I'll be brave and name a few...
La Finca Maduro's....they're not the greatest, but for the price, much better and cheaper than most seconds
Sherpa's....a little one dimensional, but I've never had one that had a bad draw, and didn't taste and smoke great
El Mejor maduro's....again, not a great cigar, but just right for the money.
Most overrated?
anything in the CI catalog in which the description starts off.."back in the cigar boom"
any domestic version of a Cuban cigar (i.e. domestic montecristo's). No matter how good they are (and I have had some good ones such as the Monte Platinum)they aren't worth the price placed on them or the attention they recieve.
Macanudo...although this is just fine with me. I figure as long as people are looking at this as the holy grail of cigars, they aren't driving up the price of what I'm buying.