Brett Favre the quarterback is a lot of things.
Gutsy
Determined
Talented
Emotional
Etc.
But he is not, and despite his lofty stats, will NEVER be in the category of "Big Game" QB's.
This season was amazing for many reasons:
He had his best statistical season of his career, and his career is a great one.
He threw so few interceptions (A Favre specialty over the years) that many felt he had matured into a smart QB.
But let's be honest.
We all knew he would eventually make the bonehead play.
Forget about the other turnovers (including his other int).
Forget about the defense not holding the Saints in OT.
The Vikings were in position to WIN the game. It was their game to lose with under 30 seconds. Hell, under 20 seconds.
They were at the edge of FG distance.
But they F'd up coming back from a FRIGGIN TIME OUT.
12 men in the huddle? Are you ****ting me???
So the play relies on, gulp, Brett Favre to make a play that was conservative yet "good enough" to move 5 yards closer.
Well, at that point, they should have had Peterson receive a direct snap, because Bret is a LOT of things.
But he's not a smart QB, and he simply can not be conservative.
Even when his team needs him to be.