lukin
  • lukin
  • Herf-A-Holic Topic Starter
Thursday, February 10, 2005 2:35:00 PM
I was reading the reviews of cigars in CA last night and it struck me as to how many different things they taste in a cigar. I can sometimes get Chocolate, nuts, wood, or leather, but these guys are either lying or they have unbelievable tastebuds

Leather x10

sweet coffee

cedar x14

Spice x10

cocoa bean x7

toast x12

Black pepper x5

Anise x4

wood x17

coffee bean x4

walnut

black cherry x4

sweet x6

rich

Nuts x13

citrus

vanilla x6

tangy wood

herbal x2

creamy x5

dry woodx7

acrid x3

Cardboard x2

Bread x3

Earth x10

hickory

Bread dough x2

weedy

coconut x3

Marzipan x2

Raisins

Wheat x6

dry

Chewy x2

Powdery

mineral

bitter x2

Starbucks Coffee (not only coffee but a particular brand...I think this is what made me go back and look at all of the flavors)

Sweet Wood x2

Rose Petals

Orange Peel

Harshness x3

funky

Tapioca

Papery x3

Balsa Wood x3

Saccharine

Red Meat

Middle Eastern Spices

Doughy

Alfalfa x2

Cinnamon

Chocolate

Roasted Meat

Dark Earth

Stemmy

Cumin

Pencil Lead x2

Creamed Coffee

Floral x2

Sour

Sweet Cedar

Licorice x2

Chalk

Tobacco

Chemical

Peppermint

Hard Wood

69 different flavors in their cigars. Some of them are broad and general (sweet) some of them are pretty finite (starbucks coffee) some of them I wonder how they know (balsa wood) and others make me wonder how it only ended up on the list once (tobacco)

I think it is funny and intriguing

WaldoAR15
Thursday, February 10, 2005 2:40:00 PM

@ my age, I can get coffee,chocolate, spice,pepper,cedar,

then it moves onto "I don't know what that is, but I don't want another one of those".

;)

ryantp
Thursday, February 10, 2005 2:42:00 PM
lukin: i'm glad you brought that up. i find the descriptions amazing and sometimes ridiculous.
stlbluesaddict
Thursday, February 10, 2005 3:00:00 PM
Some of them I can relate to, and others I also question.

However, descriptions are based on taste, which is influenced by not only the taste on the tongue and the palate, but aroma as well. I will say this, my palate is no where near the level of these 69 flavors, LOL!

You and I could smoke the same cigar and I may taste what I believe to be wood tones. You may feel it resembls earthy or nutty flavors. Somewhere in our enjoyment of the cigar we sensed a hint of something that made us think/relate to those tones.

Tazziedevil
Thursday, February 10, 2005 3:29:00 PM
That's why I don't read CA. I find it hard to relate tobacco to food tastes. Might be appropriate for wine, but Cigars? I personally smoke what I like and could care less what CA likes this month.
cigarbidwidow
Thursday, February 10, 2005 5:00:00 PM
What I wonder is how someone would know what "dark earth" tastes like in the first place. Makes you wonder... My favorite response was "funky." Really makes me want to go out and buy that one--NOT.
sketcha
Thursday, February 10, 2005 5:10:00 PM
lukin,

Your hands must be quite the whipping boys of The Devil.

I got a subscription for Christmas. I canceled the one year scrip I had a few years ago. It's an interesting read at this new price. Makes a good baby placemat, too for my 2 yr. old.

I also smoke what I like, but I think it can be a good tool (one of many) for beginners. I think it a good idea to try the higher rated value smokes. At least you can be pretty sure you're not smoking dogs. I use a few of the internet sites to get an idea before I blow my hard earned cash on something new, as well.

EvilJAR
Thursday, February 10, 2005 5:47:00 PM
Pencil lead is my favorite. Cause pencil lead is delicious.
Smokestud
Thursday, February 10, 2005 5:55:00 PM
Mmmm. Pencil lead. lol
WaldoAR15
Thursday, February 10, 2005 6:29:00 PM

Yeah, what's up with the pencil lead? Especially since it's really graphite.

Blech,,,

If I tasted anything like that it would be hissing in pain in a mud puddle somewhere 😉

ryantp
Thursday, February 10, 2005 6:30:00 PM
"Saccharine"

Wasn't this why Tab faced so much criticism in the 1980s?

I'm half expecting to see cyanide on this list.

dwallen
Thursday, February 10, 2005 6:45:00 PM
>Might be appropriate for wine

Nope. Wine reviews are about as silly. In fact, I think I've seen most of these "flavors" in wine reviews. LOL

If this stuff actually meant anything, we would undoubtedly see it in the advertising. ("Tastes great, less filling, and will evoke memories of Alfalfa and Roasted Meat":-)

Great post, lukin

WaldoAR15
Thursday, February 10, 2005 6:57:00 PM

Not to mention their 5 Vegas ratings.

MACS
Friday, February 11, 2005 4:23:00 AM
I'm going to be brutally honest here... who the f**k eats leather? Wood? Cedar? and a host of the other 'flavors' they claim to describe....

I think it's pure pretentious bulls**t if you really want to know.

Hell, I can't 'taste' half the flavors that are actually flavors!! Chocolatey? Yeah. Vanilla? Yeah. But to describe cigars the way they do? Do you WANT me to be totally confused?

I lump cigars into two categories:

1) I liked it and would smoke it again

2) It sucked and I wouldn't use it for mulch.

But that's just me... you may be one of those folks who has a palate like a dog's sense of smell. I'm not.

Slimboli
Friday, February 11, 2005 4:52:00 AM
Professional 'taste testers' do just that ... they train their palates to learn these flavors.

I use to work at the National Food Processors Association in Dublin, CA, (a food labarotory) and they had a 'sensory' group that paid people 'off the street' (besides those who worked there) to come in and taste new products offered by food companies.

They would first have to go through training. They had samples of leather, cardboard, grass, metal, etc. as 'controls' that people would taste in order to train themselves in what these things tasted like ... so I see nothing unusual about any of the flavor notes mentioned above.

It really was quite an extensive training ... and most professional tasters are required to go through it.

cigarbidwidow
Friday, February 11, 2005 5:08:00 AM
Slim--that makes a lot of sense but I sure hope they get paid a lot to do that. Tasting cardboard and metal would not be on the top of my list.
bullwyf
Friday, February 11, 2005 5:08:00 AM
Great POST...here's my answers.......I'm being mostly serious......I think....

Leather Yeah I've tasted what has the aroma of leather in many sticks.

sweet coffee Never got that detailed but coffee yeah

cedar Definately a common flavor/aroma

Spice Yeah this is one of those catch all, taste kinda spicy, sometimes it is a sweet spice, but identifying it like they do is beyond me.

cocoa bean I'll have to say no, chocolate, yes sometimes they say white chocalate, which I have tasted in a TTT

toast If they mean bready, I'd say yes ussualy in mild cigars.

Black pepper No doubt about this one.

Anise If they mean licorice I'd say yes, I've never eaten or smelled anise....where's that come from?

wood They get to specific with this one sometimes, hardwood, cedar, walnut, maple, come on be real

coffee bean Once again I think they got bored with writting coffee and went for coffee bean.

walnut Maybe once or twice. . I'd say black walnut. .ha ha

black cherry . .Perla Habana Black Pearl definately.

sweet This is a characteristic not a taste. .but yes

rich Definately. .

Nuts Some one smoking a white owl skin tip to hard might taste nuts. ha ha ha ha

citrus Never Citrus. . .maybe Apple in the Ghurka 100

vanilla Definately in a lot of mild cigars. .

tangy wood . . .NO that's just silly

herbal I'd say that's ussualy a negative thing,,medicinal is what I would call it.

creamy . .ussualy in mild cigars. .

dry woodx as appossed to what wet wood..silly

acrid can you say Dog rocket.....

Cardboard yeah any candela wrapper or supper mild cigar, hint no flavor....cardboard.

Bread ..see toast....

Earth yeah taste like dirt.....ha ha

hickory don't think so, never ate hickory

Bread dough see toast and bread...getting silly ain't they

weedy Once again dog rocket ussually no age on tobacco and will stick up your humidor with the smell of amonia

coconut PAN has a great macaroon flavor towards the mid way point..so yes

Marzipan What the heck is that ...corn....NO

Raisins NO...

Wheat see bread, toast, bread doe....etc

dry this one is just stupid...IMHO

Chewy that's a flavor...?

Powdery Now that's a dry cigar brothers...

mineral see medicinal..yuk

bitter not always a bad thing if bitter chocolate or coffee like starbucks..see below..

Starbucks Coffee (not only coffee but a particular brand...I think this is what made me go back and look at all of the flavors) Yeah, I guess they meant strong

Sweet Wood ....see wood...silly...

Rose Petals this is gay...

Orange Peel see above.....

Harshness x3 Dog rocket....

funky see above....their out of control...ahaajajaj

Tapioca Which is almost tasteless.....hell i like the pudding...

Papery see mild cigars

Balsa Wood x3 again with the dog gone wood.....

Saccharine Don't have a clue

Red Meat I'd eat that cigar....are they talking about char, see CAO Brazilia...deliocious char flavor..and no calories...or fat...

Middle Eastern Spices

Doughy see bread

Alfalfa dog rocket....weedy...yuk...no age...

Cinnamon Yes Diplomaticos #4 is layered in this spice...no BS

Chocolate I think so....come on...

Roasted Meat Char again...they get tired of using the same words I think..

Dark Earth rich dirt...ha ha

Stemmy WTF? are they smoking...

Cumin not touching this one.......

Pencil Lead Who's the dumba$$ who ate it to begin with...

Creamed Coffee again with the coffee..

Floral that's not a leaf that's a bud....

Sour no

Sweet Cedar OH you've got to be kidding....as apposed to what sour cedar...

Licorice see anise...isn't that the same...

Chalk some one was drunk when they lit this one....

Tobacco Well no screaming eagle $hit.....

Chemical Ah NO

Peppermint LMAO>>>>no no no no

Hard Wood again...soft wood, sweet wood, sour wood, balsa wood....BS wood....

lukin
  • lukin
  • Herf-A-Holic Topic Starter
Friday, February 11, 2005 6:19:00 AM
^

LMAO...too funny

drnos
Friday, February 11, 2005 6:32:00 AM
Cumin: I wouldn't know cumin if I tasted it.

Chewy: texture, not a taste

Powdery: ditto

Chalk: ditto...been a long, long time since I ate chalk

Mineral: C'mon, be specific. What mineral? You mean silver tastes like tin tastes like copper?

Stemmy: Like in a lid? Burns hot, no potency

Hard wood: See mineral above

Charlie
Friday, February 11, 2005 6:42:00 AM
I thought everything was judged against chicken! You know:

Q-How doe it taste?

A- Like Chicken...

Charlie