heisman, Super Bowl XV MVP

Marcus Allen: 1981 Heisman, Super Bowl XVIII MVP

Desmond Howard: 1991 Heisman, Super Bowl XXXI MVP

just wait till you see richardson go.......he will be next in this line

Man, I really thought they were going to give it to Obama for watching a game earlier in the season.

re # 17 - what is that % of total????

very minimal - most Heisman winners are busts!

c3s